Arrow International Ltd v QBE Insurance (International) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

  1. NOTE

    Arrow International Ltd v QBE Insurance (International) Ltd

  1. Court of Appeal    Wellington   CA426/2009;  [2010] NZCA 408

    22 June; 8 September 2010

    O’Regan, Ellen France and Randerson JJ

Insurance  – Liability  of insurer  – Policy  construction  – Cover  for  damage

  1. occurring  “during  period  of insurance” –  Whether  deterioration by water ingress into building occurred  “during  period of insurance” – Whether policy to be construed  contra  proferentem.

Contract  – Interpretation – Whether insurance  policy to be construed  contra proferentem.

  1. Arrow International Ltd appealed from the judgment of MacKenzie J reported at [2009] 3 NZLR 650 (HC) and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the reasoning of MacKenzie J.

The reasons of the Court were given by

O’REGAN J.

  1. [Editorial note: [1]–[14] are omitted from this note.]

Issues on appeal

[15]    Arrow did not seek to challenge the Court’s factual findings on appeal. Rather, it identified the following key legal issue: is QBE liable to indemnify Arrow for the settlement reached with the owners and others:

  1. (a)  on  the  basis  that  damage  occurred  during  the  relevant  period  of insurance;

    (b)or, on the basis that the damage that was happening both before and during the relevant period of insurance first became actionable during the relevant  period of insurance  (that is, when it caused loss to the

  2. owners and completed their cause of action against Arrow);

    (c)  or, on the basis that the extent of the damage first became manifest

    during the relevant period of insurance?

[16]    If that issue is resolved  in favour of Arrow, three other issues would arise:

  1. (a)  if QBE is liable, whether this liability is excluded by the “Defective

    Products” exclusion in the insurance policy;

    (b) if QBE  is liable,  whether  the  full  amount  of settlement  should  be apportioned  between  the  insured  and  uninsured  heads  of  claim  on which the settlement  was based,  so that QBE is liable only for the

  2. insured aspects; and

    (c)  whether Arrow is entitled to recover its defence costs from QBE.

Our approach

  1. On the approach we take to the case, it is necessary for us to deal only with the first issue identified above.10 Because our views correspond closely to those of MacKenzie  J, we can set them out relatively briefly.

  2. We start with the proposition expressed by MacKenzie  J in his judgment    5 to the effect that the search for a trigger for coverage under a public liability policy  must  be  firmly grounded  in  the  policy  wording.11  We  agree.  In  the present case, Arrow will be entitled to indemnity only if the sums for which it became  legally  liable  to pay by way of compensation  to the owners of the leaking apartments and retail units was a liability that was “consequent upon ...    10 physical ... damage ... happening ... during the period of insurance”.

  3. There was no dispute that Arrow did become legally liable to pay a sum by way of compensation for accidental physical damage to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arrow International Ltd v QBE Insurance (International) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZCA 408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Arrow International Ltd appealed a decision of MacKenzie J, who found that QBE Insurance (International) Ltd was not liable to indemnify Arrow for the settlement reached with the owners and others regarding damage to Luxford Villas. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the judgment of MacKenzie J. The central issue was whether QBE was liable to indemnify Arrow for the settlement based on damage that occurred during the relevant period of insurance, or if the damage first became actionable or manifest during that period. The Court of Appeal, aligning with MacKenzie J, concluded that Arrow was not entitled to indemnity as the physical damage that triggered Arrow's liability for compensation had occurred before the policy period commenced. The Court found that the policy's wording clearly required a single point of damage occurrence to trigger coverage, and in this case, the damage had already happened before QBE's policy was in effect.

The Court further rejected Arrow's argument that the policy should cover continuous exposure, allowing for multiple triggers of liability. MacKenzie J and the Court of Appeal found that the policy's wording did not support such an interpretation. Additionally, the Court dismissed the notion that the policy's trigger for liability was the manifestation of damage, rather than its occurrence. The Court found that Arrow's liability for compensation was already established before QBE's policy period, and no new liability was incurred during that period. As a result, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and awarded costs to QBE on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established