WHĀTua v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2024-404-000271 CIV-2024-404-000367

[2024] NZHC 3794

IN THE MATTER OF an Appeal under Section 299 of the Resource Management Act 1991

BETWEEN

TE RŪNANGA O NGĀTI WHĀTUA

First Appellant

ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED

Second Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

First Respondent

WASTE MANAGEMENT NZ LTD
Second Respondent

Continued...

Hearing: 29 July to 2 August 2024

Appearances:

R B Enright, I Paniora, M R Enright for First Appellant P D Anderson, M Downing for Second Appellant

A F Buchanan, W M C Randall for First Respondent

B J Matheson, W M Irving, S H Pilkington, A E Gilbert for Second Respondent

R H Haazen for Ngāti Whātua Orākei Whai Maia Ltd A W Braggins, A Parkinson for Fight the Tip Inc

J M Pou, T M Urlich for Ngāti Manuhiri Kaitiaki Charitable Trust

Judgment:

19 December 2024


JUDGMENT OF WHATA J


This judgment was delivered by me on 19 December,

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ………………………….

TE RŪNANGA O NGĀTI WHĀTUA v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2024] NZHC 3794 [19 December 2024]

Continued...

NGĀTI MANUHIRI KAITIAKI CHARITABLE TRUST

First Interested Party

FIGHT THE TIP INCORPORATED

Second Interested Party

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

First Respondent

NGĀTI WHĀTUA ŌRĀKEI WHAI MAIA LIMITED and ENVIRON HOLDINGS LIMITED

Third Interested Party

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TABLE OF CONTENTS 3
INTRODUCTION [1]
Appeal threshold [5]
Overview [6]
Mana whenua [7]
Avoid policies [11]
Material harm [15]
Another issue of interest [16]
PART A - BACKGROUND [17]
Description of the Landfill [18]
Context [19]
Description of the site [20]
Landfill site characteristics [20]
Water catchments [25]
Planning maps [27]
Ecological values [28]
Proposed works [29]
Site layout [29]
Potential adverse effects and proposed response [31]
Reclamation effects [32]
Effects on wetlands [34]
Effects on freshwater fauna [36]
Sediment Effects [39]
Leachate and groundwater effects [41]
Effects on vegetation [43]
Effects on pepeketua [45]
Effects on pekapeka (long-tailed bats) [49]
Mitigation, offset and compensation proposal [51]
Council hearing [53]
Environment Court [57]
Site selection [61]
Policy Framework [62]
NPS-FM [63]
AUP [66]
Section 104D(1)(b) of the RMA [69]
The Waste Minimisation Act 2008 [70]
Tangata whenua [78]

PART B – THE INTERIM DECISION  [79]

Tangata whenua issues  [80]

Other Environmental impacts  [95]

Objectives and Policies  [97]

Inland wetlands, rivers and freshwater  [101]

Landfills  [112]

Infrastructure  [115]

Mana whenua, Toitū te whenua, Toitū te taiao  [116]

Overall  [117]

Effects management  [120]

Waste minimisation  [124]

Conclusion  [127]

PART C – MANA WHENUA  [129]

“Common understanding”  [129]

Assessment  [133]

“Strength of relationship”  [141]

Assessment  [146]

“Cultural bottom lines”  [164]

Some definition  [174]

Assessment  [176]

PART D – SITE SELECTION  [216]

Assessment  [219]

PART E — FRESHWATER  [221]

The Objective error  [223]

Error one — pragmatic and proportionate  [228]

Assessment  [232]

NPS-FM 2020 policies  [237]

Policies E13 (1) and (4)  [240]

Policy E3.3(17), “holistically”  [241]

Frogs  [242]

Error two – failure to apply directive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WHĀTua v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 3794
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Waste Management NZ Limited (WM) has applied for resource consents to construct and operate a large regional landfill at Wayby Valley, Wellsford. Consents were granted by Auckland Council. Several parties appealed this grant to the Environment Court. That Court has released an interim decision indicating it is minded to grant consent, subject to resolution of specific issues. Two appeals have been filed on the Environment Court's interim decision by Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Whātua and by Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand (Forest and Bird). The appeals challenge five key areas of the Environment Court decision: mana whenua status and cultural effects; site selection; freshwater matters and the National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management 2020 (NPS-FM); the Auckland Unitary Plan (AUP) and Chapter E13 of the AUP; and the waste minimisation framework. The Court found that the Environment Court adequately addressed the relevant matters on mana whenua. The Court did not exclude the possibility of "cultural" or tikanga bottom lines, but considerable caution is needed before making such a finding. The Court found that the Court erred insofar as it found that only the avoid policies relating to mauri were truly "bottom line" policies. But this did not have a material impact on the decision because the Court still treated the relevant NPS-FM avoid policies as "prescriptive" and "directive" and ultimately adopted a no material harm approach to the threshold gateway criteria at s 104D(1)(b) for grant of consent. The Court found that a no material harm approach is sufficient to satisfy the avoid policies of the AUP. This may include a net offsets approach, provided those offsets respond to the loss of extent of river. The Court found that the Court gave careful consideration to the goals of Waste Minimisation Act and the Waste Minimisation Plan. The Court dismissed the appeals against the interim decision. The final judgment will nevertheless need to more clearly address how the competing tikanga ā-iwi positions are resolved and the basis upon which a no material harm result is achieved, especially in relation to extent of river loss.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established