Port Otago Ltd v Environmental Defence Society Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA240/2020
 [2021] NZCA 638

BETWEEN

PORT OTAGO LIMITED
Appellant

AND

ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENCE SOCIETY INCORPORATED
First Respondent

OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL
Second Respondent

ROYAL FOREST AND BIRD PROTECTION SOCIETY OF NEW ZEALAND INCORPORATED
Third Respondent

MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Fourth Respondent

Hearing:

6 July 2021

Court:

Kós P, Miller and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

L A Andersen QC for Appellant
D A Allan and M C Wright for First Respondent
A J Logan and T M Sefton for Second Respondent
P D Anderson and S T Shaw for Third Respondent
J W Maassen and B D Mead for Fourth Respondent

Judgment:

2 December 2021 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the first, second and third respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis plus usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Kós P and Gilbert J   [1]

Miller J  [94]

KÓS P AND GILBERT J

(Given by Kós P)

Table of Contents

Para No

Background

The PRPS and its consequences

Statutory and regulatory framework

The RMA:  policy statements and regional plans
The NZCPS
Resource consents

The King Salmon decision

Majority judgment
Dissenting judgment
Issues arising from King Salmon

Environment Court interim decision
High Court decision
Approved question of law for appeal
Did the High Court misapply King Salmon?

Discussion
Conclusion

Two immaterial errors below
Result

[1]
[11]
[16]
[16]
[21]
[30]
[35]
[38]
[50]
[53]
[62]
[66]
[71]
[73]
[78]
[87]
[88]
[92]
  1. The New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement 2010[1] requires adverse effects in areas of outstanding natural character be “avoided”.  The essential question in this appeal is whether a proposed regional policy statement gives effect to that requirement by providing adverse effects in such areas be “avoided, remedied or mitigated”? 

Background

[1]Herein, the NZCPS.

  1. The Otago Harbour, or Ōtākou, is the only significant natural port located between Timaru and Bluff.  Ngāi Tahu sold the Otago block to the New Zealand Company in 1844, and Dunedin was founded four years later.  Harbour dredging to Port Chalmers began in 1865, and on to Dunedin in 1881. 

  2. The harbour is a long, hill-girt waterway running southwest from its entrance at Taiaroa Head.  That entrance is not without difficulty:  a narrow, dredged channel lying between the dramatic, steepling Taiaroa Head to the southeast and a long low‑lying man-made mole, over a kilometre in length, to the southwest at Aramoana.  The mole, constructed in the 1880s, prevents littoral drift of sediment southward along Spit Beach.  Without the Aramoana mole, a sand bar would form and block the harbour entrance. 

  3. The navigation channel, dredged at this point to a depth of 13.5 metres, takes a serpentine course to Port Chalmers:  past Harington Point to port and, to starboard, a long sandy feature off the Aramoana banks known as The Spit.  A course adjustment to starboard is required soon after to continue down the channel:  a vessel entering the harbour will now be heading due west past…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Port Otago Ltd v Environmental Defence Society Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 638
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Port Otago Limited appealed to the Court of Appeal against a decision of the High Court. The High Court had allowed an appeal by the Environmental Defence Society Incorporated against an interim decision of the Environment Court. The Environment Court had recommended an amendment to a regional policy statement (RPS) which was under consideration by the Otago Regional Council. The RPS in question related to the Otago Harbour. The appellant, Port Otago, operates ports in the Otago Harbour. It submitted that the RPS, as recommended by the Environment Court, failed to give effect to the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS). The NZCPS requires adverse effects in areas of outstanding natural character to be avoided. The appellant argued that the RPS, as recommended, provided for adverse effects in such areas to be avoided, remedied or mitigated, rather than avoided. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. It held that the alternative wording for the policy in question in the RPS (whether or not modified in the manner suggested by the Environment Court) failed to give effect to the environmental bottom lines set by the NZCPS avoidance policies in the manner required by the Supreme Court in Environmental Defence Society Incorporated v The New Zealand King Salmon Company Limited. The RPS failed to give effect to the NZCPS because it provided for adverse effects in areas of outstanding natural character to be avoided, remedied or mitigated, rather than avoided. The wording suggested by the Environment Court invited a decision-maker instead to reach a broad judgment, potentially permitting (rather than avoiding — that is, preventing the occurrence of) adverse effects of activities on natural character in areas of the coastal environment with outstanding character (and significant adverse effects on natural character in other areas of the coastal environment). The Court of Appeal held that the appeal must be dismissed. The appellant must pay the first, second and third respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis plus usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established