NZDSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2021-485-595

[2022] NZHC 716

UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016 and the Declaratory Judgments Act 1908

IN THE MATTER

of the making and amendment of the COVID-19 Public Health Response

(Vaccinations) Order 2021 under s 11 of the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act

BETWEEN

NZDSOS INC

First Applicant

NZTSOS INC

Second Applicant

AND

MINISTER FOR COVID-19 RESPONSE

First Respondent

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF HEALTH

Second Respondent

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Third Respondent

Hearing: 3, 4 and 7 March 2022

Appearances:

W C Pyke and N T C Batts for the First Applicant S K Green for the Second Applicant

D Jones and R M McMenamin for the Respondents

Judgment:

8 April 2022


JUDGMENT OF COOKE J


NZDSOS INC v MINISTER FOR COVID-19 RESPONSE [2022] NZHC 716 [8 April 2022]

Table of Contents

The background[4]

Nature of the claims[35]

Is the s 11 right an absolute right?[40]

The arguments[43]

Assessment[46]

Is the limit of the right by the Order demonstrably justified?[56]

How the Bill of Rights directly controls the exercise of power[57]

Framework for assessing justification[65]

Justification for the health sector mandate[70]

Justification for education sector mandate[77]

The contested issues[83]

The evaluation of the expert evidence[84]

First Disputed Issue : Vaccine effectiveness in reducing transmission[94]

Second Disputed Issue : Safety of the Pfizer vaccine[110]

Third Disputed Issue : Adverse implications of mandate[120]

Conclusions[130]

Challenge to exemption criteria[145]

Summary of the Court’s conclusions[155]

[1]                  In this proceeding NZDSOS Inc, an incorporated society representing health practitioners who are opposed to vaccination (the first applicant), and NZTSOS, an incorporated society made up primarily of teachers and educators who are opposed to vaccination (the second applicant), challenge orders that were made under the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020 (the Act) imposing mandatory vaccination for workers in the health and disability, and education sectors.

[2]                  The challenges have been partly addressed at earlier hearings of the Court. By judgment dated 12 November 2021 Palmer J heard and dismissed the claim that the requirement to be vaccinated as established by the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021 (the Order) was not within the empowering provisions of the Act.1 In addition, by judgment dated 12 November 2021 Palmer J dismissed an application for interim relief directed to the remaining claims.2  The remaining claims

— including the claim that the Order is invalid as it is not a reasonable and demonstrably justified limit of rights under the New Zealand Bill of Right Act 1990 (the Bill of Rights) — were heard by me in March and are the subject of this judgment.


1      Four Midwives, NZDSOS Inc and NZTSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response [2021] NZHC 3064.

2      NZDSOS Inc and NZTSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response [2021] NZHC 3071.

[3]                  After the hearing before me the Prime Minister announced that the vaccine mandates imposed by the Order had been reviewed, and that a mandate would no longer exist…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NZDSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 716
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, NZDSOS Inc and NZTSOS Inc, challenged the validity of COVID-19 vaccine mandates imposed by the Minister for COVID-19 Response under the COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020. The applicants, representing health and education sector workers opposed to vaccination, argued that the mandates violated their right to refuse medical treatment under section 11 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990. The Crown argued that the mandates were a reasonable and demonstrably justified limit of the right under section 5 of the Bill of Rights. The court dismissed the applicants' claims, finding that the mandates were justified at the time they were implemented in October 2021, but that the emergence of the Omicron variant had changed the circumstances. The court noted that the government had already revoked the education mandate and was reviewing the health mandate, and that further review may be necessary. The court held that the mandates could only be justified as emergency measures in response to an exceptional and temporary threat, and that the changing circumstances may mean that a narrower mandate may be necessary. The court also rejected the applicants' challenge to the exemption criteria, finding that the criteria were based on clinical grounds and were not applied unreasonably.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established