Prattley Enterprises Limited v Vero Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV2013-409-001511 [2015] NZHC 411

BETWEEN

PRATTLEY ENTERPRISES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 9 March 2015

Appearances:

FMR Cooke QC with S P Rennie for Plaintiff
D J Goddard QC with SWB Foote and C M Brick for
Defendant

Date ofRuling:

10 March 2015

RULING 1 OF DUNNINGHAM J

[1]      In  a  memorandum  dated  20  November  2014,  the  defendant  signalled  a challenge to the admissibility of some sections of the evidence of the plaintiff’s witness,  George Wilton  Keys,  who  gives  expert  evidence  on  the  approach  to depreciation to be adopted when assessing the indemnity value of the plaintiff’s building.

[2]      As agreed at the outset of the hearing, the issue of its admissibility was deferred to be considered later in the hearing, and when the context in which the evidence was to be given was clearer.   I therefore heard submissions on the admissibility challenge when the hearing resumed on 9 March 2015.

[3]      The particular passages of concern are found in paragraphs 13 and 18 of

Mr Keys’  brief  of  29  August  2014,  and  in  paragraph  6  of  his  reply  brief  of

PRATTLEY ENTERPRISES LIMITED v VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2015] NZHC 411 [10 March 2015]

14 October 2014.  The paragraphs concern the approach to depreciation adopted in another proceeding, Morrison and Cross v Vero Insurance Limited.1

[4]      The first  challenged passage refers to  a letter from the defendant to the plaintiffs in the Morrison proceeding regarding its approach to depreciation in that case.  The other challenged passages of the evidence refer to the outcome of expert witness conferral in the Morrison proceedings, as Mr Keys seeks to rely on the outcome of that to support his opinion as to the appropriate approach to, and allowance for, depreciation of the building that is the subject of the current proceeding.  In its current form, his evidence references both the defendant’s letter, and the joint expert report on depreciation in the Morrison proceeding, although their inclusion in the common bundle was objected to by the defendant.

[5]      The defendant submits that both its stance on depreciation as identified in the letter,  and  the  outcome  of  witness  conferral  in  the  Morrison  proceeding,  are irrelevant and should not be admissible in this hearing.   It says that the Morrison case concerned a claim against the defendant by a different plaintiff for damage to a different building.   As a consequence, the approach taken by Vero, or by expert witnesses in that case are neither relevant nor admissible in this proceeding as they cannot shed light on the correct interpretation of a policy or on its application to the facts in the present case.   The defendant seeks orders ruling all three identified passages, and the documents they refer to, as inadmissible.

[6]      The plaintiff argues that the three identified passages should be admissible. First,  an  issue  in  dispute  in  the  present  proceedings  is  the  correct  depreciation method to adopt when calculating indemnity…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prattley Enterprises Limited v Vero Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Prattley Enterprises Limited, a plaintiff, brought an action against Vero Insurance Limited, the defendant, in the High Court of New Zealand. The dispute centred on the admissibility of certain expert evidence given by George Wilton Keys, an expert witness on depreciation in the assessment of the indemnity value of the plaintiff’s building. Vero Insurance challenged the admissibility of specific passages of Mr Keys' evidence, which referenced the approach to depreciation adopted in another proceeding, Morrison and Cross v Vero Insurance Limited. The court was required to determine whether the challenged evidence was relevant and admissible under the Evidence Act 2006.

The court examined the relevance of the evidence in question, considering whether it pertained to the specific issues in the current case. The plaintiff argued that the evidence was relevant as it demonstrated the industry’s approach to depreciation, supporting Mr Keys’ expert opinion. Vero Insurance contended that the evidence was irrelevant because it related to a different case with different facts. The court concluded that while the general reasoning applied in the Morrison case might be relevant, the specific evidence in question was not. The court found that the probative value of the evidence was outweighed by the risk of unfairness and unnecessary prolongation of the proceeding.

In its ruling, the court found the challenged passages and the documents they referenced to be inadmissible. The court held that the evidence was either irrelevant or would cause undue expense and delay if tested for its relevance. Furthermore, the court found that the evidence did not satisfy the requirements of the Evidence Act and was potentially prejudicial to the defendant. The court directed that the specified passages and documents could not be read in evidence at trial.

The final orders of the court were that specific paragraphs of Mr Keys’ evidence and the documents referenced in those paragraphs were inadmissible and could not be used in the trial. The plaintiff was not permitted to rely on this evidence to support their case regarding the appropriate depreciation method for the building in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established