Marley New Zealand Ltd v Skellerup Rubber Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-001857 [2013] NZHC 3040

BETWEEN  MARLEY NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSKELLERUP RUBBER SERVICES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing:                   (On the papers)

Counsel:                  J R Billington QC, R M Gapes and J W S Baigent for Plaintiff

J E Hodder QC and J W J Graham for Defendant

Judgment:                18 November 2013

COSTS JUDGMENT OF VENNING J

This judgment was delivered by me on 18 November 2013 at 12.15 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the

High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Simpson Grierson, Auckland

Chapman Tripp, Auckland

Copy to:            J R Billington QC, Auckland

J E Hodder QC, Wellington

MARLEY NZ LTD v SKELLERUP RUBBER SERVICES LTD [2013] NZHC 3040 [18 November 2013]

Introduction

[1]      In a minute issued on 24 October 2013, I confirmed the adjournment of the fixture in this case which had been scheduled for four weeks to commence on 30

October 2013.  At Marley’s request the fixture was vacated for the reasons set out in that minute.  Costs were reserved to be dealt with by way of exchange of memoranda on the basis that, as a condition of the adjournment, Marley was to pay a contribution to Skellerup’s wasted costs of preparation of both its legal advisers and experts.

The costs sought

[2]      Skellerup now seeks costs in the sum of $34,447.69 calculated as follows:

Wasted legal costs (50% allowance)  $25,000.00

Costs on the application to adjourn  $3,084.50

Disbursements on the application  $95.65

Wasted expert disbursements (50% allowance)  $4,684.78

Wasted airfare and accommodation  $1,582.76

Total:  $34,447.69

Marley’s response

[3]      In the reply memorandum filed for Marley, counsel confirms that Marley accepts the costs and disbursements on the application to adjourn, the figures for wasted  experts’ disbursements,  wasted  airfare and accommodation  and  does  not dispute those sums.  However, Marley takes issue with the claim for $25,000 for 50 per cent of the wasted legal costs.

Skellerup’s argument

[4]      Skellerup supports the claim for $25,000 in the following way.  Skellerup’s actual legal costs for the period between 8 October and 23 October, being between finalisation of its briefs and the granting of the adjournment, were in excess of

$90,000 excluding GST and disbursements.   For a period of 10 working days Skellerup’s actual legal costs were around $9,000 a day.   On that basis counsel submits that Skellerup would potentially lose around $45,000 if one-half of the costs are wasted as a result of the adjournment with the required duplication of effort to gear up again for trial at a later date.

[5]      Mr Hodder submits that the High Court scale costs do not adequately reflect the intensity of preparation for a long and complex  trial, noting that calculated variously between a 2B basis through to a 3C basis, the resultant costs are between

$9,950 and $26,460.  He submits that 3C categorisation of approximately $26,460 is most realistic.

[6]      Fifty per cent of these figures and Skellerup’s actual costs produces a range of between $4,975 to $45,000.  The mid-point is approximately…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marley New Zealand Ltd v Skellerup Rubber Services Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was called upon to determine the costs incurred by Skellerup Rubber Services Limited as a result of the adjournment of a scheduled four-week trial against Marley New Zealand Limited. The case, Marley New Zealand Ltd v Skellerup Rubber Services Ltd, was adjourned at Marley’s request, and as a condition of this adjournment, Marley was required to contribute to Skellerup’s wasted costs of preparation. Skellerup sought costs totalling $34,447.69, including wasted legal costs, costs on an application to adjourn, disbursements, and wasted expert disbursements, airfare, and accommodation. Marley contested the $25,000 claim for 50% of wasted legal costs, arguing that the case should be categorised as a category 2 matter, which would result in a lower wasted costs figure.

The legal issues before the court were whether the court should adopt a 50% allowance for wasted legal costs based on Skellerup’s actual legal costs or whether the scale costs under the High Court Rules were sufficient. Skellerup argued that a 50% uplift on a 3C basis was appropriate, given the intensity of preparation for the trial, while Marley contended that the case should be categorised as a category 2 matter, resulting in a lower figure for wasted costs. The court had to decide on the appropriate method of calculating wasted costs in the context of an unexpectedly adjourned trial.

The court concluded that the circumstances of the case warranted a departure from the standard 50% allowance for wasted costs. The court recognised the significant preparation undertaken by Skellerup for a four-week trial involving a claim of over $7 million and expert evidence. The adjournment was granted reluctantly due to Marley’s failure to appreciate an issue flagged by Skellerup. The court found that a 50% allowance for wasted costs, even on a 3C basis, was insufficient to reflect the inconvenience and wasted costs incurred by Skellerup. The court determined that a contribution to the wasted legal costs in the sum of $25,000 as sought by Skellerup was appropriate in the particular circumstances of the case.

The court ordered that Marley New Zealand Limited pay Skellerup Rubber Services Limited costs in the sum of $34,447.69. This decision recognised the exceptional nature of the circumstances leading to the adjournment and the significant preparation undertaken by Skellerup, justifying an increased costs award.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established