PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA616/2008
[2009] NZCA 611

BETWEENPAE (NEW ZEALAND) LTD


Appellant

ANDMARK DAVID BROSNAHAN, MICHAEL RALPH CARTER, WAYNE ALBANY PATTINSON


Respondents

CA755/2008

AND BETWEEN  MARK DAVID BROSNAHAN


First Appellant

ANDMICHAEL RALPH CARTER


Second Appellant

ANDWAYNE ALBANY PATTINSON


Third Appellant

ANDPAE (NEW ZEALAND) LTD


Respondent

Hearing:18 November 2009

Court:Ellen France, Gendall and Harrison JJ

Counsel:D M Salmon and P W O’Neil for PAE (New Zealand) Ltd


A S Butler and M F Mabbett for Brosnahan & others

Judgment:21 December 2009 at 2.15 pm 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal and cross-appeal are dismissed.

BNo order as to costs.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]

High Court  [3]

(1)      Contractual Remedies Act

(a)      Contractual Provisions  [9]

(b)      Section 4(1)  [13]

(c)      Appeal  [16]

(d)      Decision  [19]

(2)      Fair Trading Act

(a)      Introduction  [26]

(b)      Decision

(i)       Unreasonable Reliance  [33]

(ii)      Implied Warranty  [41]

Renewal  [49]

Cross-Appeal

Introduction [55]

Interest  [57]

Costs[65]

Result  [81]

Introduction

[1]        This appeal and cross-appeal from decisions in the High Court relate to a claim for damages arising from an agreement for sale and purchase of shares.

[2]        The appeal raises issues about the effect of what is known as an entire agreement clause and the relationship between the Contractual Remedies Act 1979 (CRA) and the Fair Trading Act 1986 (FTA).  Secondary issues derive from the interpretation of a renewal provision in the agreement, giving rise to a counterclaim for damages.  The cross-appeal relates to a consequential award of interest and costs.

High Court

[3]        Messrs Wayne Pattinson, Michael Carter and Mark Brosnahan (“the directors”) owned the shareholding in and were directors of Central Property Services Ltd (CPS), a maintenance company based in Palmerston North.  PAE (New Zealand) Ltd (PAE) is a facilities management company in Lower Hutt.  In April 2004 PAE entered into a written agreement to purchase all the directors’ 100 shares in CPS for $1.25m.  Execution of the agreement followed a process of negotiations commencing in November 2003.  In that intervening period the directors had made representations about CPS’s turnover and profitability and provided copies of financial statements.

[4]        PAE issued proceedings against the directors in 2005, alleging that they made misrepresentations during the negotiation period on which it relied in deciding to enter into the agreement.   The company claimed consequential loss of $964,000, representing the difference between the purchase price of $1.25m and the true value of CPS’s shares of $286,000.  PAE pleaded four discrete claims for fraud, misrepresentation, breach of warranty and misleading or deceptive conduct.

[5]        The directors denied liability and counterclaimed for damages of $350,000.  The agreement obliged PAE to pay this additional amount if CPS renewed a contract with Housing New Zealand (the HNZ contract) on certain terms.

[6]        Mallon J delivered a lengthy judgment following trial in the High Court at Wellington in September 2007: PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan HC WN CIV 2005-485-843 10 September 2008.  In summary the Judge found…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 611
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, PAE (New Zealand) Ltd initiated an appeal against the decisions of the High Court in the case of PAE (New Zealand) Ltd v Brosnahan. The respondents, Mark Brosnahan, Michael Ralph Carter, and Wayne Albany Pattinson, filed a cross-appeal. The central dispute involved the sale and purchase agreement of shares in Central Property Services Ltd (CPS). PAE claimed damages for misrepresentation, while the directors counterclaimed for damages. The Court of Appeal addressed the effect of an entire agreement clause, the relationship between the Contractual Remedies Act 1979 and the Fair Trading Act 1986, and the interpretation of a renewal provision in the agreement.

The Court of Appeal found that the entire agreement clause effectively precluded PAE's misrepresentation claim under the Contractual Remedies Act. The Court determined that the clause was fair and reasonable, considering the parties' relative bargaining positions and access to legal advice. The directors had made significant errors in CPS's financial statements, but these factors did not negate the effect of the entire agreement clause. The Court also held that PAE's Fair Trading Act claim failed because the directors' conduct, while misleading and deceptive, did not cause PAE's loss due to PAE's unreasonable reliance on the directors' representations.

Furthermore, the Court of Appeal rejected PAE's appeal against the High Court's finding on the directors' counterclaim for renewal of a contract with Housing New Zealand. The Court found that the renewal provision was satisfied, and PAE's argument against the renewal was without merit. Lastly, the Court dismissed the directors' cross-appeal against the decision on interest and costs, affirming the High Court's reasoning.

Ultimately, the Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal and the cross-appeal, with each party bearing its own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established