Scrapbook Alley Limited v Chow

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-454-141 [2012] NZHC 1635

IN THE MATTER OF     a Deed of Lease

BETWEEN  SCRAPBOOK ALLEY LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDDAN CHOW, FAI CHOW AND DAVID ALAN LEA

Defendants

Memoranda:  From Counsel for Defendants dated 30/05/12

From Counsel for Plaintiff dated 13/06/12

Counsel:         G.A. Paine - Counsel for Plaintiff

T. Manktelow - Counsel for Defendant

Judgment:      17 July 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment of Associate Judge Gendall was delivered by the Registrar on 17 July

2012 at 3.30 pm under r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors:           Bruce Andrews, Solicitors, PO Box 351, Palmerston North

Guy and Toby Manktelow, Solicitors, PO Box 12-091, Palmerston North

SCRAPBOOK ALLEY LIMITED V D CHOW, F CHOW AND DA LEA HC PMN CIV-2011-454-141 [17 July

2012]

Introduction

[1]      Before the Court are two applications.   The first is an application by the defendants to strike out certain causes of action in the claim brought against them by the plaintiff.  In the second application, also brought by the defendants, they seek an order for security for costs against the plaintiff.

[2]      Both applications are opposed by the plaintiff.

Background

[3]      The defendants are the owners of commercial premises located in a building situated at 88 Main Street, Paihiatua (the building).  They agreed to lease one shop (the premises), situated in and being a part of the building, to the plaintiff by Deed of Lease dated 17 February 2010 (the Lease).   The plaintiff then opened and began carrying out its scrap-booking material retailing business from the premises.

[4]      The Lease of the premises was for an initial term of 2 years commencing on 1

March 2010 at a rental of $5,200.00 plus GST per annum, with two further rights of renewal, each for three years.  The plaintiff also agreed under the Lease that it would pay twenty per cent of the total rates and insurance premiums for the defendants’ building.

[5]      Not long after the commencement of the Lease, on 23 May 2010, a fire broke out in the building.  It appears that the cause of the fire related to electrical faults in the  building,  which  occurred  outside  the  premises  leased  by the  plaintiff.    The premises, being that part of the building leased by the plaintiff, were substantially damaged by the fire.  In addition, the fire caused substantial damage to the plaintiff’s chattels, stock and plant in the plaintiff’s leased premises.  The plaintiff in its first amended statement of claim filed 18 October 2011 claims that this damage amounted to $62,661.67 (GST inclusive).

[6]      Subsequently, the defendants claimed that the fire had rendered the building (and the plaintiff’s leased premises) un-tenantable.   Therefore, the defendants purported to terminate the lease.

[7]      The plaintiff sought details of the insurance cover on the building and any insurance assessor’s reports in relation to the fire.  The defendants have advised that they forwarded the plaintiff’s requests to their insurance company.  Nevertheless, the plaintiff maintains that to date, the defendants have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scrapbook Alley Limited v Chow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 1635
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Scrapbook Alley Limited v Chow involves a dispute between a tenant (Scrapbook Alley Limited) and its landlords (Dan Chow, Fai Chow, and David Alan Lea) over damages caused by a fire that destroyed the tenant's shop within a leased building. The plaintiff, Scrapbook Alley Limited, filed claims for breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, conversion, trespass, nuisance, and a duty to prevent the escape of fire. The defendants applied to strike out certain causes of action and sought security for costs.

The court addressed the strike-out application, noting that the plaintiff's claims for breach of fiduciary duty and escape of fire were clearly untenable and were struck out. The fiduciary duty claim was dismissed because the court found that the landlord-tenant relationship did not create a fiduciary obligation. The escape of fire claim was also dismissed, as the court found that the defendants had contractually excluded liability for such losses. However, the claims for breach of contract, conversion, trespass, and nuisance were allowed to proceed as they raised complex issues requiring factual determination.

Regarding the security for costs application, the court found that the plaintiff had ceased trading, appeared to have no assets, and faced financial difficulties, including a dismissed bankruptcy application against its director. Despite these factors, the court decided not to grant security for costs, as it found that the plaintiff's impecuniosity was likely a result of the defendants' actions, which could make it unjust to impose security for costs on the plaintiff.

In summary, the court partially granted the strike-out application, dismissing the claims for breach of fiduciary duty and escape of fire, while allowing the claims for breach of contract, conversion, trespass, and nuisance to proceed. The application for security for costs was dismissed, and no order was made as to costs. The court encouraged the parties to seek a reasonable and sensible resolution to the dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established