Trans-Tasman Resources Limited v Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 28/2020
 [2022] NZSC 63
BETWEEN

TRANS-TASMAN RESOURCES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

TARANAKI-WHANGANUI CONSERVATION BOARD,
CLOUDY BAY CLAMS LIMITED, FISHERIES INSHORE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED,
GREENPEACE OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED,
KIWIS AGAINST SEABED MINING INCORPORATED,
NEW ZEALAND FEDERATION OF COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN INCORPORATED,
SOUTHERN INSHORE FISHERIES
MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED,
TALLEY’S GROUP LIMITED,
TE OHU KAI MOANA TRUSTEE LIMITED,
TE RŪNANGA O NGĀTI RUANUI TRUST,
ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED AND
THE TRUSTEES OF TE KĀHUI O RAURU TRUST
First Respondents

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY
Second Respondent

Court:

Winkelmann CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, Ellen France and Williams JJ

Counsel:

J B M Smith QC and V N Morrison-Shaw for Appellant
J D K Gardner-Hopkins for Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board


R A Makgill and P D M Tancock for Cloudy Bay Clams Ltd, Fisheries Inshore New Zealand Ltd, New Zealand Federation of Commercial Fishermen Inc, Southern Inshore Fisheries Management Co Ltd and Talley’s Group Ltd
D M Salmon QC, D A C Bullock and D E J Currie for Greenpeace of New Zealand Inc and Kiwis Against Seabed Mining Inc
R J B Fowler QC, J Inns, H K Irwin-Easthope and N R Coates for Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd, Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Ruanui Trust and the Trustees of Te Kāhui o Rauru Trust
M C Smith, H E McQueen and P D Anderson for Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Inc

Judgment:

19 May 2022

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appellant must pay costs of $155,000 plus usual disbursements, to be fixed by the Registrar if necessary.  We allow for second counsel.

BThe costs awards made in the Court of Appeal stand.

CThe High Court should now determine costs in that Court in light of this Court’s judgment dismissing the appeal.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS
(Given by Ellen France J)

Introduction

  1. In a judgment delivered on 30 September 2021, the Court dismissed an appeal brought by Trans‑Tasman Resources Ltd (TTR).[1]  The judgment addressed issues arising from TTR’s application for marine consents and marine discharge consents to undertake seabed mining within New Zealand’s exclusive economic zone.  We reserved costs and sought submissions from the parties if agreement could not be reached.[2] 

    [2]At [233]–[235] per William Young and Ellen France JJ, [237] per Glazebrook J, [300] per Williams J and [333] per Winkelmann CJ.

  2. Submissions for the parties have now been received.  Those submissions raise the following issues:

    (a)Should we make an order for costs or should costs lie where they fall?

    (b)If costs are awarded, what awards should be made?

    (c)Should the Court direct the Court of Appeal to revisit its costs orders?

  3. We deal with each of the three outstanding issues in turn.  In doing so, we note that for these purposes the first respondents have formed three groupings.  The first of these groupings, which we…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trans-Tasman Resources Limited v Taranaki-Whanganui Conserva... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZSC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trans-Tasman Resources Limited, an appellant, brought an appeal against the Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board, Cloudy Bay Clams Limited, Fisheries Inshore New Zealand Limited, Greenpeace of New Zealand Incorporated, Kiwis Against Seabed Mining Incorporated, New Zealand Federation of Commercial Fishermen Incorporated, Southern Inshore Fisheries Management Company Limited, Talley’s Group Limited, Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Limited, Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Ruanui Trust, the Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated, and the Trustees of Te Kāhui o Rauru Trust, the first respondents, and the Environmental Protection Authority, the second respondent, in the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The appeal arose from the appellant's application for marine consents and marine discharge consents to undertake seabed mining within New Zealand’s exclusive economic zone. The Court dismissed the appeal in a judgment delivered on 30 September 2021. The Court reserved costs and sought submissions from the parties if agreement could not be reached. The issues to be decided were whether the Court should make an order for costs or whether costs should lie where they fall, what awards should be made if costs are awarded, and whether the Court should direct the Court of Appeal to revisit its costs orders. The Court decided that costs should follow the event in the usual way and awarded $155,000 plus usual disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar if necessary. The Court allowed for second counsel and made no direction in relation to the costs awards in the Court of Appeal. The High Court should now determine costs in that Court in light of this Court’s judgments.

The Court's reasoning was that the appellant had some limited success in that the Court upheld its position in relation to a number of matters, but that the underlying issues were difficult and finely balanced. The litigation had a public interest element and the appeal resulted in principles of significance, but the Court accepted the submissions for the first respondents that costs should follow the event in the usual way. To the extent the appellant had some limited success, that success can be factored into the sums awarded. The Court's general approach is to make awards of costs which are a reasonable contribution to the costs actually incurred although retaining a discretion to make a higher award if that is considered just. The Court calculated the daily rate for preparation time by reference to the highest daily rate applicable under the High Court Rules and extrapolated from the High Court Rules, $3,800 reflects an appropriate daily rate. The Court discounted that figure by around 10 per cent to a total figure of $155,000 plus usual disbursements to reflect, first, the indication in the Court's substantive judgment that full recovery would result in over-recovery and, second, that there were some issues on which the appellant's view prevailed. The Court left it to the first respondents to allocate the sum of $155,000 as between themselves. The Court did not consider it necessary to confine the number of counsel or to otherwise depart from the orthodoxy which is that the successful party is entitled to recover usual disbursements to be determined by the Registrar if necessary. The Court agreed with Forest and Bird and KASM/Greenpeace that there was no basis for reconsidering the costs awards in the Court of Appeal. The Court made an order that the High Court, which has not yet awarded costs, should determine costs in light of this Court’s decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established