Primary Services New Zealand Ltd v Colombo Projects Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2019-409-000404

[2020] NZHC 549

BETWEEN

PRIMARY SERVICES NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

COLOMBO PROJECTS LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

ANDREW MICHAEL FONAGY

Second Defendant

AND

JOHN RICHMOND PAYNTER

Third Defendant

Hearing: 3 March 2020

Appearances:

J L Bates for Plaintiff

M D Pascariu and E I D Fox for Second Defendant

Judgment:

18 March 2020


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE PAULSEN


This judgment was delivered by me on 18 March 2020 at 2.30 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

PRIMARY SERVICES NEW ZEALAND LTD v FONAGY [2020] NZHC 549 [18 March 2020]

Introduction

[1]    Colombo Projects Ltd (Colombo) and Primary Services New Zealand Ltd (Primary) entered into a loan facility agreement dated 21 December 2015 (the LFA) pursuant to which Primary made advances to Colombo for a development project at 818 Colombo Street, Christchurch (818 Colombo). Colombo’s obligations were guaranteed by Andrew Fonagy (Mr Fonagy) and John Paynter (Mr Paynter). Colombo defaulted under the LFA. Primary called up the loan and made demand upon Colombo, Mr Fonagy and Mr Paynter for payment. No payment has been made.

[2]    Primary has already  obtained  summary  judgment  against  Colombo  and Mr Paynter. It now seeks summary judgment against Mr Fonagy. Mr Fonagy opposes summary judgment. He says he is not liable on his guarantee or has a set-off and/or counterclaim against Primary because of misrepresentations made to him by Primary’s agent, David Short, without which he would not have provided his guarantee.

[3]Specifically, Mr Fonagy alleges Mr Short represented to him that:

(a)Mr Short was a lawyer who had been involved in property deals all the time; and

(b)Mr Short had access to funds, including through Primary and the Jocelyn Grattan Charitable Trust (JGCT), to fund the development of 818 Colombo to completion.

[4]    Mr Fonagy says these representations were false because Mr Short was no longer a practicing lawyer and Mr Short did not have the ability and declined to provide funding necessary to complete the project.

[5]Primary raises several matters in response but principally, that:

(a)The representations were not made; and

(b)The LFA contained an entire agreement clause which is conclusive and by which any previous agreements or understandings between the parties were superseded.

Facts

[6]    Mr Paynter and Mr Fonagy incorporated a company called 818 Central Ltd (Central) which acquired 818 Colombo to develop into a multi-storey unit title development. The purchase was funded by:

(a)a $1,250,000 loan from MG & SJ Howard Limited (Howard), secured by a first ranking mortgage; and

(b)a $1,000,000 loan from Frank Colombo Ltd (Frank), secured by a second ranking mortgage.

[7]    Both the Howard and Frank loans were also secured by the personal guarantees of Mr Fonagy and Mr Paynter.

[8]    In June 2015, Central entered into an agreement to lease units to Quest Hotels following completion of the project.

[9]    The Howard loan went into default. On 21 September 2015, Howard…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Primary Services New Zealand Ltd v Colombo Projects Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 549
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Primary Services New Zealand Limited sought summary judgment against Andrew Fonagy, who had guaranteed a loan facility agreement made between Primary and Colombo Projects Limited. The loan was intended to fund the development of 818 Colombo Street, Christchurch. Fonagy opposed the summary judgment, alleging that he had relied on false representations made by David Short, an agent for Primary, that induced him to give his guarantee. The court found that Fonagy had not provided an evidential basis for his defence and dismissed his opposition to the summary judgment application. The court held that the representations were not made and that the entire agreement clause in the loan facility agreement was conclusive, superseding any prior agreements or understandings.

The court found that Primary had satisfied the burden of proving that Fonagy had no defence to its claim. The court considered the surrounding circumstances, contemporaneous correspondence, the parties' agreements, and evidence from other persons present at the meeting where the representations were allegedly made. The court found that none of the evidence supported Fonagy's claim that the representations were made.

The court also considered the entire agreement clause in the loan facility agreement, which provided that the agreement and other finance documents constituted the entire agreement between the parties and superseded all previous agreements or understandings. The court held that it was fair and reasonable to regard the entire agreement clause as conclusive, and that it was irrelevant whether the representations were made because the parties had agreed that any prior agreements or understandings were superseded.

Finally, the court considered an application by Primary to cross-examine Fonagy and issue subpoenas, which was filed in response to a protest to jurisdiction filed by Ora Trustees Ltd. The court found that Primary was not justified in pursuing the subpoena application when Ora's general manager corrected his earlier affidavit, and that Fonagy was the successful party and entitled to costs. The court awarded Fonagy costs of $6,613 on a 2B basis.