Trans-Tasman Resources Ltd v Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA573/2018
 [2020] NZCA 86

BETWEEN

TRANS-TASMAN RESOURCES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

TARANAKI-WHANGANUI CONSERVATION BOARD,
CLOUDY BAY CLAMS LIMITED,
FISHERIES INSHORE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED,
GREENPEACE OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED,
KIWIS AGAINST SEABED MINING INCORPORATED,
NEW ZEALAND FEDERATION OF
COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN INCORPORATED,
SOUTHERN INSHORE FISHERIES
MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED,
TALLEY’S GROUP LIMITED,
TE OHU KAI MOANA TRUSTEE
LIMITED,
TE RŪNANGA O NGĀTI RUANUI
TRUST,
THE ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD
PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED AND
THE TRUSTEES OF TE KAHUI O
RAURU TRUST
First Respondents

AND

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AUTHORITY
Second Respondent

Hearing:

24–26 September 2019

Court:

Kós P, Courtney and Goddard JJ

Counsel:

J B M Smith QC and V N Morrison-Shaw for Appellant
J D K Gardner-Hopkins for Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board
R A Makgill and P D M Tancock for Cloudy Bay Clams Ltd, Fisheries Inshore New Zealand Ltd, New Zealand Federation of Commercial Fishermen Inc, Southern Inshore Fisheries Management Co Ltd, Talley’s Group Ltd
D M Salmon, D A C Bullock and D E J Currie for Greenpeace New Zealand Inc and Kiwis Against Seabed Mining Inc
R J B Fowler QC and H K Irwin-Easthope for Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd
R J B Fowler QC and J Inns for Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Ruanui Trust
M C Smith and H E McQueen for The Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Inc
R J B Fowler QC and N R Coates for Te Kahui o Rauru Trust
V E Casey QC and C J Haden for Second Respondent

Judgment:

3 April 2020 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.  The High Court’s decision to allow the first respondents’ appeal and quash the decision of the Decision-making Committee is upheld on other grounds.

B        In so far as the first respondents’ cross-appeal seeks the appellant’s application for a marine consent and marine discharge consent to be declined, that cross-appeal is dismissed. 

CThe appellant’s application is referred back to the Environmental Protection Authority to be considered in light of this judgment.

DWe award costs as follows:

(a)We award one set of costs to Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Ruanui Trust, the Trustees of Te Kahui o Rauru Trust, Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd, Cloudy Bay Clams Ltd, Fisheries Inshore New Zealand Ltd, New Zealand Federation of Commercial Fishermen Inc, Southern Inshore Fisheries Management Co Ltd, Talley’s Group Ltd and the Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board for a complex appeal on a band B basis.  We certify for two counsel with usual disbursements.

(b)We award costs to The Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Inc for a complex appeal on a band B basis, for one counsel only, with usual disbursements.

(c)We award one set of costs to Kiwis Against Seabed Mining Inc and Greenpeace of New Zealand Inc for a complex appeal on a band B basis, for one counsel only, with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

Table of Contents

Para…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trans-Tasman Resources Ltd v Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trans-Tasman Resources Ltd (TTR) sought a marine discharge consent to carry out seabed mining activities within New Zealand's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). The Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board (TWCB) was involved in the dispute as a party concerned with the environmental impacts of TTR's proposed activities. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand. The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation and application of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 (EEZ Act) provisions, particularly concerning the granting of marine discharge consents and the consideration of environmental effects both within New Zealand and beyond its territorial waters. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) was required to consider the effects of TTR's activities outside of New Zealand's territorial jurisdiction, and if the EPA could rely on adaptive management approaches in granting consents.

The court examined the statutory framework of the EEZ Act, noting that Section 87F precludes the use of adaptive management conditions in marine discharge consents. Section 59 outlines the mandatory considerations the EPA must take into account when determining an application for a marine consent. The court held that while Section 59 lists numerous environmental and socio-economic factors, it does not provide specific decision-making criteria for the EPA. Moreover, the court found that the statutory definition of "existing interest" in Section 4 does not explicitly mandate the consideration of activities outside New Zealand's territorial jurisdiction. The court further clarified that the EPA must consider the effects of proposed activities within the EEZ, including those that may impact areas beyond New Zealand’s jurisdiction.

The court ruled in favour of TTR, finding that the EPA was not statutorily required to consider the potential effects of seabed mining activities outside New Zealand's territorial waters when assessing TTR's application for a marine discharge consent. Additionally, the court determined that the statutory provisions did not mandate the use of adaptive management approaches in granting consents. Consequently, the court found that the EPA's decision to refuse TTR's application was not based on a proper interpretation of the EEZ Act. The court's decision thus allowed for a reassessment of TTR's application, taking into account the proper statutory considerations and limitations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 87F expressly precludes the possibility of granting marine discharge consents or marine dumping consents on the basis of conditions amounting to an adaptive management approach. It provides:87F Decision on application for marine discharge consent or marine dumping consent(1) After complying with sections 87D and 87E, the Environmental Protection Authority may—(a) grant an application for a marine discharge consent or a marine dumping consent, in whole or in part, and issue a consent; or(b) refuse the application.(2) However, the EPA must refuse an application for a marine dumping consent if—(a) the EPA considers that the waste or other matter may be reused, recycled, or treated without—(i) adverse effects on human health or the environment that are more than minor; or(ii) imposing costs on the applicant that are unreasonable in the circumstances; or(b) the waste or other matter is identified in such a way that it is not possible to assess the potential effects of dumping the waste or other matter on human health or the environment; or(c) the EPA considers that dumping the waste or other matter is not the best approach to the disposal of the waste or other matter in the circumstances.(3) To avoid doubt, the EPA may refuse an application for a marine discharge consent or a marine dumping consent if the EPA considers that it does not have adequate information to determine the application.(4) If the EPA grants the application, it may issue the consent subject to conditions under section 63, but not under section 63(2)(b). The conditions referred to in s 63(2)(b), which by virtue of s 87F(4) may not be included in a marine discharge consent or marine dumping consent, are conditions which “together amount or contribute to an adaptive management approach”. Adaptive management is not permitted in the marine dumping or discharge context. Section 87G provides for the application to marine dumping consents and marine discharge consents of ss 65 to 67, which relate to conditions (including conditions relating to bonds), and ss 68 to 72, which address a number of ancillary matters in relation to consents. Subpart 3 of pt 3 is concerned with marine consents for cross-boundary activities, which are defined as activities that are carried out partly in the EEZ or in or on the Continental Shelf, and partly in New Zealand.[36] The seabed mining activities that TTR proposes to carry out are not cross boundary activities as defined, as they would be carried out solely within the EEZ. But as noted above, the effects of those activities will occur to a significant extent within the CMA. We return to this topic at paragraph [111] below.[36]Section 88. Before leaving this review of relevant provisions of the EEZ Act, we note that s 105 provides for appeals on a question of law from a decision of the EPA. Section 113 provides for appeals from the High Court to this Court as if the decision had been made under s 300 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011. In light of this review of the relevant provisions of the EEZ Act, we turn to some key elements of the approach that the EPA was required to adopt when making decisions in respect of TTR’s application for a marine discharge consent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A number of the provisions that are at the heart of this appeal are set out under the sub-heading “Decisions”. Section 59 identifies a number of mandatory relevant considerations in relation to the determination of an application for a marine consent. The relevant limbs of s 59 provide as follows:59Environmental Protection Authority’s consideration of application(1) This section and sections 60 and 61 apply when the Environmental Protection Authority is considering an application for a marine consent and submissions on the application.(2) The EPA must take into account—(a) any effects on the environment or existing interests of allowing the activity, including—(i) cumulative effects; and(ii) effects that may occur in New Zealand or in the waters above or beyond the continental shelf beyond the outer limits of the exclusive economic zone; and(b) the effects on the environment or existing interests of other activities undertaken in the area covered by the application or in its vicinity, including—(i)the effects of activities that are not regulated under this Act; and (ii) effects that may occur in New Zealand or in the waters above or beyond the continental shelf beyond the outer limits of the exclusive economic zone; and(c) the effects on human health that may arise from effects on the environment; and(d) the importance of protecting the biological diversity and integrity of marine species, ecosystems, and processes; and(e) the importance of protecting rare and vulnerable ecosystems and the habitats of threatened species; and(f) the economic benefit to New Zealand of allowing the application; and(g) the efficient use and development of natural resources; and(h) the nature and effect of other marine management regimes; and(i) best practice in relation to an industry or activity; and(j) the extent to which imposing conditions under section 63 might avoid, remedy, or mitigate the adverse effects of the activity; and(k) relevant regulations; and(l) any other applicable law; and(m) any other matter the EPA considers relevant and reasonably necessary to determine the application.(3) The EPA must have regard to—(a) any submissions made and evidence given in relation to the application; and(b) any advice, reports, or information it has sought and received in relation to the application; and(c) any advice received from the Māori Advisory Committee.… Although s 59 identifies the key factors that are relevant to consideration of an application for a marine consent, it does not set out any decision-making criteria for the EPA to apply when determining that application. We return to this point below. The term “existing interest” used in s 59(2) is defined in s 4 as follows:existing interest means, in relation to New Zealand, the exclusive economic zone, or the continental shelf (as applicable), the interest a person has in—(a)any lawfully established existing activity, whether or not authorised by or under any Act or regulations, including rights of access, navigation, and fishing:(b)any activity that may be undertaken under the authority of an existing marine consent granted under section 62:(c)any activity that may be undertaken under the authority of an existing resource consent granted under the Resource Management Act 1991:(d)the settlement of a historical claim under the Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975:(e)the settlement of a contemporary claim under the Treaty of Waitangi as provided for in an Act, including the Treaty of Waitangi (Fisheries Claims) Settlement Act 1992:(f)a protected customary right or customary marine title recognised under the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011