VPCL Trustees Limited v Tasman District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV-2010-442-518 [2014] NZHC 752

BETWEEN

VPCL TRUSTEES LIMITED

First Plaintiff

HEARTLAND BANK LIMITED Second Plaintiff

AND

TASMAN DISTRICT COUNCIL Defendant

Hearing:

7 - 11 October 2013

(Heard at Wellington)

Appearances:

No appearance for the first plaintiff
R M Dunningham for the second plaintiff
J C Ironside, D J Russ and A A Woodhouse for the defendant

Judgment:

14 April 2014

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J

Solicitors:

Buddle Findlay, Christchurch for the second plaintiff. Fletcher Vautier Moore, Richmond for the defendant.

VPCL TRUSTEES LTD and ANOR v TASMAN DISTRICT COUNCIL [2014] NZHC 752 [14 April 2014]

CONTENTS

Introduction ............................................................................................................. [1] Evidence ................................................................................................................... [6] The planning context ............................................................................................ [10]

The Lot 22 dispute

The facts ........................................................................................................ [20] The Lot 22 Deed ............................................................................................ [29] Subsequent events ......................................................................................... [32] Mr Wootton’s valuations ............................................................................... [40]

VPCL’s claims against TDC for moneys owing under the Deed in

respect of Lot 22 ............................................................................................ [47]

The law .......................................................................................................... [51]

Analysis

The valuation date ................................................................................ [56] The “zoning” dispute ........................................................................... [59] The “market valuation” issue .............................................................. [70]

The Lot 24 dispute

The facts ........................................................................................................ [86]

VPCL’s claim – analysis ............................................................................... [93]

Result and costs ................................................................................................... [104]

Introduction

[1]      In August 2009 the defendant, Tasman District Council (TDC), granted the first plaintiff, VPCL Trustees Limited (VPCL), consent to subdivide some 10 ha of land adjacent to the town of Richmond in the Tasman district (the Property).

[2]      This is a dispute about:

(a)      the meaning of a deed between VPCL and TDC (the Deed) setting the price to be paid to VPCL by TDC for some 1.6 ha of the Property (Lot 22)  acquired  by  TDC  for  drainage  reserve  purposes  as  a condition of that subdivision consent (the Lot 22 dispute); and

(b)the application of a rule in TDC’s Tasman Resource Management Plan (the TRMP) which determines the compensation to be paid to VPCL by TDC for a further 0.55 ha of the Property (Lot 24) acquired by TDC similarly for recreation reserve (tree protection) purposes (the Lot 24 dispute).

[3]      VPCL says TDC owes it a total of $2,052,500: $1,480,000 for Lot 22 and

$572,500 for Lot 24.  TDC admits it owes VPCL some money for Lot 22.  It says the amount owing may be as little as $120,000.  TDC denies owing VPCL any money for Lot 24.

[4]      The second plaintiff, Heartland Bank Limited (Heartland), is the successor to VPCL’s  original  funder  Ashburton  Building  Society.     It  is  a  party  to  these proceedings as assignee of VPCL’s rights against TDC.  Heartland being a party does not alter the nature of VPCL’s claims against TDC.  Nor does Heartland make any claim in its own right.  There is therefore no need to refer to Heartland again in this judgment, save as regards any relief that might be ordered.

[5]      In this judgment I first set out the context of the Lot 22 and Lot 24 disputes provided by TDC’s planning rules as contained in the TRMP as it developed over time.  I then…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VPCL Trustees Limited v Tasman District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 752
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Vice President Clifford heard a dispute between VPCL Trustees Limited and the Tasman District Council regarding the compensation owed by the council for land acquired for drainage and tree protection purposes. The case hinged on the interpretation of a deed between the parties and the application of the council's planning rules. VPCL claimed that the council owed it $2,052,500 in total, $1,480,000 for Lot 22 and $572,500 for Lot 24. The council admitted owing VPCL some money for Lot 22, possibly as little as $120,000, but denied owing any money for Lot 24.

The court held that the council was indebted to VPCL in the sum of $1,480,000 for Lot 22, together with interest from when that amount became payable. The court found that the valuer appointed by both parties had correctly valued Lot 22 according to the terms of the deed, which required the land to be valued as if it were part of the subdivision. The court dismissed VPCL's claim for compensation for Lot 24, holding that the council had obtained a market valuation of the land as required by its planning rules.

The court reserved the question of costs but indicated that category B costs at 75 per cent of the scheduled rate would be appropriate, given VPCL's partial success in the case. The parties were given time to submit their views on costs, with a limit of five pages per party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.