Morrison v Vero Insurance New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV 2013-409-000792 [2014] NZHC 2344

BETWEEN

ANTHONY BRENDON MORRISON and

GAIL CROSS Plaintiffs

AND

VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing:

12-16 May 2014

17 May 2014
19-22 May 2014
27-28 May 2014

Counsel:

S P Rennie and J E Bayley for Plaintiffs
M Ring QC and P Hunt for Defendant

Judgment:

25 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

MORRISON and CROSS v VERO INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2014] NZHC 2344 [25 September 2014]

Table of Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] Summary of findings ..............................................................................................[6] Approach to Assessment ......................................................................................[14] PART 1 - Context .................................................................................................[15] The Building.........................................................................................................[15] The effects of the earthquakes on use ..................................................................[17] The claims process ...............................................................................................[18] The policy.............................................................................................................[20] PART 2 – The nature, scale and timing of earthquake damage............................[54] The investigations and reports .............................................................................[54] The Richardson reports ....................................................................................[55] The BMC reports ..............................................................................................[67]

Dr Ma’s review of Weidlinger Associates Inc report........................................[75] MWH Recovery Ltd report ...............................................................................[76] The Weidlinger reports .....................................................................................[79] Pre hearing expert caucusing ...............................................................................[94] The evidence ........................................................................................................[98] Allocation assessment ........................................................................................ [110] The modelling................................................................................................. [111] The criticisms .................................................................................................[121] The evidence as a whole.................................................................................[137] Conclusion..........................................................................................................[145] PART 3 – The indemnity ....................................................................................[146] Material Damage ...........................................................................................[146] Economic repair and feasibility / destroyed...................................................[156] Notice .............................................................................................................[158] The deductible ................................................................................................[163] Depreciation...................................................................................................[168] Merger ............................................................................................................[173] Quantum .............................................................................................................[177] The problem(s) with caucusing ..........................................................................[178] Result..................................................................................................................[181] Process from here ...........................................................................................[185]

Introduction

[1]      The Tony Morrison Trust (TMT)1 owns a building in Woolston, Christchurch. It was severely damaged by the Christchurch earthquakes.   Vero Insurance New Zealand Limited (Vero) agreed to indemnify for damage to the building, capped at

$3,482,000 per event of loss.  TMT claims there were five earthquake events causing loss  to  the  building,  namely  on  4  September  and  26 December  2010,  and  on

22 February, 6 April and 13 June 2011.  If correct, the total amount payable under the policy  is  estimated  by  TMT  at  about  $13,100,000.  Vero  denies  it  is  liable  to indemnify five events of loss.   Rather it says it was only liable to indemnify for damage caused by the September and February earthquakes. It says that the total amount payable (and in fact paid) for these events is about $3,985,000.

[2]      TMT employed modelling to identify five major events of loss and then to quantify  the  extent  of  the  damage  caused  by  those  events.    Vero  rejects  this modelling as unreliable. It also contends that most if not all major elements of the building required replacement after the February event so that subsequent  damage to the  same  elements  was  not  material  damage  for  the  purpose  of  an  indemnity payment.

[3]      The  central  issue  to  resolve  therefore  is  whether  the  indemnity  value  is limited to the repair cost associated with the damage caused by the September 2010 and February 2011 earthquakes. This then raises the following key questions:

(a)       Is the modelling used by TMT reliable and substantially helpful in allocating damage and repair cost to events of loss?

(b)What was the nature, scale and type of damage, if any, caused by each of the September,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morrison v Vero Insurance New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard a case involving the Tony Morrison Trust (TMT) and Vero Insurance New Zealand Limited regarding damage to a building in Woolston, Christchurch, caused by several earthquakes. TMT, which owns the building, sought to recover damages under an insurance policy, while Vero contested the extent of its liability. The court was required to decide whether Vero was liable for multiple events of loss and, if so, the extent of its indemnity liability under the policy. The key issues included the reliability of modelling used to allocate damage per earthquake event, the nature, scale, and timing of the damage caused by each earthquake, and the interpretation of the policy terms, including the deductible, depreciation, and merger doctrine.

The court found that the modelling used by TMT was reliable and substantially helpful for understanding the relative impact of ground shaking on the building and as an input for assessing the allocation of damage across the earthquakes. The court concluded that the majority of the damage to the building was caused by the February earthquake, with additional damage from the September and June earthquakes. The court rejected the claim that the December and April earthquakes caused material additional damage. The court held that Vero was liable to indemnify TMT for the repair costs associated with the additional damage caused by the June earthquake. The court also found that the delay in reporting the June earthquake did not prejudice Vero, and that the deductible should be interpreted based on insurance practice, a matter to be resolved in a future hearing. The court ruled that the cost of new piles should not be included in the indemnity value but must be included in the reinstatement value.

The court proposed to make declarations regarding the indemnity payments for each event, the exclusion of new piles from the indemnity value, and the need for further submissions on the deductible and other unresolved issues. The court gave the parties 20 working days to file submissions on the final form of the declarations, the judgment sum, costs, and the timetable for addressing the issue of the deductible.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established