Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board v Environmental Protection Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE

CIV-2017-485-704

[2018] NZHC 2217

UNDER the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012

IN THE MATTER OF

an appeal under s 105

BETWEEN

THE TARANAKI-WHANGANUI CONSERVATION BOARD CLOUDY BAY CLAMS LIMITED FISHERIES INSHORE NZ LIMITED

GREENPEACE OF NEW ZEALAND INC KIWIS AGAINST SEABED MINING INC NEW ZEALAND FEDERATION OF

COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN INC SOUTHERN INSHORE FISHERIES

MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED TALLEY’S GROUP LIMITED

TE OHU KAI MOANA TRUSTEE LIMITED

TE RUNANGA O NGĀTI RUANUI TRUST

THE ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NZ INC

THE TRUSTEES OF TE KĀHUI O RAURU

Appellants

AND

THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY

First Respondent

TRANS-TASMAN RESOURCES LIMITED

Second Respondent

Hearing: 16-20 April 2018

Counsel:

J D Gardner-Hopkins for The Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board

THE TARANAKI-WHANGANUI CONSERVATION BOARD v THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY [2018] NZHC 2217 [28 August 2018]

F M R Cooke QC, R A Makgill, J L Inns and H K Irwin-Easthope

for Cloudy Bay Clams Limited, Fisheries Inshore NZ Limited, NZ Federation of Commercial Fishermen Inc,

Southern Inshore Fisheries Management Company Limited, Talleys Group Limited, Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Limited, Te Runanga o Ngāti Ruanui Trust and The Trustees of

Te Kāhui o Rauru

D Salmon, D A C Bullock and D Currie for Greenpeace of NZ Inc and Kiwis Against Seabed Mining Inc

M C Smith, H E McQueen and P D Anderson for Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of NZ Inc

V Casey QC and C J Haden for The Environmental Protection Authority

J B M Smith QC, M J Slyfield and V N Morrison-Shaw for Trans-Tasman Resources Limited

Judgment:

28 August 2018


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


TABLE OF CONTENTS

The consents  [4]

Approach to appeals  [7]

The application  [10]

Issues on appeal  [18]

Should the EPA have returned the application as incomplete?  [45]

What are the relevant purposes of the EEZ Act?  [70]

Legislative history relating to discharges  [70]

Purpose  [90]

The appellants’ argument  [106]

Analysis  [117]

Other marine management regimes  [122]

Analysis  [153]

International law obligations  [163]

Section 59(2)(f) – economic benefit  [178]

Did the DMC properly assess the effects on existing interests correctly?  [192]

Were only physical effects on the existing interests of iwi considered?  [195]

Was a cultural impact assessment by tangata whenua necessary?  [206]

Did the DMC need to consider claims of customary title under MACA?  [229]

What is the relevance of New Zealand’s obligations under UNDRIP?  [234]

Was proper regard given to the Treaty of Waitangi?  [238] Did the DMC apply the information principles correctly?  [244] Did the DMC make “full use of its powers”?  [252]

Was the impact assessment adequate?  [265]

Did the DMC act on the best information available?  [276]

Analysis  [297]

Was there a lack of information on the proposal’s impacts?  [300] Did the DMC err in failing to consider requiring a bond for performance of conditions?  [301] Was the DMC required to apply a precautionary approach?  [313] Analysis  [331]

Adaptive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taranaki-Whanganui Conservation Board v Environmental Protec... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 2217
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) granted Trans-Tasman Resources Limited (TTR) consents to extract and process seabed material containing iron ore and to discharge processed material into the sea. The granting of those consents has been challenged. Seven separate appeals have been lodged by entities who were submitters before the EPA. The broad issue for determination on the appeal is whether the consents granted by the EPA are in accordance with the provisions of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 (EEZ Act) and consistent with legal obligations that the parties contend arise from other sources including: the Resource Management Act 1991, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the Treaty of Waitangi, and the Marine and Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011. The Court identified eight issues for determination. The first issue was whether the EPA should have returned the application as incomplete. The Court found that the EPA had correctly decided not to return the application as incomplete. The second issue was what were the relevant purposes of the EEZ Act. The Court found that the purposes were to promote the sustainable management of the natural resources of the exclusive economic zone and continental shelf, and to protect the environment from pollution by regulating or prohibiting the discharge of harmful substances. The third issue was whether the Decision-Making Committee (DMC) had properly assessed the effects on existing interests. The Court found that the DMC had correctly identified the purposes of the EEZ Act and explained how they had taken the Act’s purposes into account in reaching their decision to grant the consents. The fourth issue was whether the DMC was required to apply a precautionary approach, and if so, did they do so. The Court found that the DMC had not made an error of law in failing to apply a precautionary approach. The fifth issue was whether the DMC adopted a prohibited adaptive management approach to the marine discharge consent. The Court found that the DMC had applied a narrow interpretation of the concept of adaptive management approach that was inconsistent with the purpose of the Act in s 10(1)(b) of protecting the environment from pollution by regulating or prohibiting the discharge of harmful substances. It was also inconsistent with the obligation set out in s 61(2) that, where information available is uncertain or inadequate, a marine consent authority must favour caution and environmental protection. The error was material and may well have influenced the outcome of the consent application. The sixth issue was whether the DMC observed the principles of natural justice. The Court found that the DMC had not breached the principles of natural justice. The Court allowed the appeal and quashed the decision of the DMC. The matter was referred back to the DMC for reconsideration, applying the correct legal test in relation to the concept of adaptive management approach. The Court invited the parties to agree on costs but in the absence of agreement, the appellants shall have 15 working days within which to file submissions, and the respondents 15 working days thereafter to reply.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established