The Phone Company Ltd v M2 NZ Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2015-404-2903

[2018] NZHC 2167

BETWEEN

THE PHONE COMPANY LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

M2 NZ LIMITED

First Defendant

M2 TELECOMMUNICATIONS PTY LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 15 February 2018

Appearances:

D W Grove for Plaintiff

J Marcetic and R M Jones for Defendants

Judgment:

22 August 2018


JUDGMENT OF PETERS J


This judgment was delivered by Justice Peters on 22 August 2018 at 4.45 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ...................................

Solicitors:           Foy & Halse, Auckland

Chapman Tripp, Auckland

Counsel:            D W Grove, Auckland

THE PHONE COMPANY LTD v M2 NZ LTD [2018] NZHC 2167 [22 August 2018]

Introduction

[1]        The plaintiff (“TPC”) and the defendants (together “M2”) seek determination of a preliminary question concerning the construction of a provision of an agreement dated 4 December 2006 (“termination agreement”).1

Background

[2]        M2 is an Australian telecommunications business.2 In or about the early 2000s, M2 was seeking to establish a presence in New Zealand. The evidence of Mr Bryan Holmes of TPC is that, having failed in its first attempt to establish here, M2 then approached him to assist.3 Mr Holmes’ evidence is that he and Mr Vaughan Bowen, the managing director/CEO of M2, discussed what would be required to establish M2’s presence here and this led to their Heads of Agreement (“HoA”).

[3]        The HoA is a letter from M2 to TPC dated 14 December  2005, signed by   Mr Bowen and Mr Holmes for their respective companies. The HoA included provisions regarding the services that TPC would render to M2 and how TPC would be remunerated for doing so.4

[4]        In December 2006, the parties agreed to terminate the HoA and to “settle all outstanding claims”.5 The terms on which they did so are recorded in a letter from M2 to TPC dated 4 December 2006, ie  the  termination  agreement,  again  signed  by Mr Bowen and Mr Holmes. Amongst other things, this agreement provided that M2 would pay two commissions to TPC in perpetuity.

[5]        Five years after the termination agreement, in May 2012, the parties executed what is referred to as the “variation agreement”. This appears to have been the only agreement between the parties that was drafted by a lawyer.


1      High Court Rules 2016, r 10.15. Nothing turns on the distinction between the first and second defendants.

2 Affidavit of V G Bowen dated 6 July 2016 at [8].

3 Affidavit of B C Holmes sworn 25 July 2017 at [24].

4 At [12].

5      There is no evidence of the nature of those claims.

[6]        The variation agreement added a provision to the termination agreement, giving each party the option of bringing the ongoing payment of commissions to an end, by M2 paying TPC a lump sum calculated according to an agreed formula.

[7]        TPC exercised this option in July 2012, and was paid out according to the formula.

Proceedings

[8]        By its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Phone Company Ltd v M2 NZ Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 2167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Phone Company Ltd (TPC) commenced proceedings against M2 NZ Ltd and M2 Telecommunications Pty Limited (M2) seeking to set aside a variation agreement and reinstate a termination agreement. The dispute centred on the interpretation of a clause in the termination agreement that outlined the commissions due to TPC. Specifically, TPC argued for the inclusion of all mobile phone service customers, while M2 contended that the commission should only apply to customers whose services were delivered on the Vodafone network. The court was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of this clause and its implications for the calculation of the commissions.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the commission outlined in clause (f) of the termination agreement should be calculated based on revenue from all mobile phone service customers of M2 or only those customers whose services were delivered on the Vodafone network. This interpretation hinged on the precise wording of clause (f) and the surrounding context provided by the termination agreement and other related documents. The court had to consider the ordinary and natural meaning of the clause, the broader context of the contract, and the principles of contract interpretation.

Justice Peters concluded that the literal reading of clause (f), particularly the placement of the comma before “including,” favoured TPC’s interpretation. The court found that clause (f) should be interpreted to include all revenues from mobile phone service customers of M2, regardless of the network on which their services were delivered. The court rejected M2's argument that the reference to the Vodafone network limited the scope of the commission to only those customers carried on that network, finding instead that the clause's wording supported TPC’s broader interpretation. Additionally, the court noted that any ambiguity in the clause should be resolved in favour of TPC, given that M2 drafted the termination agreement.

The court's decision was based on the principle that the ordinary meaning of the contractual language, construed in context, should guide the interpretation. Given the wording of clause (f) and the absence of any compelling evidence to the contrary, the court found that TPC’s interpretation was the correct one. Consequently, the preliminary question was answered in favour of TPC, meaning that the commission would be calculated based on revenue from all mobile phone service customers of M2.