Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA37/2021
 [2021] NZCA 240

BETWEEN

ANDREW SHAUNT MALKHASIAN AND JEAN ANN MALKHASIAN
Applicants

AND

NZ BRICK DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Respondent

Court:

Cooper and Courtney JJ

Counsel:

V A Whitfield for Applicants
J E Standage and JJK Spring for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

8 June 2021 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The application for leave to appeal is granted. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Courtney J)

Introduction

  1. In District Court proceedings arising out of a construction contract, Mr and Mrs Malkhasian obtained an order for third party discovery against NZ Brick Distributors Ltd (NZBD).  Judge Mabey QC refused to make a costs order in favour of NZBD because of its conduct in complying with the order.  Instead he awarded costs to Mr and Mrs Malkhasian.[1]  On appeal, Brewer J overturned the District Court decision and awarded NZBD costs.[2]

    [1]Malkhasian v Home Builders BOP Ltd DC Tauranga CIV-2017-070-1030, 23 October 2019 [District Court decision].

  2. A High Court decision on appeal from the District Court is final unless a party obtains leave to appeal to this Court.[3]  Applicants are required to apply for leave first from the High Court and, failing that, from this Court.[4]  Brewer J refused leave to appeal.[5]  Mr and Mrs Malkhasian seek leave to appeal to this Court.

    [3]Senior Courts Act 2016, s 60(1).

    [4]Section 60(2).

    [5]Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Ltd Partnership HC Tauranga CIV-2019-470-119, 15 December 2020 (Minute of Brewer J).

  3. The test for leave to bring a second appeal is settled.  The appeal must raise some question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal.[6]

  4. The applicants say that there are bona fide and serious issues arising on the proposed appeal in that:

    (a)there is conflict between the District Court and High Court as to the correct approach to non-party costs where there has been non‑compliance by the non-party and there is a bona fide and serious argument that the High Court Judge wrongly applied the settled principles;

    (b)there is a significant public interest in resolving the approach taken by the High Court because of the risk it will be applied to future decisions involving non-party costs; and

    (c)there is a personal interest that justifies a second appeal — the outcome in the High Court was that costs of $8,808 were awarded to the non‑party, notwithstanding that the non-party had itself assessed the reasonable costs of compliance at $1,192.

The case in the lower courts

  1. The order for non-party discovery related to the supply of bricks by NZBD, the value of which was about $16,000.  Mr and Mrs Malkhasian agreed to pay NZBD’s reasonable costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership, the applicants, Mr. and Mrs. Malkhasian, sought leave to appeal a decision of the High Court which overturned a decision of the District Court and awarded costs to the respondent, NZ Brick Distributors Ltd Partnership. The applicants argued that the High Court had wrongly applied the settled principles of law in determining non-party costs where there had been non-compliance by the non-party, and that there was a significant public interest in resolving the approach taken by the High Court because of the risk it would be applied to future decisions involving non-party costs.

The court had to decide whether the applicants' proposed appeal raised some question of law or fact capable of bona fide and serious argument in a case involving some interest, public or private, of sufficient importance to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal. The applicants argued that there was a conflict between the District Court and High Court as to the correct approach to non-party costs, and that there was a significant public interest in resolving the approach taken by the High Court. The court found that the questions raised were of wider significance and considered that a further appeal was justified.

The court granted the application for leave to appeal and found that there were bona fide and serious issues arising on the proposed appeal. The court found that there appeared to be no authority addressing the approach to be taken where there had been non-compliance with a non-party discovery order, including whether it was open to the Court to award costs to the party seeking discovery in relation to the conduct of a non-party during the compliance stage of the discovery process, and if so, what kind of conduct would justify that approach. The court considered that a further appeal was justified to clarify these issues.

The final orders were that the application for leave to bring a further appeal was granted.

Background

Background to the litigation

In a construction contract dispute, Mr and Mrs Malkhasian obtained an order for third-party discovery against NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership (NZBD) in the District Court. The order related to the supply of bricks by NZBD valued at approximately $16,000. Mr and Mrs Malkhasian agreed to pay NZBD's reasonable costs in complying with the order, estimated by NZBD at $1,192. However, NZBD failed to comply with the order, as it believed it should only disclose documents it deemed relevant. This led to four case management conferences being required to enforce compliance, with 34 documents eventually being discovered. NZBD subsequently sought an order for its costs of $26,459.60. The exercise cost Mr and Mrs Malkhasian over $14,000. The District Court Judge found that NZBD had taken an "unnecessarily obstructive and adversarial approach" and refused to award costs to NZBD, instead awarding costs to Mr and Mrs Malkhasian of $7,500. NZBD appealed this decision, and the High Court Judge overturned the District Court's decision, awarding NZBD costs of $10,000.

The case began in the District Court, where Mr and Mrs Malkhasian obtained an order for third-party discovery against NZBD. Following the discovery process, the District Court awarded costs to Mr and Mrs Malkhasian. NZBD appealed this decision to the High Court, which overturned the District Court's decision and awarded costs to NZBD. Mr and Mrs Malkhasian subsequently sought leave to appeal the High Court's decision to the Court of Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is there a conflict between the District Court and High Court regarding the correct approach to non-party costs where there has been non-compliance by the non-party?
2. Is there a significant public interest in resolving the approach taken by the High Court due to the risk it will be applied to future decisions involving non-party costs?
3. Does the personal interest of the applicants justify a second appeal given the outcome in the High Court awarded costs of $8,808 to the non-party, despite the non-party estimating its reasonable costs of compliance at $1,192?

Held
1. There is a conflict between the District Court and High Court regarding the correct approach to non-party costs where there has been non-compliance by the non-party. The court concluded that the issue warrants clarification.
2. There is a significant public interest in resolving the approach taken by the High Court due to the risk it will be applied to future decisions involving non-party costs. The court found that this issue merits further consideration.
3. The personal interest of the applicants justifies a second appeal given the outcome in the High Court awarded costs of $8,808 to the non-party, despite the non-party estimating its reasonable costs of compliance at $1,192. The court determined that a second appeal is warranted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the established test for leave to bring a second appeal, which requires a question of law or fact capable of a bona fide and serious argument and a sufficient interest to outweigh the cost and delay of the further appeal. The Court examined the applicants' arguments, which included a conflict between the District Court and High Court on the approach to non-party costs in the event of non-compliance, a significant public interest in resolving this conflict, and a personal interest due to the disparity between awarded and estimated costs. The Court noted that the High Court had awarded costs of $8,808 to the non-party despite it estimating its reasonable costs at $1,192. The Court found that there appeared to be no authority addressing the approach to be taken in such cases, and the questions raised were of wider significance. Therefore, the Court granted the application for leave to appeal, allowing the applicants to bring a second appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The Court recognised the two-stage approach to non-party costs set out in Clear Communications Ltd v Telecom Corporation of NZ Ltd, where costs are determined first on the application itself and then on compliance with the order. The applicants argued that the High Court had wrongly conflated these stages and limited the Court's discretion by creating a threshold of "exceptional conduct" for awarding reasonable costs in the event of non-compliance. The Court considered this issue to be of wider significance and granted leave for the applicants to appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal held that the questions raised warranted further consideration and that a further appeal was justified to clarify the law in this area.