Fonterra Co-Operative Group Ltd v McIntyre and Williamson Partnership

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA736/2015
[2016] NZCA 538

BETWEEN

FONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED
Appellant

AND

MCINTYRE AND WILLIAMSON PARTNERSHIP AND ORS
Respondents

Hearing:

13 and 14 September 2016

Court:

Randerson, Winkelmann and Brown JJ

Counsel:

J E Hodder QC, D T Street and H K Wham for Appellant
D J Goddard QC and B M Russell for Respondents

Judgment:

16 November 2016 at 2.15pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

B    The appellant must pay the respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We allow for second counsel. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Randerson J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
The issues
The facts in more detail

Events leading to the sale agreement between Fonterra and the receivers
The terms of the sale agreement with the receivers
The meetings on 15 and 20 June
Fonterra’s letter of offer and the information pack
The application forms
The Milk Supply Agreements
Approval under the Commerce Act 1986 and issue of shares

The statutory scheme
Fonterra’s Constitution
Question one: Were the respondents “new entrants” for the purposes of s 106 of DIRA?  Or were they supplying milk to Fonterra on a basis other than as “new entrants”?

Fonterra’s argument
The Judge’s approach
Question one — discussion

Question two: If the respondents were “new entrants” within s 106, did Fonterra breach s 106 in offering the respondents the terms of supply set out in the Milk Supply Agreements signed by the respondents?

The Judge’s approach
Fonterra’s submissions
Question two — discussion

Question three: Did Fonterra advise the respondents about the extent of the respondents’ ability to buy shares and to supply milk on a shared up basis in terms or to the effect pleaded in paragraph 31 of the Amended Statement of Claim, or as pleaded in paragraph 31 of the Amended Statement of Defence?
Question four: Was such advice misleading and deceptive conduct in trade in breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986?

The pleadings
The Judge’s factual findings
The first representation — not legally possible for the respondents to acquire shares
The second representation — inability of other Fonterra shareholders to buy shares
Fonterra’s submissions on appeal
Our assessment
Remaining issues on Questions three and four

Question five: Did Fonterra’s advice to the respondents about the extent of the respondents’ ability to buy shares and supply milk on a shared up basis amount to a misrepresentation in terms of s 6 of the Contractual Remedies Act 1979?
Result

[1]
[7]
[10]

[10]
[31]
[36]
[39]
[44]
[55]
[58]
[61]
[76]

[83]
[83]
[84]
[89]

[99]
[101]
[106]
[109]

[131]

[131]
[131]
[135]

[137]

[142]
[150]
[153]
[172]

[182]
[184]

Introduction

  1. The respondents are dairy farmers in South Canterbury and North Otago.  In the 2011/12 dairy season they were all suppliers of raw milk to New Zealand Dairies Ltd (NZDL), which processed the milk through its plant at Studholme, South Canterbury.

  2. On 17 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fonterra Co-Operative Group Ltd v McIntyre and Williamson Pa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 538
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal was brought by Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited against the McIntyre and Williamson Partnership and others (the respondents). The appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal. The appeal was about whether Fonterra had breached s 106 of the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act 2001 by offering the respondents less favourable terms of milk supply. The respondents had supplied milk to New Zealand Dairies Ltd (NZDL) but NZDL went into receivership in May 2012. Fonterra was the successful tenderer for the Studholme plant, which processed the milk. The sale was conditional on the respondent suppliers entering into Milk Supply Agreements committing their milk supply to Fonterra for a six-year period. The respondents claimed that Fonterra had breached s 106 by discriminating against them as "new entrants" in respect of the terms of supply. Section 106 provides that Fonterra is required to ensure that the terms of supply that apply to a new entrant are the same as the terms that apply to a shareholding farmer in the same circumstances or differ only to reflect different circumstances. The respondents also alleged that pre-contractual statements made by Fonterra representatives at meetings on 15 and 20 June 2012 constituted misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 and amounted to misrepresentations in breach of s 6 of the Contractual Remedies Act 1979. The Court of Appeal found that the respondents were new entrants for the purposes of s 106. The respondents were not in any doubt about the actual terms offered and that they differed from those applying to suppliers already on Growth Contracts with Fonterra. The respondents were told at the June meetings that they had no entitlement to commence supply in the 2012/13 season on a fully shared up basis because they were outside the application period. There was no written record of the respondents being told it was "legally impossible" for them to share up in the first season. The respondents were also told at the 20 June meeting there was a moratorium on the issue of shares to existing shareholders until after the expected commencement of the TAF scheme. The Court of Appeal found that the respondents were misled on this issue and that a breach of s 9 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 was established. The Court of Appeal concluded that the appeal was dismissed and Fonterra must pay the respondents costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established