Sea World LLC v Sea World Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE

CIV-2018-485-139

[2018] NZHC 1995

BETWEEN

SEA WORLD LLC

Appellant

AND

SEA WORLD MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

Respondent

Hearing: 2 July 2018

Appearances:

L Carter and P Moodley for the Appellant B P Cain for the Respondent

Judgment:

7 August 2018


JUDGMENT OF COOKE J


Table of Contents

Assistant Commissioner’s Decision  [4]

Delays in the case  [9]

Arguments for Sea World US  [14]

Arguments for Sea World Australia  [18]

Issues not in dispute  [23]

Section 16 confusion – consistency of approach  [28]

(1)Nature of reputation  [34]

(2)Prominence of the words in the design marks  [37]

(3)Implications  [42]

Is there confusion?  [47]

Ensuring geographical limitation  [59]

Honest concurrent use  [63]

Summary and result  [66]

[1]                   Sea World LLC (Sea World US) is a corporation based in the United States of America. It has operated marine mammal amusement parks in San Diego and other locations in the United States. At the time of its application it was a well-established business, with a well-established reputation.  Sea World Management Pty Ltd (Sea

SEA WORLD LLC v SEA WORLD MANAGEMENT PTY LTD [2018] NZHC 1995 [7 August 2018]

World Australia) is an Australian based company which has offered a similar marine mammal amusement park on the Gold Coast in Queensland, Australia. At the time of its application it was also a well-established business with a well-established reputation.

[2]                   Both parties had used the name “Sea World” in association with their marine mammal amusement parks for many years in their respective countries. Both parties promoted their parks as tourist destinations to New Zealanders within New Zealand. On 27 May 1994, Sea World US’s predecessor submitted an application for registration of the word mark SEA WORLD in New Zealand. Sea World Australia’s predecessor lodged a notice of opposition in November 2001. On 1 May 1996, Sea World Australia’s predecessors submitted  an  application  for  the combined  mark  in New Zealand. Sea World US’s predecessor lodged a notice of opposition on 23 August 1999.

[3]                   The contested applications were consolidated, and evidence was filed by the parties at various dates between 2000 and 2002, although some of the evidence dates back as far as 1994. Following those initial steps, a large number of extensions of time were sought and obtained by consent over many years. Ultimately, on 26 May 2016, the Intellectual Property Office of New Zealand (the Office) advised that there would be no further delays noting that it was “strongly against the public interest, irrespective of the situation between the parties”. Ultimately the disputes between the parties were subject to a decision made by Victoria Casey QC, Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks, on 26 January 2018.1 This was some 24 years after the first application had been filed. In the meantime, the Trade Marks Act 2002 (the 2002 Act) had been passed. It is accepted that the transitional provisions apply to the applications, and they were accordingly addressed under the terms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sea World LLC v Sea World Management Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1995
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sea World LLC (Sea World US), a United States based corporation, and Sea World Management Pty Ltd (Sea World Australia), an Australian based company, both operated marine mammal amusement parks under the name "Sea World." Sea World US lodged an application for the registration of the word mark SEA WORLD in New Zealand in May 1994, and Sea World Australia lodged an application for the registration of a combined mark in May 1996. Sea World Australia opposed the Sea World US application, and Sea World US opposed the Sea World Australia application. After a series of delays, the applications were dealt with by Victoria Casey QC, Assistant Commissioner of Trade Marks, who declined to register the Sea World US mark on the basis that its registration would likely lead to confusion under s 16 of the Trade Marks Act 1953. Sea World US appealed that decision to the High Court. The Court found that the Assistant Commissioner erred in concluding that Sea World US's mark would give rise to confusion in under s 16 because of the Sea World Australia mark. The Court held that the Assistant Commissioner erred when considering the nature of the reputation arising from Sea World US's use of the name Sea World. The evidence demonstrated that there was a market reputation for marine park amusement services associated with the word Sea World for both Sea World Australia and Sea World US. The Court also found that the Assistant Commissioner erred in concluding that the visual differences between the design marks were sufficient to avoid s 16 confusion. The words "Sea World" dominated the visual presentation of each of the more detailed design marks, and the relevant marine parks were known as "Sea World." On an objective basis, the Court did not accept that relevant consumers would recognise only the design details, and not the key striking similarity arising from the use of exactly the same words in the design marks. The Court held that the clear geographic separation between Sea World US and Sea World Australia meant that there was no likelihood of confusion in the manner contemplated by s 16. The Court concluded that the Assistant Commissioner erred in reaching the conclusion that there was s 16 confusion that meant that the Sea World US trade mark should not be registered. The appropriate outcome for the applications was that both should be granted, subject to the registration being limited to the services offered by Sea World Australia and Sea World US in their respective jurisdictions. The appeal was allowed in part.