Broadhurst v Broadhurst

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-000441 [2016] NZHC 3102

BETWEEN

JACQUELINE HELEN BROADHURST

Applicant

AND

MARK HARTLEY BROADHURST First Respondent

AND

MAUREEN BROADHURST AND ALAN BROWN

Second Respondents

AND

ORCHID LTD Third Respondent

AND

CHERUB CHOIR LTD Fourth Respondent

AND

LEMON LTD Fifth Respondent

AND

GARDENIA LTD Sixth Respondent

Contd…

Hearing: 14 December 2016

Appearances:

T Rainey for Applicant
K P McDonald for First and Second Respondents
R J Collis for Third to Ninth Respondents
A Steele for non-party Mr R Smith

Judgment:

16 December 2016

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie

On 16 December 2016 at 2.00pm Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:…………………………

BROADHURST v BROADHURST [2016] NZHC 3102 [16 December 2016]

AND

HARTLEY INVESTMENTS LTD

Seventh Respondent

AND

IN THE PARK LTD Eighth Respondent

AND

MINT ADVISORS TRUSTEES-BRUTUS LTD and 12A TRUSTEE CO LTD

Ninth Respondents

Solicitors:

Rainey Law, Auckland

Kevin McDonald & Associates, Takapuna
Martelli McKegg, Auckland

Counsel:

R J Collis, Auckland

Introduction

[1]      The first and second respondents seek costs against the applicant’s previous solicitor, Mr Rod Smith, either on an indemnity basis, or in such an amount as the Court shall order.   Costs are sought because of Mr Smith’s repeated failures to comply with various timetable orders. This resulted in a 12 day fixture, due to commence on 7 November 2016, being adjourned.

[2]      The proceeding has recently settled as between the parties.   It has not yet been discontinued.  It has been adjourned to 24 April 2017 so that the settlement can be completed.

[3]      Costs have been resolved between the respondents and the applicant.   The respondents were, however, granted leave by the Court to pursue a costs application against Mr Smith personally.

Factual background

[4]      Mr Smith acted for the applicant from the outset, and in October 2010 he commenced the proceedings in the Family Court.

[5]      Mr and Mrs Broadhurst had been in a relationship.  It commenced in about

1993 and they married in 1995.   They separated in 2010 and their marriage was dissolved in 2014.  Through the proceedings they were seeking to untangle complex property dealings in which they had been involved during their relationship.

[6]      The proceedings were transferred to this Court in March 2015 by order of Judge J H Walker.1   It is noteworthy that one of the concerns raised by Judge Walker was the inability of the District Court to enforce compliance and the lack of case

management of the file.

1      Broadhurst v Broadhurst [2015] NZDC 1531.

[7]      The proceedings became subject to case management in this Court from the outset. Associate Judge Bell made a series of orders designed to get the matter ready for a prompt hearing.2

[8]      Mr Smith immediately breached the timetable directions made by this Court. He was directed to file a statement of claim in this Court within 10 days from 13

March 2015.  He did not do so.  The statement of claim was not filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broadhurst v Broadhurst and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 3102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Broadhurst v Broadhurst is a case concerning a claim for costs against an applicant's previous solicitor, Mr Rod Smith, following repeated failures to comply with various timetable orders. The court was required to decide whether the respondents should be awarded costs on an indemnity basis, or in such an amount as the court shall order. The court also had to determine the quantum of the costs award, if any, and whether an uplift on scale costs was appropriate.

The court held that the respondents were entitled to an award of costs against Mr Smith. The court found that Mr Smith's conduct had contributed unnecessarily to the expense of the proceeding, and that an uplift in scale costs was appropriate. The court awarded the first and second respondents scale costs of $4,906, uplifted by 50 per cent to make a total costs award of $7,359. The court also directed that Mr Smith is to pay 50 per cent of the expert's fee, a total sum of $5,103.12. The total award of costs and disbursements against Mr Smith in favour of the first and second respondents jointly was $12,462.12. The third to ninth respondents were awarded jointly the sum of $1,750.00.

In summary, the court held that Mr Smith's repeated failures to comply with timetable orders resulted in wasted costs for the respondents, and that an award of costs against Mr Smith was appropriate. The court found that an uplift on scale costs was justified, and awarded costs accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established