Yingling v Gifford

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TŪRANGANUI-A-KIWA ROHE

CIV-2015-416-26

[2019] NZHC 2342

BETWEEN

RANDY YINGLING

Plaintiff

AND

KEN JOHN GIFFORD (aka KENNETH JOHN GIFFORD)

First Defendant

AND

DEAN JOHN WITTERS (aka DEAN JOHN WITTERS)

Second Defendant

Teleconference: 16 September 2019

Counsel:

G J Thwaite for Plaintiff

G R Webb for First Defendant

Judgment:

17 September 2019


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


Background

[1]        On 30 June 2015, the plaintiff filed a statement of claim against the first and second defendants in the High Court at Gisborne.

[2]        The statement of claim had five causes of action. The first and second causes of action sought enforcement of a judgment of the Superior Court of the State of California. After a hearing in California on 9 April 2012, at which neither the first or second defendants in these proceedings appeared, judgment was given for the plaintiff in the sum of US$232,500 compensatory damages, US$150,000 exemplary damages, and costs in the sum of US$395.

YINGLING v GIFFORD & ANOR [2019] NZHC 2342 [17 September 2019]

[3]        The third cause of action was a claim against the first and second defendants for breach of contract seeking judgment for commission in the sum of US$232,500, and the fourth cause of action sought the same sum as compensatory damages although the cause of action was pleaded as being “Common Counts”. Both the third and fourth causes of action pleaded that the judgment of the Superior Court in California created an estoppel against the first and second defendants.

[4]        The fifth cause of action was said to be “fraud under the law of California” and sought compensatory damages in the sum of US$232,500, and punitive damages of US$150,000 plus interest and costs.

[5]        The plaintiff also filed an application for summary judgment at the same time as the statement of claim was filed.

[6]        On 9 February 2016, Associate Judge Sargisson, on the first call of these proceedings, made a timetable order.

[7]        On 11 July 2016, following a hearing in the High Court at Gisborne on 3 May 2016, Associate Judge Sargisson dismissed the plaintiff’s application for summary judgment.

[8]        One of the ways by which a party can avoid the entry of a foreign judgment against them in a New Zealand court is to establish that the judgment was obtained by fraud. While the New Zealand courts are not able to re-examine the merits of a foreign judgment sought to be enforced here, where fraud is pleaded, effectively a defendant has an opportunity to invite the New Zealand court to examine the evidence upon which the foreign judgment was obtained.1

[9]        Here, the defendants had put in issue, the question of whether the Californian Court had been advised that the commission being claimed by the plaintiff related to sales which had not in fact occurred. As no evidence had been tendered by the plaintiff on this point, Associate Judge Sargisson found that the defendants had an arguable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yingling v Gifford and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 2342
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yingling v Gifford is a case where the plaintiff, Randy Yingling, sought to enforce a foreign judgment against the first and second defendants, Ken John Gifford and Dean John Witters, in the High Court of New Zealand. The California Superior Court had previously awarded Yingling US$232,500 in compensatory damages, US$150,000 in exemplary damages, and costs of US$395. Yingling filed a statement of claim with five causes of action, seeking enforcement of the Californian judgment, damages for breach of contract, and damages for fraud. The defendants argued that the Californian judgment was obtained by fraud and that the New Zealand court lacked jurisdiction over certain causes of action. The court had to decide whether the Californian judgment could be enforced in New Zealand and whether the court had jurisdiction over the additional causes of action.

The court found that the defendants had an arguable defence of fraud against the enforcement of the Californian judgment, as the commission claimed by Yingling related to sales that had not occurred. The court noted that while it could not re-examine the merits of the foreign judgment, it could consider evidence of fraud. The court also found that the defendants had not complied with the timetable order, and the plaintiff had made two unsuccessful applications for summary judgment. The court concluded that the defendants could not be blamed for delays in the proceedings due to the plaintiff's unsuccessful applications. The court rejected the defendants' application for security for costs but granted an adjournment to allow the first defendant to file an amended statement of defence. The court ordered that the first defendant must file an amended statement of defence within 10 working days and that the plaintiff must file a reply within 10 working days of service. The court also set out detailed directions for filing evidence and allocating a fixture for the hearing of the substantive matter. The court warned that costs may be awarded if the plaintiff sought an award of costs against the first defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established