Borrowdale v Director-General of Health

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA520/2020
 [2021] NZCA 520

BETWEEN

ANDREW BORROWDALE
Appellant

AND

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF HEALTH
First Respondent

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Second Respondent

NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY
Intervener

Hearing:

6–7 July 2021

Court:

French, Cooper and Collins JJ

Counsel:

J A Farmer QC and L C A Farmer for Appellant
U R Jagose QC and V McCall for Respondents
T C Stephens, J B Orpin-Dowell and M R G van Alphen Fyfe for Intervener

Judgment:

2 November 2021 at 2.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThere is no order for costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Collins J)

PART I

INTRODUCTION

Questions addressed by this appeal

  1. Two questions are addressed in this judgment.  The first asks whether s 70(1)(f) and (m) of the Health Act 1956 (the Act) allowed the Director-General of Health (the Director-General) to issue three Orders that required:

    (a)all premises in New Zealand to be closed except those referred to as “essential businesses”;[1]

    (b)people not to congregate in outdoor places unless they maintained “physical distancing”;[2]

    (c)all people to remain at their place of residence except as permitted.[3]

    [1]This was contained in the First Health Act Order.  We explain how “essential businesses” were defined at [6] and [72(d)] below.

    [2]This was contained in the First Health Act Order.  We explain how “physical distancing” was defined at [7] and [72(e)] below.

    [3]This was contained in the Second and Third Health Act Orders.  We explain the exceptions at [8]–[9] and [78] below.

  2. The second question asks whether the Director-General unlawfully delegated to other officials the decisions concerning what businesses could remain open pursuant to the Orders he made under s 70(1)(m) of the Act.

  3. The Orders in question came into force on 25 March, 3 April and 27 April 2020 and were an integral part of New Zealand’s effort to prevent the outbreak and spread of COVID-19.

The statutory powers

  1. We shall examine s 70(1)(f) and (m) of the Act in Parts II and III of this judgment.  At this juncture we set out the key parts of those subsections in order to provide context to the two questions we have explained at [1] and [2]:

    70       Special powers of medical officer of health

    (1)For the purpose of preventing the outbreak or spread of any infectious disease, the medical officer of health may from time to time, if authorised to do so by the Minister or if a state of emergency has been declared under the Civil Defence Emergency Management Act 2002 or while an epidemic notice is in force,—

    …

    (f)require persons, … to be isolated, quarantined, … as he thinks fit:

    …

    (m)by order …

    (i)require to be closed, until further order or for a fixed period, all premises within the district (or a stated area of the district) of any stated kind or description:

    …

    (iii)forbid people to congregate in outdoor places…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borrowdale v Director-General of Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Dr Andrew Borrowdale challenged the validity of three Orders made by the Director-General of Health during the COVID-19 pandemic in New Zealand. The Orders required the closure of all premises in New Zealand except for essential businesses, prohibited people from congregating in outdoor places of amusement or recreation, and required all persons in New Zealand to be isolated or quarantined by remaining in their current place of residence. Dr Borrowdale argued that the Director-General exceeded his powers under the Health Act 1956 and that the Director-General unlawfully delegated to other officials the decisions concerning what businesses could remain open. The High Court dismissed Dr Borrowdale's claims. The Court of Appeal also dismissed the appeal, finding that the Director-General did not unlawfully delegate his powers to determine what constituted essential businesses. However, the Court found that the subsequent exemptions to the First Health Act Order that allowed some businesses to remain open were probably ultra vires. The appeal was dismissed, and no order for costs was made due to the significant public importance of the issues raised.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established