Sanders v Project Management Agreement & Associates Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA671/2016
CA379/2017
[2018] NZCA 18

BETWEEN

SCOTT PATRICK SANDERS
Appellant

AND

PROJECT MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT & ASSOCIATES LIMITED
First Respondent

Continued over…

Hearing:

22 and 23 August 2017

Court:

Kós P, Cooper and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC and L Theron for Appellant
P G Skelton QC for Respondents
K S Graham for Financial Markets Authority

Judgment:

20 February 2018 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal in CA671/2016 is allowed.

BThe orders made in the High Court are set aside and judgment is entered for the appellant on the respondents’ claim.

C    The appeal in CA379/2017 is dismissed. 

DThe respondents must pay the appellant costs in CA671/2016 for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

EWe make no order for costs on the dismissal of the appeal in CA379/2017.

____________________________________________________________________

PAUL ANDREW CHEESEMAN AND
  SARAH FRANCES CHEESEMAN
  Second Respondents  
  PPD INVESTMENTS LIMITED
  Third Respondent

PEAK ASSETS LIMITED
  Fourth Respondent

PAUL GRAHAM ROSE AND
  JOYCE MARY ROSE  
  Fifth Respondents

ANDREW JOHN MILLWARD AND
  SALI-ANN MILLWARD
  Sixth Respondents

MATTHEW JUSTIN MORRIS AND
  JILL ANITA MORRIS
  Seventh Respondents

TAMSIN JUDITH RAISTRICK AND
  DAVID IAN RAISTRICK
  Eighth Respondents

JOHN DAVID SHACKLETON AND
  MARILYN FREDA SHACKLETON
  Ninth Respondents

HERBERT MICHAEL TATE
  Tenth Respondent

MARC VAN GELDER AND
  ANN WATZEELS
  Eleventh Respondents   

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

Table of Contents

Introduction        

Background

The resort  [2]
Purchase agreements  [4]
The cottage lease  [6]
Proceedings  [10]
High Court judgments  [18]

The issues  [20]

Issue 1 — did the offers to purchase units subject  to the cottage lease constitute offers of participatory securities under the Act?

Pleadings  [22]
High Court judgment  [24]

Submissions  [26]

Analysis  [29]

Issue 2 — did the exemption under s 5(1)(b) of the Act apply?

Pleadings  [42]
High Court judgment  [43]

Submissions  [44]

Analysis  [49]

Issue 3 — should Mr Sanders be permitted to argue on appeal that any respondents who were outside New Zealand when they received their

offers were not entitled to claim?  [53]

Issue 4 — if the answer to issue 3 is “yes”, is this an available defence?[58]
Issue 5 — did Mr Sanders prove that the default in repayment of the subscriptions was not due to any misconduct or negligence on his part in terms of the proviso to s 37(6) of the Act?                  [59]
Hotel lease — income pooling  [62]

Income pooling identified as Securities Act issue  [63]
Cottage lease —separate accounting  [64]

Securities Commission grants exemption to Monaco Village Holdings          [65]
    Mr Sanders' involvement  [69]
    Legal advice received  [70]  
    High Court judgment  [73]
    Analysis  [74]
Issue 6 — should a relief order have been made under s 37AH of the Act? [79]

Result  [80]

Introduction

  1. The question in this appeal is whether the High Court was correct to find that the respondents were entitled to escape their purchases of units in a resort development on the basis that the purchase agreements constituted void allotments…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sanders v Project Management Agreement & Associates Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sanders v Project Management Agreement & Associates Limited concerned the legal implications of a securities exemption granted to Monaco Village Holdings for a hotel lease arrangement. The dispute arose from the Securities Commission's decision to grant an exemption to Monaco Village Holdings in 2005, which allowed the hotel lease to operate under an income pooling scheme. The court had to determine whether this exemption was valid and whether it complied with the Securities Act 1978 and the Securities Regulations 1983.

The central legal issue was whether the income pooling arrangements under the hotel lease constituted a contravention of the Securities Act 1978. The court had to consider whether the pooling of rental income across units amounted to the offer or allotment of a participatory security, which is prohibited under the Act. Furthermore, the court examined the enforceability of the undertaking given by Monaco Village Holdings, which committed to re-offering lease arrangements on a per-unit basis if individuals did not approve the income pooling scheme.

The court found that the income pooling arrangements did indeed constitute a participatory security, thereby contravening the Securities Act 1978. However, it also concluded that the exemption granted by the Securities Commission was valid and enforceable. The court reasoned that the undertaking given by Monaco Village Holdings was sufficient to remedy the contravention by allowing unit owners to opt out of the income pooling scheme and instead receive their rental income on a per-unit basis. Consequently, the court upheld the exemption and the enforceability of the undertaking.

The court ordered that Monaco Village Holdings must notify unit owners of the contravention and re-offer lease arrangements on a per-unit basis to those who did not approve the income pooling scheme. This ruling ensured that the exemption remained in effect while providing a mechanism for unit owners to avoid the securities contravention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In July 2005 the Securities Commission granted an exemption to Monaco Village Holdings for participatory securities for the proportionate ownership scheme offered under the hotel lease at the resort. The exemption notice was supported by an enforceable undertaking given by Monaco Village Holdings and Messrs Gepp and Duke and accepted by the Securities Commission. It is clear from this document that all parties, including the Securities Commission, regarded the income pooling arrangements under the hotel lease as giving rise to the Securities Act issue and that there would be no such issue if the income for each unit was accounted for separately. The undertaking relevantly states: 2.Background ...2.5The Company [Monaco Village Holdings] and Monaco Management wish to administer the rental income payable to each unit owner on a pooled income basis, with income/expenses derived from guests occupying all accommodation units pooled together within each relevant block of units, on a block by block basis. The Company and Monaco Management believe that income pooling is more efficient allowing cost savings, provides a fairer return to unit owners, and has a measure of support within the tourist accommodation industry. The rental income for some units is already being administered on a pooled income basis for each block.Contravention of Securities Act 1978 and Securities Regulations 19832.6The Company and Monaco Management accept that the offer or allotment of securities in the form of an interest in the income pooling scheme to existing or prospective unit holders, constitutes the offer of a participatory security to the public for the purposes of the Securities Act 1978. …2.7The Company and its Directors were, at the time of the offer and allotment of the interests in the income pooling scheme arrangements (“the Securities”), unaware that such offers and allotment were made in contravention of the Securities Act 1978. ……4.Undertakings…4.2In relation to the Securities already offered to persons who have entered into sale and purchase agreements to purchase property in the Development, whether settled or unsettled, the Company: (a)Will give written notice to each such person … of the contravention or possible contravention of the Securities Act 1978 …(b)Will re-offer to each such person the “lease back” arrangements of all accommodation units to Monaco Management on the basis of the income pooling scheme whereby net pooled income will be distributed to unit owners, on a block by block basis.(c)Will request that each such person approve their willingness to participate in such income pooling scheme.(d) In circumstances where such persons do not request to participate under the re-offer proposal in an income pooling scheme regarding net rental, administered on a block by block basis, the Company will take appropriate steps to administer and account for the rental income derived from the relevant person’s unit on a per unit basis and take appropriate steps to separately account for income and expenditure regarding the relevant unit.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.