Port Otago Ltd v Environmental Defence Society Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 6/2022
 [2023] NZSC 112
BETWEEN

PORT OTAGO LIMITED
Appellant

AND

ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENCE SOCIETY INCORPORATED
First Respondent

OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL
Second Respondent
ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED
Third Respondent
MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Fourth Respondent
Hearing:

11–12 May 2022

Court:

Winkelmann CJ, Glazebrook, Ellen France, Williams and William Young JJ 

Counsel:

L A Andersen KC and S M Chadwick for Appellant
D A Allan, M C Wright and C S S Woodhouse for First Respondent
S J Anderson and T M Sefton for Second Respondent
M C Smith, S T Shaw and M Downing for Third Respondent
J W Maassen and B D Mead for Fourth Respondent
V E Casey KC, V S Evitt and J W E Parker for Waka Kotahi | New Zealand Transport Agency
R B Enright for Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Whai Maia Limited
P F Majurey and K Ketu for Ngāti Maru Rūnanga Trust, Te Ākitai Waiohua Waka Taua Incorporated, Ngāi Tai ki Tāmaki Trust and Ngāti Tamaoho Trust
G C Lanning and C J Ryan for Auckland Council

Judgment:

24 August 2023

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe order remitting the matter to the Environment Court is set aside.

C        The Otago Regional Council is directed to consult the parties and any other persons it considers appropriate on a redrafted policy 4.3.7(d)–(e) in the proposed Otago Regional Policy Statement either: 

(a)along the lines in paragraph [87] of this judgment or to similar effect; or

(b)otherwise to give appropriate effect to the policies of the NZCPS and their inter-relationships.

D        Costs are reserved.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS
(Given by Glazebrook J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction [1]
Factual background [4]
The NZCPS [9]
Proposed Regional Policy Statement [14]
Decisions of the Courts below [18]
Environment Court decision [18]
High Court decision [35]
Court of Appeal decision [36] 
The submissions of the parties [42]
  Port Otago [42]
  Marlborough District Council [47]
  Environmental Defence Society
  Otago Regional Council 
[49]
[51]
  Royal Forest and Bird  [52]
Other submissions [55]
Issues [58]
Relationship between the NZCPS avoidance policies and the ports policy

[59]

  Interpretation of the NZCPS [60]
  NZCPS avoidance policies [64]
  NZCPS ports policy [69]
  Potential for conflict [71]
Where conflicts should be addressed [72]
How any conflicts should be addressed [75]
Summary of decision [83]
Suggested policy amendment [85]
Disposition [90]
Result and costs [92]

Introduction

[1]       This appeal raises important issues about the relationship between the policies in the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS) and how such policies should be reflected in lower-order planning documents.[1]  Resolving these issues requires us to address the principles established by this Court in Environmental Defence Society v The New Zealand King Salmon Co Ltd (King Salmon)[2] and Sustain Our Sounds Inc v The New Zealand King Salmon Co Ltd (Sustain Our Sounds)[3] in a different context.  At issue in King Salmon and Sustain Our Sounds

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Port Otago Ltd v Environmental Defence Society Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZSC 112
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the relationship between the policies in the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS) requiring the protection of the natural environment and the NZCPS policy on ports as it relates to Port Otago, which is critical existing infrastructure. The appeal requires a consideration of the relationship between the NZCPS avoidance policies and the NZCPS ports policy, whether any potential conflicts between those policies should be addressed in regional policy statements and plans or at the consent level, and how any conflicts should be addressed. The Court concluded that the avoidance policies and the ports policy are all directive. There is potential for conflict between the ports policy and the avoidance policies. The issue of the reconciliation of any potential conflict between the NZCPS avoidance policies and ports policy should be addressed at the regional policy statement and plan level as far as possible. Where there is a potential conflict between the avoidance policies and the ports policy with regard to a particular project, the decision-maker would have to be satisfied that the work is required (and not merely desirable) for the safe and efficient operation of the ports; if the work is required, all options for dealing with these safety or efficiency needs have been evaluated and, where possible, the option chosen should not breach the avoidance policies; and where a breach of the avoidance policies is unable to be averted, any breach is only to the extent required to provide for the safe and efficient operation of the ports. Even where the option chosen encroaches on the avoidance policies only to the extent necessary for the safe and efficient operation of the ports, this does not mean that a resource consent would necessarily be granted. In deciding whether to grant a resource consent all relevant factors would have to be considered in a structured analysis, designed to decide which of the directive policies should prevail, or the extent to which a policy should prevail, in the particular case. The Court provided suggested wording to be inserted after para (c), replacing (d)–(f), of the proposed ports policy (4.3.7). The appeal is allowed. The order remitting the matter to the Environment Court is set aside. The Council is directed to consult the parties and any other persons it considers appropriate on a redrafted policy 4.3.7(d)–(e) in the proposed Otago Regional Policy Statement either: (a)along the lines in paragraph [87] of this judgment or to similar effect; or(b)otherwise to give appropriate effect to the policies of the NZCPS and their inter-relationships. Costs are reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established