Rowmata Holdings Limited (in liquidation) v Hildred

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2011-412-663 [2014] NZHC 3257

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the liquidation of Rowmata Holdings
Limited

BETWEEN

ROWMATA HOLDINGS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

First Plaintiff

HENRY DAVID LEVIN and VIVIEN JUDITH MADSEN-RIES Second Plaintiffs

AND

NOLEEN MARGARET HILDRED First Defendant

SHANE DAVID HILDRED Second Defendant

GEORGE STEPHEN COLE Third Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

M Davies and N Malarao for Plaintiffs
L A Andersen for Defendants

Judgment:

16 December 2014

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J (COSTS)

Introduction

[1]      This is a costs decision.  In a decision released on 18 December 2013, I found in favour of the plaintiffs and ordered the defendant trustees to pay the plaintiffs

$720,000 plus interest.  I indicated that the plaintiffs were also entitled to costs on a

Category  2B  basis  plus  disbursements  but  gave  leave  to  the  parties  to  file

ROWMATA HOLDINGS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) & ORS v HILDRED & ORS (COSTS) [2014] NZHC

3257 [16 December 2014]

memoranda in the event they could not reach an agreement.1    Agreement has not been reached and the matter has returned to the Court for determination on the papers.

[2]      Schedule 2 and 3 of the High Court Rules changed while the proceeding was still on foot.   The relevant time allocation and daily rate for each step therefore depends on whether it took place before 14 June 2012.

The proceedings

[3]      The first and second defendants, the Hildreds, purchased a dairy farm.  It was intended  that  the title  would  be taken  by the  first  plaintiff,  Rowmata Holdings Limited (RHL).  The Hildreds are directors of RHL.  RHL obtained a GST refund on the purchase price and used it to pay the deposit.   The contract was made unconditional but settlement did not occur due to insufficient finance.   The IRD became a creditor to RHL for the GST refund.  RHL could not repay the money and IRD obtained an order liquidating RHL.

[4]      The liquidators brought a claim asking the Court to reach through RHL to its directors to make them account for the GST refund.  The liquidators said this was appropriate because the Hildreds breached their duties as directors under ss 131(1),

135, 136 and 137 of the Companies Act 1993.  The liquidators also made a separate claim against the Hildreds and their friend George Cole, the third defendant, as trustees of the two mirror trusts (Rowmata 1 and Rowmata 2) under ss 292, 297 and

298 of the Companies Act, s 348 of the Property Law Act 2007 and equitable doctrines of restitution.

[5]      In relation to the first to fourth causes of action, I found in favour of the plaintiffs and ordered the directors of RHL to pay 70 per cent of $720,000.   In relation to the fifth and ninth causes of actions, I found that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover the full $720,000 from the trustees of the Rowmata 1 and 2 trusts. In relation to the seventh cause of action, I found that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowmata Holdings Limited (in liquidation) v Hildred and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 3257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a dispute between Rowmata Holdings Limited (in liquidation) and the Hildreds, directors of the company, and George Cole, a trustee of two trusts. The plaintiffs, the liquidators of Rowmata Holdings Limited, sought to recover a GST refund used to pay for a dairy farm purchase. The defendants argued that they were not liable for the refund as they were not personally liable for the company's debts. The court found in favour of the plaintiffs, ordering the defendants to pay $720,000 plus interest. The current case concerns the costs incurred during the proceedings.

The main legal issues addressed in this case are the costs associated with discovery, the certification of second counsel, the acceptance of certain disbursements claimed by the plaintiffs, and the possibility of increased costs due to the defendants' conduct. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants' piecemeal approach to discovery necessitated additional costs for inspection. They also claimed that the defendants' unsatisfactory provision of discovery required them to seek non-party discovery from Rodgers Law, Staples Rodway, and ASB Bank Ltd. The plaintiffs further argued that the defendants' conduct warranted the certification of second counsel and increased costs for preparation for trial.

The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to additional costs for inspection of the defendants' discovery, as the piecemeal approach taken by the defendants caused confusion and additional time and costs. The court also found that the applications for non-party discovery were reasonably necessary, and the defendants should contribute to the costs incurred by the plaintiffs. However, the court did not certify second counsel, as it was not satisfied that the proceeding was sufficiently complex to require it. The court also denied certain disbursements claimed by the plaintiffs, such as flights and accommodation for Ms Madsen-Ries, and service fees for second counsel. Lastly, the court awarded increased costs of 25% for preparation for trial, due to the defendants' conduct.

The final orders of the court are as follows: the defendants are to pay for the second inspection, contribute one third of the costs paid to ASB Bank for non-party discovery, and contribute half of the costs paid to Rodgers Law and Staples Rodway for non-party discovery. The defendants are also to pay the service fees, but not for flights and accommodation for Ms Madsen-Ries. Additionally, the court awarded increased costs of 25% for preparation for trial. The total amount due, excluding flights, accommodation, and meals for principal counsel, is $94,823.03.