IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TŪRANGANUI-A-KIWA ROHE
CIV-2015-416-26
[2019] NZHC 3111
BETWEEN RANDY YINGLING
Plaintiff
AND
KEN GIFFORD
First Defendant
DEAN WITTERS
Second Defendant
On the papers: Counsel:
G J Thwaite for Plaintiff
G R Webb for First Defendant
Judgment:
27 November 2019
JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J (COSTS)
Background
[1] By judgment dated 17 September 2019, I granted the first defendant’s application for an adjournment of civil proceedings that had been set down to commence on 18 September 2019.
[2] The basis for the application was that the first defendant had just changed solicitors (for the third time) and that his new solicitor needed to amend the pleadings.
[3] The granting of an adjournment in these circumstances was an indulgence, and I indicated that I would entertain an application for costs if the plaintiff wished to make one.
YINGLING v GIFFORD (COSTS) [2019] NZHC 3111 [27 November 2019]
[4] By memorandum dated 24 September 2019, counsel for the plaintiff sought costs of $17,925. This sum was calculated on the basis of full recovery of all of the preparation costs the plaintiff would have been able to claim had the hearing proceeded and the plaintiff being successful. On top of that, the plaintiff also sought an uplift of 50 per cent.
[5] The rationale for the claim for the entire preparation costs, plus a 50 per cent uplift is not entirely clear. However, the relevant parts of the plaintiff’s submissions appear to be the claims that:
Plaintiff’s preparation for the trial has been wasted. If a new Statement of Defence is filed, it will likely require a new approach by Plaintiff. Accordingly, Plaintiff seeks reasonable costs for preparation for the trial on the existing pleadings.
[6] The first part of the plaintiff’s submissions on costs traces the history of the plaintiff’s unsuccessful applications for summary judgment.1
[7] Subsequently in his memorandum, counsel for the plaintiff submits that “First Defendant has held off a final hearing on a Judgment for five calendar years.” This statement seems to be made in support of the application for costs.
[8] As I indicated in the 17 September 2019 judgment, given that over two and a half years of the delay were taken up with the plaintiff’s unsuccessful summary judgment and strike-out application, at least until 5 February 2018, the defendants cannot be blamed for any delay to this point.2
[9] The costs application that the Court anticipated in [30] and [31] of the 17 September 2019 decision related to the application for an adjournment and leave to file an amended statement of defence. It did not relate to the earlier interlocutory applications or the delays caused by them.
[10] By memorandum dated 1 October 2019, counsel for the defendant opposed the costs application. Among the grounds were that the work claimed for in the
1 The convoluted history of these proceedings is detailed in Yingling v Gifford [2019] NZHC 2342 at [1]-[14].
2 At [13].
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Yingling v Gifford and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 3111
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff was entitled to the full preparation costs claimed, including the 50% uplift, and whether the first defendant should be held accountable for the entire amount. The court considered the plaintiff's submissions and the history of unsuccessful applications for summary judgment and strike-out. The first defendant opposed the costs application, arguing that the work claimed might be appropriately regarded as costs in the proceeding and dealt with on finality, and that no basis had been given for the claimed 50% uplift.
The court held that while it has a discretion in relation to costs, the award of costs is usually related to the wasted costs, which are costs that will have to be incurred again in relation to preparation for the fresh fixture. The court found that the plaintiff's claim that preparation for the trial had been wasted was an exaggeration and that the actual wasted costs incurred by the plaintiff were likely to be relatively modest. Considering the first defendant had received an indulgence, the court awarded $2,000 to the plaintiff, payable by the first defendant.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi