Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-11179 [2016] NZHC 312

BETWEEN

IAN JAMES BURDEN

First Plaintiff

AND

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED Second Plaintiff

AND

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (VIETNAM LIMITED)

Third Plaintiff

AND

DEBONAIRE FURNITURE LIMITED First Defendant

AND

BURDEN FURNITURE (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED Second Defendant

AND

BURDEN FURNITURE CO LIMITED Third Defendant

AND

LINDSAY JOHN BURDEN Fourth Defendant

AND

JEREMY DAVID SMITH Fifth Defendant

AND

ROBERT WAYNE SMITH Sixth Defendant

Hearing: 29 February 2016

Counsel:

B P Cain for Plaintiffs
G F Arthur for First, Fifth and Sixth Defendants

Judgment:

29 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

BURDEN v PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (INTL) LTD [2016] NZHC 312 [29 February 2016]

Introduction

[1]      This   conference  was   convened   in   response   to   a  request   in   a  joint memorandum  of  the  plaintiffs  and  the  first,  fifth  and  sixth  defendants  (the defendants)  dated  28 January 2016  advising  that  the  parties  had  been  unable  to resolve the following six issues:

(a)       the plaintiffs’ request that the defendants better plead the allegation in

relation to industrial application;

(b)      the  defendants’  request  that  the  plaintiffs  provide  discovery  of

documents relating to the industrial application of the artistic works;

(c)       the plaintiffs’ request  that  the defendants  withdraw or replead  the

second counterclaim;

(d)the  defendants’  request  that  the  plaintiffs  provide  discovery  of documents from the Burden v ESR Group Ltd trial, including briefs of evidence and the transcript;

(e)      the   plaintiffs’  request   that   the   defendants   provide   details   for documents  discovered  by  the  defendants  in  compliance  with  the listing and exchange protocol in Schedule 9, Part 2 of the High Court Rules;

(f)       an appropriate timetable in light of the slippage to date.

[2]      In accordance with the direction in para [2] of my Minute of 5 February 2016 both sides filed both support and reply memoranda addressing each of the issues and proposing revised timetables to trial.

Plaintiffs’ request for particulars of industrial application defence

[3]      The  close  of  pleadings  date  was  extended  to  4 December 2015  in  my Minute [4]  of  2 November 2015.    On  3  December 2015  the  defendants  filed  an amended statement of defence and amended counterclaim dated 2 December 2015. That defence added a further sentence at para 23 as follows:

They further say that they deny infringement on the grounds that the alleged artistic works were industrially applied more than 16 years before the alleged infringements were made.

That pleading invoked the special exception in s 75 of the Copyright Act 1994 in respect of artistic works that have been industrially applied.

[4]      The plaintiffs’ position was that the defendants had failed to comply with r 5.48 of the High Court Rules and that further particulars were required, such as details  of  which  works  were  said  to  have  been  industrially  applied  more  than

16 years ago and when and where such application occurred.  Having regard to the creation dates of the copyright works listed in the third amended statement of claim dated 4 December 2015, the plaintiffs had difficulty in comprehending…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 312
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited was heard in the High Court of New Zealand. The plaintiffs, Ian James Burden, Plantation Grown Timbers (International) Limited, and Plantation Grown Timbers (Vietnam) Limited, sought relief against the defendants, Debonaire Furniture Limited, Burden Furniture (International) Limited, Burden Furniture Co Limited, Lindsay John Burden, Jeremy David Smith, and Robert Wayne Smith. The dispute revolved around intellectual property rights, specifically the alleged infringement of copyright in artistic works and the industrial application of these works. The court had to decide on several issues raised by both parties, including the adequacy of the defendants' pleadings regarding the industrial application of artistic works, the scope of discovery of documents related to these works, and the propriety of the defendants' counterclaims.

The court examined whether the defendants' pleadings sufficiently detailed the industrial application of the artistic works more than 16 years prior to the alleged infringements, as required under section 75 of the Copyright Act 1994. The plaintiffs argued that more specific details were necessary to comprehend how the special exception could apply. The court concluded that the way the issue was raised in the defence was sufficient, provided the reference to "the alleged artistic works" was clarified to specifically mention the copyright works in question.

Regarding the discovery of documents, the court ruled that the defendants were entitled to discover pleadings, briefs of evidence, and cross-examination of the plaintiffs in the Burden v ESR Group Ltd trial, to the extent that they related to the subsistence and originality of copyright in the artistic works common to both proceedings. However, the plaintiffs were not required to produce documents that no longer existed or were misappropriated by a former employee.

The court also deliberated on the propriety of the defendants' second counterclaim, which sought orders for the release of detained furniture and compensation. The plaintiffs argued that this counterclaim was inappropriate and should be struck out or amended. The court decided that while the counterclaim might be more appropriately pursued via an interlocutory application, it was not necessary to strike it out, as it ensured the issue would be on the trial agenda.

In summary, the court made several orders to amend pleadings, direct the scope of discovery, and set a revised timetable for the proceeding. Both parties were directed to cooperate in resolving these issues to keep the case on track for the scheduled trial date. The court refrained from making any order for costs in connection with the conference.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established