The Phone Company Ltd v M2 NZ Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2016-404-002903 [2016] NZHC 2283

BETWEEN

THE PHONE COMPANY LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

M2 NZ LIMITED First Defendant

M2 TELECOMMUNICATIONS PTY LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 5 September 2016

Appearances:

D Grove for the Plaintiff
L L Fraser and R M A Jones for the Defendants

Judgment:

27 September 2016

JUDGMENT OF FITZGERALD J

This judgment was delivered by me on Tuesday, 27 September 2016 at 3.30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Ellis Law, Auckland

Chapman Tripp, Auckland

Counsel:            D Grove, Auckland

THE PHONE COMPANY LTD v M2 NZ LTD [2016] NZHC 2283 [27 September 2016]

INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................... [1] FACTUAL BACKGROUND ......................................................................................... [4] Initial relationship between the parties............................................................. [5] Termination Agreement ................................................................................... [10] Dispute concerning Black & White ................................................................. [13] Negotiation of the Variation Agreement .......................................................... [15] Variation Agreement ........................................................................................ [24] Exercise of Option to Discharge ..................................................................... [27] Financial accounts .......................................................................................... [28] TPC’S CLAIM AND M2’S APPLICATION - OVERVIEW .............................................. [31] LEGAL PRINCIPLES ............................................................................................... [35] Strike out ......................................................................................................... [35] Defendant’s summary judgment ...................................................................... [36] ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................. [42] First cause of action........................................................................................ [42] Second, third and fourth causes of action ....................................................... [47] Misrepresentation 9(a) ................................................................................ [48] Paragraph 9(b) misrepresentation – the business is “failing” ..................... [65] Paragraph 9(c) representation ..................................................................... [80] Paragraph 9(d) – M2’s letter dated 30 August 2011.................................... [84] Limitation ........................................................................................................ [96] CONCLUSION ...................................................................................................... [117] RESULT .............................................................................................................. [120] COSTS ................................................................................................................ [123]

Introduction

[1]      The parties operate in the telecommunications industry.   The essence of the

plaintiff’s (“TPC”) claim is two-fold:

(a)      A claim for contractual damages against the defendants (collectively referred to as “M2”) arising from an alleged failure by M2 to pay commission payments said to be due to TPC; and

(b)Damages arising from losses suffered by TPC as a result of alleged misrepresentations made by M2.  This aspect of the claim is advanced under both the Contractual Remedies Act 1979 and the Fair Trading Act 1986.

[2]      It is fair to say that the claims as presently pleaded are in relatively high level terms.    There  have  already been  two  rounds  of  requests  for  further  and  better particulars.   In respect of significant aspects of its claim, TPC says it can only provide further particulars after discovery.

[3]      M2  denies  all  claims.    It  applies  to  strike  out  the  claims,  and/or  seeks defendant’s summary judgment in relation to them.  It says the contractual claim of an alleged failure to pay commissions is barred by a later agreement between the parties, by which TPC gave up all rights to further commission payments.  In relation to the misrepresentation claims, M2 says the alleged representations are either demonstrably true or not actionable at law.   There is also a limitation defence in respect of the Fair Trading Act claims.

Factual background

[4]      The factual background to TPC’s claim is largely undisputed, but given the

issues arising on the current application, is set out in some detail below.

Initial relationship between the parties

[5]      M2 is based in Australia, though it is said…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Phone Company Ltd v M2 NZ Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2283
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an application by M2 NZ Ltd and M2 Telecommunications Pty Limited to strike out certain claims by The Phone Company Limited (TPC) or, in the alternative, for summary judgment. The claims were for alleged breaches of contract and misrepresentations made by M2 to TPC. The court was required to decide whether the claims disclosed a reasonably arguable case and whether they were time-barred under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The court found that some of the claims related to an alleged failure to pay commissions from Black & White revenues, which TPC knew about and therefore could not be misled by. The court also found that some of the misrepresentation claims were time-barred as TPC ought to have discovered the loss or damage prior to 1 December 2012. The court struck out the claims related to Black & White commissions and the prayers for relief seeking recovery of those commissions. The court also struck out certain paragraphs of the amended statement of claim and the prayers for relief to the third and fourth causes of action to the extent they sought recovery of Black & White commissions. TPC was ordered to file an amended statement of claim within 15 working days and M2 was to file its defence within 10 working days. The court encouraged the parties to agree on costs, with a provisional view that M2 should recover its costs on a 2B basis, discounted to reflect that it had not been successful on all aspects of its application.