NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership v Malkhasian

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TAURANGA MOANA ROHE

CIV-2019-470-119

[2020] NZHC 2147

BETWEEN NZ BRICK DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Appellant

AND

ANDREW SHAUNT MALKHASIAN and JEAN ANN MALKHASIAN

Respondents

Hearing: 30 July 2020

Counsel:

J J K Spring for Appellant

V A Whitfield and M Myer for Respondents

Judgment:

24 August 2020


JUDGMENT OF BREWER J


This judgment was delivered by me on 24 August 2020 at 4:00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Minter Ellison Rudd Watts (Auckland) for Appellant Gallie Miles (Te Awamutu) for Respondents

NZ BRICK DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP v MALKHASIAN [2020] NZHC 2147 [24 August 2020]

Introduction

[1]    The respondents are suing a number of defendants in respect of a building project. They applied for third party discovery against the appellant. The appellant supplied bricks to one of the parties being sued by the respondents and the respondents wanted documents relating to that supply.

[2]    The appellant accepted it should make discovery. A District Court Judge, by consent, ordered that informal discovery would take place. However, it did not go smoothly. Mr Spring, counsel for the appellant, took the view that only documents relevant to the respondents’ case should be discovered and Ms Whitfield, counsel for the respondents, took the view that assessment for relevance was not for Mr Spring and that all documents falling within the categories described in the application for third party discovery should be disclosed.

[3]    Eventually, after much toing and froing, discovery was completed and the appellant applied to the District Court for an order for its actual and reasonable costs in making third party discovery. It put its costs as $26,459.60. This application was opposed by the respondents who argued that the appellant’s conduct disqualified it from receiving any costs and instead the appellant should pay the respondents’ costs of $14,038.50.

[4]    The question of costs was decided by Judge PG Mabey QC.1 His Honour took the view that the appellant took “an unnecessarily obstructive and adversarial approach … to what was a straightforward issue of third party discovery”.2

[5]The Judge held that because of the appellant’s approach:

[9]        The Court was required to intervene and make directions for compliance. It was observed that any issues of relevance are not for a subjective assessment of the second respondent which could bring those matters to Court for assessment.

[10]      That very situation has arisen between the plaintiffs and second defendant in the litigation whereby with co-operation between counsel the


1      Malkhasian v Home Builders BOP Ltd & Ors DC Tauranga CIV-2017-070-1030, 23 October 2019 (Ruling 2).

2 At [2].

Court has determined issues of relevance and privilege in relation to documents and the parties can move on secure in the knowledge that no documents have been improperly withheld.

[11]      The second respondent did not choose to take that approach and I consider it was obstructive against reasonable suggestions made by the plaintiffs.

[12]      A number of case…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership v Malkhasian and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The respondents, Andrew Shaunt Malkhasian and Jean Ann Malkhasian, are suing multiple defendants in relation to a building project. They sought third party discovery from the appellant, NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership, who had supplied bricks to one of the parties being sued. The appellant agreed to make discovery but disagreed with the respondents about the scope of the discovery. The appellant argued that only documents relevant to the respondents’ case should be disclosed, while the respondents argued that all documents falling within the categories described in the application for third party discovery should be disclosed. The appellant applied for an order for its actual and reasonable costs in making third party discovery, which was opposed by the respondents. The District Court Judge, PG Mabey QC, decided that the appellant should be denied its costs and ordered the appellant to pay the respondents' costs of $7,500. The appellant appealed against this decision.

The appeal raises the issue of whether the District Court Judge rightly characterised the appellant’s approach to discovery and, if so, whether it was available to him in the exercise of his discretion to order the appellant to pay the respondents' costs. The appellant argues that it is entitled to its costs of $26,459.60 as it took a prompt, comprehensive, and obliging approach to discovery. The respondents argue that the appellant took an unnecessarily obstructive and adversarial approach and should not be entitled to its costs. The court found that the appellant took an unreasonably pedantic approach to providing discovery, which resulted in the exercise becoming disproportionate to the tailored discovery ordered. However, the court found that the appellant’s conduct was not so disqualifying as to make it in the interests of justice that the party forfeits its right to costs and is liable to contribute to the costs of the party seeking discovery. The court ordered that the appeal is allowed, the District Court’s ruling on costs is quashed, and the respondents must pay the appellant $10,000 as its reasonable costs in the non-party discovery. The appellant is entitled to its costs on this appeal on a 2B basis.