Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2011-404-007233

CIV2012-404-005249 [2013] NZHC 507

IN THE MATTER OF     appeals pursuant to the Land Valuation

Proceedings Act 1946

BETWEEN  GREEN & MCCAHILL HOLDINGS LIMITED

Appellant

ANDAUCKLAND COUNCIL (AS SUCCESSOR TO RODNEY DISTRICT COUNCIL)

Respondent

Hearing:         27 & 28 February 2013

Counsel:         A R Galbraith QC and J Collinge for the Appellant

R B Lange for the Respondent

Judgment:      26 March 2013

[RESERVED] JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J and

MR G J HORSLEY

This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie and Mr G J Horsley on 26 March 2013 at 3.00 pm

Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

Distribution:
A Galbraith QC:  argalbraith@shortlandchambers.co.nz

R Lange: richard.lange@simpsongrierson.com

GREEN & MCCAHILL HOLDINGS LIMITED V AUCKLAND COUNCIL (AS SUCCESSOR TO RODNEY DISTRICT COUNCIL) HC AK CIV 2011-404-007233 [26 March 2013]

INDEX

Paragraph Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] Factual Background ...............................................................................................[3]

The Land ......................................................................................................[3] The Acquisition/Taking.................................................................................[8] The Compensation Application ..................................................................[13] The Tribunal’s 2006 Decision ....................................................................[19] Amended Compensation Application by GMH ..........................................[23] The Tribunal’s 2011 Decision ....................................................................[24] The Costs Judgment ...................................................................................[31] Penlink .......................................................................................................[32]

The Notice of Appeal ...........................................................................................[33] Nature of Appeal ..................................................................................................[35] The Submissions ..................................................................................................[39] Analysis ................................................................................................................[45] Issue Estoppel ............................................................................................[46]

Compensation under s 62 of the Public Works Act ....................................[52] The Exceptions — Section 62(1)(b)(i) and (ii)...........................................[63] What state of affairs is assumed in the after valuation? ............................[67] Betterment ..................................................................................................[75] Summary in relation to applicable valuation principles............................[85]

The Valuers.................................................................................................[87] (i)    Mr Roberts .....................................................................................[88] (ii)  Mr Gamby......................................................................................[92] (iii) Mr Dean ........................................................................................[93] (iv)  Mr Smithies ....................................................................................[94]

Summary in relation to approaches of valuers ..........................................[95] Remedy ................................................................................................................[98] The Costs Decision ............................................................................................[100] Conclusion..........................................................................................................[102] Costs of this appeal ............................................................................................[104]

Introduction

[1]      Green & McCahill Holdings Limited (“GMH”) appeals two decisions of the

Land Valuation Tribunal:

a)       In the first decision dated 19 October 2011,1 the Tribunal held that no compensation is payable to GMH for the compulsory acquisition of

33.3522 hectares of its land, because there is betterment to the balance of GMH’s land that exceeds the value of the land taken.

b)In the second decision dated 22 August 2012,2  the Tribunal awarded costs and disbursements of $180,046.42 to the respondent, Auckland Council, as successor to the Rodney District Council, (“the Council”).

[2]      The  appeals  raise  issues  as  to  the  appropriate  valuation  principles  to  be applied   when   assessing   compensation   under   s   62(1)(b)(ii)   and   (e)   of   the Public Works Act 1981.  In particular, they ask what factual state of affairs is to be assumed in assessing the compensation (if any) payable to a claimant.

Factual Background

The Land

[3]      GMH is  the  owner of  a large  area of  coastal  land situated between  the Weiti River   and   Okura   River   Estuary,   immediately   to   the   south   of   the Whangaparaoa Peninsula.    Much  of  the  land  is  comprised  in  certificate  of  title

80D/150.  Prior to the taking of part of that land by the Council, the title comprised a

total of 888.3613 hectares.

1      Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd v Rodney District Council [2011] NZLVT 1, LVP 012/04, 19

October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 507
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Green & McCahill Holdings Limited (“GMH”) appealed two decisions of the Land Valuation Tribunal in relation to the compulsory acquisition of 33.3522 hectares of its land for the construction of Penlink. The Tribunal held that no compensation was payable because there was betterment to the balance of GMH’s land that exceeded the value of the land taken. The Tribunal also awarded costs of $180,046.42 to the respondent, Auckland Council, as successor to the Rodney District Council (“the Council”). GMH argued that the Tribunal misapplied the statutory provisions governing the assessment of compensation, and that it was not entitled to assume the existence of the Penlink road for the purposes of the after valuation. The Court agreed with GMH, holding that the Tribunal had erred in law and fact. It was not entitled to assume the existence of the Penlink road, and it was necessary to prove any betterment caused by the prospect of the work. The Court set aside the Tribunal’s 2011 decision, and referred GMH’s claim for compensation back to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The Court also set aside the Tribunal’s costs decision, and remitted the issue of costs to the Tribunal for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established