Nztsos Incorporated v Minister for COVID-19 Response

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 36/2024
 [2024] NZSC 83
BETWEEN

NZTSOS INCORPORATED
Applicant

AND

MINISTER FOR COVID-19 RESPONSE
First Respondent

AND

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF HEALTH
Second Respondent

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Third Respondent

Court:

Glazebrook, Ellen France and Miller JJ

Counsel:

M I Hague for Applicant
D Jones and O Kiel for Respondents

Judgment:

30 July 2024

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

BThe applicant must pay the respondents one set of costs of $2,500.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. The applicant represents education sector workers who challenge the lawfulness of the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021.  The Order extended the vaccine mandate to certain education sector workers on 25 October 2021.[1]  That mandate was later revoked, insofar as it applied to the education sector, on 4 April 2022.[2]  The applicant contended that it was ultra vires the empowering legislation,[3] that it was unjustified, and that criteria for exemptions were too strict.

    [1]As amended by COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Amendment Order (No 3) 2021, cl 14.

    [2]As amended by COVID-19 Public Health Response (Protection Framework and Vaccinations) Amendment Order 2022, cl 26.

    [3]COVID-19 Public Health Response Act 2020.

  2. The applicant failed in the High Court and Court of Appeal.[4]  Both Courts were satisfied that the mandate was lawful and justified and the exemption criteria were not too strict.[5]  The applicant now seeks leave to appeal to this Court.

    [4]NZDSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response [2022] NZHC 716, (2022) 18 NZELR 833 (Cooke J) [HC judgment]; and NZTSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response [2024] NZCA 74 (Gilbert, Collins and Goddard JJ) [CA judgment].

    [5]HC judgment, above n 4, at [138], [144] and [154]; and CA judgment, above n 4, at [30], [80], [84] and [93].

  3. The applicant wishes to argue that:

    (a)it is not clear on the New Zealand authorities how an “overly broad and unquantifiable” objective could justify a limitation on a right protected under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZBORA);

    (b)it is not clear on the New Zealand authorities to what degree the state must satisfy a court that a less rights-limiting alternative is not reasonably available; and

    (c)it is not clear on the New Zealand authorities how the “precautionary principle” should be applied to a s 5 NZBORA analysis.

  4. In addition, the applicant says there was a substantial miscarriage of justice because the Crown failed to disclose facts that the applicant says were material, and an expert witness for the Crown failed to disclose a report that the applicant says was relevant and contradicted the witness’s conclusions.

  1. We are not persuaded that the application for leave to appeal raises a question of general or public importance.[6]  Rather, we consider that the proposed appeal is in substance a challenge to the correctness of the judgments below, without raising any point of significant principle divorced from the particular facts.  We add that whether there is a question of general or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nztsos Incorporated v Minister for COVID-19 Response and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZSC 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of NZTSOS Incorporated v Minister for COVID-19 Response, the Supreme Court of New Zealand considered an application for leave to appeal by NZTSOS Incorporated, which represents education sector workers. The applicant challenged the COVID-19 Public Health Response (Vaccinations) Order 2021, which extended the vaccine mandate to certain education sector workers. The applicant argued that the mandate was unlawful, unjustified, and had too strict exemption criteria. The High Court and the Court of Appeal had previously rejected the applicant's claims, and the applicant sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. The applicant proposed to argue several points, including the application of the precautionary principle, the degree of proof required for less restrictive alternatives, and the clarity of the New Zealand authorities on overly broad and unquantifiable objectives.

The Supreme Court held that the application for leave to appeal did not raise a question of general or public importance. The court considered the proposed appeal to be a challenge to the correctness of the lower courts' judgments rather than a significant point of principle. The court also found that there was no substantial miscarriage of justice, as the issues of disclosure and expert evidence turned on contested views about the relevance and meaning of certain studies and information. The Supreme Court was not persuaded that these issues warranted a second appeal, especially considering that the mandate had been removed over two years prior. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondents one set of costs amounting to $2,500.

The Supreme Court's decision underscores the importance of demonstrating that an appeal raises a question of significant principle or general public importance. In this case, the applicant's arguments seemed to focus on the correctness of the lower courts' decisions rather than on broader legal principles. Furthermore, the court highlighted that potential issues of disclosure and expert evidence did not appear to warrant a second appeal, particularly given the passage of time since the mandate was removed. This case serves as a reminder of the stringent criteria that must be met for leave to appeal to be granted to the Supreme Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established