Rowmata Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Hildred

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2011-412-663 [2013] NZHC 2435

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the Liquidation of Rowmata Holdings
Limited

BETWEEN

ROWMATA HOLDINGS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

First Plaintiff

H D LEVIN and V J MADSEN-RIES Second Plaintiffs

AND

N M HILDRED First Defendant

S D HILDRED Second Defendant

G S COLE
Third Defendant

Hearing: 15-18 April 2013

Counsel:

M Davies and P Murray for First and Second Plaintiffs
L A Andersen for First and Second Defendants
R J M Sim for Third Defendant

Judgment:

18 September 2013

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J

Table of Contents

Introduction ..........................................................................................................[1] The facts ................................................................................................................[5] Agreement to purchase Marshall Road  [5] Initial discussions on financing the purchase  [9] RHL incorporated and deposits paid  [17] Changes in financial markets  [24] Deed of novation  [29]

Rowmata Holdings Limited (in liquidation) & Ors v Hildred & Ors [2013] NZHC 2435 [18 September 2013]

Settlement fails  [33] Liquidation  [42] The liquidators’ claim ........................................................................................[44] The Hildreds’ defence ........................................................................................[50] The case for George Cole ...................................................................................[52] Preliminary issues ..............................................................................................[55] Did the Rowmata 1 and 2 trusts purchase Marshall Road?  [55]

Did George Cole then retrospectively ratify that purchase as

the third trustee?  [61] Can RHL claim its deposits back?   [72] Reckless trading .................................................................................................[79] The authorities    [81] Arguments   [90] Assessment       [92] Performance of obligations................................................................................[97] Arguments   [99] Assessment  [103] Care, diligence and skill...................................................................................[120] Arguments [121] Assessment  [123] Best interests of the company ..........................................................................[126] Section 301:  Reparations, compensation or contribution............................[131] Transaction at undervalue...............................................................................[151] Arguments [152] RHL was not the purchaser  [154] RHL was a party to the deposit transaction  [156] RHL could not pay its due debts  [158] Conclusion  [171] Transactions for inadequate consideration ....................................................[173] Arguments   [174] Assessment  [176] Insolvent transaction........................................................................................[178] Intention to prejudice creditors ......................................................................[185] Restitution .........................................................................................................[191] Disposition.........................................................................................................[196]

Introduction

[1]      The Hildreds, whether by themselves personally or as trustees of two mirror trusts, purchased a dairy farm.  It was intended the title would ultimately be taken by a new company to be formed – Rowmata Holdings Limited (RHL).  The Hildreds were to be directors of the new company.  Under the agreement for sale and purchase the Hildreds had 10 working days to obtain finance and their solicitor’s approval.  If the contract was declared unconditional, there was then a reasonable delay before a deposit was payable and 10 months before final settlement.

[2]      The deal was structured this way so as to allow the purchasers time to obtain and  use  the  GST refund  on  the  purchase  price  to  pay the  deposit  and  then  to maximise the time post deposit to secure funding before being required to settle. RHL applied for, and received a refund of the GST component of the purchase price and effectively used that to pay the deposit (it is slightly more complicated than that as I explain below but that is the substance of what happened).

[3]      The Hildreds made the contract unconditional 10 working days later.  At that point they had neither finance nor investors in place to enable them to settle on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowmata Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Hildred and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rowmata Holdings Ltd (in liquidation) and others v Hildred and others involved a dispute over the purchase of a dairy farm at Marshall Road, Outram. The Hildreds, Shane and Noelene, and their associates, purchased the farm through two mirror trusts, the Rowmata 1 and 2 Trusts, with the intention that a new company, Rowmata Holdings Limited (RHL), would ultimately take title. The Hildreds were to be directors of RHL. The purchase agreement was structured to allow the Hildreds time to obtain finance and use the GST refund on the purchase price to pay the deposit. RHL effectively used the GST refund to pay the deposit, but the Hildreds were unable to settle the purchase, leading to RHL's liquidation.

The liquidators of RHL brought a claim against the Hildreds and the trustees of the Rowmata 1 and 2 Trusts, alleging breaches of directors' duties under the Companies Act 1993, transactions at undervalue, transactions for inadequate consideration, and transactions designed to prejudice creditors under the Property Law Act 2007. The liquidators sought to recover the deposits paid by RHL and to hold the defendants personally responsible for the losses.

The court found that the Hildreds, as directors of RHL, breached their duties under sections 131(1), 135, 136, and 137 of the Companies Act 1993 by committing the company to a highly speculative purchase without adequate financial arrangements, thereby exposing the company to significant risk. The court held that the Hildreds were personally responsible for 70% of the loss under section 301 of the Companies Act. The court also found that the liquidators were entitled to recover the full $720,000 in deposits from the trustees of the Rowmata 1 and 2 Trusts under sections 292, 297, and 298 of the Companies Act, and under the equitable doctrine of restitution. The court ordered the trustees to pay the liquidators $720,000 plus interest, and awarded the liquidators costs on a category 2B basis plus reasonable disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.