Klink v Environmental Protection Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2019-485-170 [2019] NZHC 3161

UNDERThe Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 (the EEZ Act)

IN THE MATTER             Of an appeal under s 105 of the Act BETWEEN  KELLY MOANA KLINK

Appellant

ANDENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY

First Respondent

AND  COASTAL RESOURCES LIMITED

Second Respondent

CIV-2019-485-288

UNDER  The Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016

BETWEENSOCIETY FOR THE PROTECTION OF AOTEA COMMUNITY AND ECOLOGY LIMITED

Applicant

ANDENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY

First Respondent

AND  COASTAL RESOURCES LIMITED

Second Respondent

Hearing:                   22 and 23 July 2019

Appearances:           S J Grey and V Toki for the Appellant and Applicant A S Butler and K J Jordan for the First Respondent

M J Slyfield and M R K Redding for the Second Respondent

Judgment:                3 December 2019

KLINK v ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY and COASTAL RESOURCES LIMITED [2019]

NZHC 3161 [3 December 2019]

JUDGMENT OF CULL J


Table of Contents

Para No.

Background  [3]

Legal principles  [13]

The EEZ Act  [13]

The appeal  [24]

The issues  [26]

The principles of the Treaty of Waitangi  [29] The process leading up to the granting of the consent application  [34] The Māori Advisory Committee’s advice  [40]

The hearing in Auckland  [48]
The Authority’s Decision  [54]
Analysis  [56]
Conclusion  [76]

The other claims  [78]

Existing interests  [79]
International obligations  [84]

Adaptive management conditions  [87]

Overview  [95]
Result  [100]
Costs  [102]

[1]                  This case concerns the grant of a marine dumping consent, permitting the dumping of increased dredged material from Auckland, Northland, and Waikato harbours into the exclusive economic zone east of Aotea Great  Barrier  Island  (Great Barrier Island). These proceedings comprise an appeal and a judicial review of the decision of the Environmental Protection Authority (the Authority) to grant the application by Coastal Resources Ltd for a marine dumping consent under s 20G of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 (the EEZ Act).

[2]                  The appeal and the application for judicial review raise similar and overlapping grounds of errors of law and procedural unfairness. Coastal Resources opposes both and the Authority appeared to assist the Court.

Background

[3]                  Ms Klink represents Ngāti Rehua Ngatiwai ki Aotea (Ngāti Rehua), the local iwi of Great Barrier Island. Coastal Resources initially protested Ms Klink’s standing, but did not pursue this at the hearing. Section 105 of the EEZ Act provides that, aside from the applicant for the consent, only those who submitted on the consent application may bring an appeal.1 Ngāti Rehua made submissions to the Authority in the decision-making process although Ms Klink did not. As Ms Klink is a kaumatua of Ngāti Rehua, the parties agreed she has standing to bring this appeal.2

[4]                  The Society for the Protection of Aotea Community and Ecology Inc (the Society) is an incorporated society formed in May 2018. Its purpose is to protect the Great Barrier Island community and ecology, and to act as a voice for community environmental concerns. Its rules…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Klink v Environmental Protection Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 3161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns an appeal and a judicial review of the decision of the Environmental Protection Authority to grant a marine dumping consent application by Coastal Resources Ltd for the dumping of increased dredged material from Auckland, Northland, and Waikato harbours into the exclusive economic zone east of Aotea Great Barrier Island. The appeal was brought by Ms Klink, as a representative of the local iwi, and the judicial review by the Society for the Protection of Aotea Community and Ecology Limited. Both proceedings raised similar and overlapping grounds of errors of law and procedural unfairness. The Authority appeared to assist the Court.

The issues were whether the Authority made errors of law in failing to take into account relevant considerations and/or take into account considerations that were irrelevant by: failing to give effect to the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi as required by s 12 of the EEZ Act; overlooking the claimants’ existing interest under the Marine & Coastal Area (Takutai Moana) Act 2011; failing to consider the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, as required by s 11; and/or taking into consideration adaptive management type conditions, contrary to s 60 of the EEZ Act. The proceedings also claimed that the process adopted by the Authority was procedurally unfair and thereby unlawful in: giving inadequate notification of the application; failing to give consistent access and treatment of different tangata whenua entities; and/or holding hearings in a location, which limited the participation (access to justice) for the claimants.

The Court found that the Authority failed to take into account the Māori Advisory Committee’s advice, contrary to s 12 and s 59(3)(c) of the EEZ Act. The Māori Advisory Committee advised the Authority to engage with the local iwi groups and, in doing so, observe tikanga Māori. As a result of this failure, the Authority’s Decision had not been appropriately informed from a Māori perspective, contrary to s 12(a) of the EEZ Act. This resulted in the Authority overlooking its powers to consider those iwi who may be affected by the application, particularly those located in Great Barrier Island. The Authority also overlooked the function and advice from the Māori Advisory Committee, which advised caution about the inadequacy of the consent holder’s consultation. The Authority imposed a condition on Coastal Resources to establish and facilitate an Iwi Liaison Group. However, contrary to the function of the Māori Advisory Committee to provide a Māori perspective and contrary to the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi as recognised under the EEZ Act, the Authority has given the consent holder the choice of whom it wishes to join the Iwi Liaison Group.

The appeal and application for judicial review succeeds and the decision of the Authority is quashed. The matter is directed to be referred back to the Authority for its reconsideration, to have regard to the advice of the Māori Advisory Committee for meaningful engagement with local iwi authorities and groups which may be affected by the application, particularly those located in Great Barrier Island. Counsel are to confer on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established