Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA37/2021
 [2024] NZCA 36

BETWEEN

ANDREW SHAUNT MALKHASIAN AND JEAN ANN MALKHASIAN
Appellants

AND

NZ BRICK DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Respondent

Hearing:

8 September 2022

Court:

Cooper P, Gilbert and Courtney JJ

Counsel:

V A Whitfield and M J Meier for Appellants
J J K Spring for Respondent

Judgment:

1 March 2024 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe High Court judgment is set aside.  The respondent must pay costs in the sum of $7,500 to the appellants in respect of their costs for the order for non‑party discovery in the District Court.

CThe respondent must pay the appellants’ costs in this Court calculated for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

DThe respondent must pay the appellants’ costs in the High Court calculated on a 2B basis, together with usual disbursements.  Any disagreement as to amount may be determined by that Court.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper P)

Introduction

  1. A non‑party is entitled to its actual, reasonable costs incurred in complying with a non‑party discovery order unless there exists good reason for it not to be awarded those costs.[1]  The present appeal addresses the principles to be applied where a non‑party, NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership (NZBD), has acted so as to significantly increase the costs of the discovery process.

Background

[1]Clear Communications Ltd v Telecom Corporation of NZ Ltd (1994) 8 PRNZ 200 (HC) at 201‑202.

  1. The appellants, Mr and Mrs Malkhasian, brought a proceeding in the District Court arising out of a construction contract.  The Malkhasians claimed there were defects in the construction works and that the builder provided incorrect invoices and overcharged them.  NZBD had supplied roughly $16,000 worth of bricks for the construction project.  On 19 December 2018, the Malkhasians obtained an order for non‑party discovery against NZBD.[2]    

    [2]Malkhasian v Home Builders BOP Ltd DC Tauranga CIV-2017-070-1030, 19 December 2018 [Minute of Judge Cameron].

  2. The non‑party discovery order was granted by consent.[3]  The order adopted the wording of the Malkhasians’ application and required NZBD to discover:

    1.4.1.1Any quotations or estimates provided by [NZBD] in relation to the supply of materials at [a residential address] ([NZBD’s] Works);

    1.4.1.2Any contract entered into between the first defendant and [NZBD] in relation to the [NZBD’s] Works;

    1.4.1.3Any and all communications and correspondence, including file notes, between the first defendant and/or second defendant and [NZBD] in relation to [NZBD’s] Works;

    1.4.1.4Copies of all invoices and/or credit notes issued by [NZBD] in relation to [NZBD’s] Works.

    [3]Malkhasian v Home Builders BOP Ltd DC Tauranga CIV-2017-070-1030, 23 October 2019 (Ruling 2) [District Court decision] at [1].

  3. The Malkhasians offered to pay $890 towards NZBD’s costs of filing a memorandum in relation to the application and also agreed to pay NZBD’s reasonable costs in complying with the order, which NZDB estimated to be $1,192.  The issue of costs was not settled prior to NZBD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Malkhasian v NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership involved a dispute between the appellants, Mr and Mrs Malkhasian, and the respondent, NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership (NZBD), over the costs incurred during a non-party discovery process in relation to a construction project. The Malkhasians had obtained a non-party discovery order against NZBD, which had supplied bricks to the project. The primary issue was whether NZBD was entitled to its actual costs incurred in complying with the discovery order, and if not, the extent to which it should contribute to the Malkhasians’ costs.

The Court of Appeal found that while NZBD was entitled to its reasonable costs, it had acted in an unreasonably pedantic manner, significantly escalating the costs. The Court held that NZBD's conduct was unjustified and that its entitlement to costs should be reduced accordingly. The appeal was allowed, the High Court judgment was set aside, and NZBD was ordered to pay the Malkhasians $7,500 in respect of their costs for the non-party discovery order in the District Court, as well as their costs in both the High Court and the Court of Appeal. The Court emphasised that while non-parties are generally entitled to their reasonable costs, they are not exempt from the consequences of conduct that unnecessarily increases costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants, Mr and Mrs Malkhasian, brought a proceeding in the District Court against Home Builders BOP Ltd arising from a construction contract. They claimed there were defects in the construction works and that the builder provided incorrect invoices and overcharged them. During the proceeding, NZ Brick Distributors Limited Partnership (NZBD), a supplier of bricks for the construction project, was ordered to give non-party discovery of documents related to the supply of bricks. NZBD initially provided seven documents but resisted providing further documents, asserting it had fully met its discovery obligations. The Malkhasians considered there must be more documents within the scope of the discovery order that had not been provided. This led to a series of case management conferences and disputes over costs and the scope of the discovery order. The District Court Judge eventually ordered NZBD to pay costs to the Malkhasians, finding NZBD's conduct unnecessarily increased the costs of the discovery process. The High Court later awarded NZBD its reasonable costs, a decision the Malkhasians now appeal.

The matter began in the District Court where the Malkhasians obtained an order for non-party discovery against NZBD. The non-party discovery order was granted by consent, and the Malkhasians agreed to pay NZBD's reasonable costs of compliance with the order. NZBD initially provided seven documents but resisted providing further documents, leading to disputes and multiple case management conferences. The District Court Judge found that NZBD had taken an unnecessarily obstructive and adversarial approach to the discovery process, resulting in the Malkhasians being awarded costs of $7,500. NZBD appealed to the High Court, which set aside the District Court's decision and awarded NZBD its reasonable costs of $10,000. The Malkhasians were granted leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and set aside the High Court judgment. The Court of Appeal ordered NZBD to pay the Malkhasians $7,500 for costs incurred in the District Court and ordered NZBD to pay the Malkhasians' costs of the appeal and the High Court proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the District Court Judge correctly found that NZBD's conduct in the discovery process justified denying it its costs and ordering it to contribute to the Malkhasians' costs.
2. Whether the High Court erred in concluding that NZBD's "unreasonably pedantic" approach did not disqualify it from receiving its costs.
3. Whether the Malkhasians are entitled to costs for steps they took in the proceeding after the discovery order was made, due to NZBD's conduct.
4. Whether the Malkhasians are entitled to their costs in the High Court on a 2B basis, as set out in their submissions.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal found that the District Court Judge correctly determined that NZBD's conduct in the discovery process justified denying it its costs and ordering it to contribute to the Malkhasians' costs.
2. The Court of Appeal held that the High Court erred in concluding that NZBD's "unreasonably pedantic" approach did not disqualify it from receiving its costs.
3. The Court of Appeal found that the Malkhasians are entitled to costs for steps they took in the proceeding after the discovery order was made, due to NZBD's conduct.
4. The Court of Appeal found that the Malkhasians are entitled to their costs in the High Court on a 2B basis, as set out in their submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal endorsed the traditional two-stage approach to assessing costs in non-party discovery applications, as outlined in Clear Communications Ltd v Telecom Corporation of NZ Ltd. The first stage involves the costs of the application itself, while the second stage concerns the costs of compliance with the discovery order. In the present case, the Court found that NZBD's conduct during the compliance stage significantly increased the costs for both parties, leading to the conclusion that the District Court Judge was correct in denying NZBD its costs and ordering it to contribute to the Malkhasians' costs.

The Court of Appeal disagreed with the High Court's finding that NZBD's "unreasonably pedantic" approach did not disqualify it from receiving its costs. The Court held that while NZBD's approach was wrong, it did not amount to deliberate obstruction or egregious failure to comply with court orders. Nevertheless, the Court found that NZBD's conduct led to an escalation of costs far beyond what could be considered reasonable, and it should not escape the consequences of its own conduct. The Court concluded that NZBD's entitlement to costs was only to its reasonable costs, which should be adjusted to reflect the increased costs incurred by the Malkhasians due to NZBD's conduct.

Regarding the Malkhasians' entitlement to costs for steps taken in the proceeding after the discovery order was made, the Court of Appeal found that NZBD's conduct caused them to incur considerable costs over a six-month period, which eclipsed any entitlement to costs that NZBD may have had. The Court held that it was reasonable for the Malkhasians to reject NZBD's escalating claims for costs while it adopted an unreasonable stance in respect of the scope of the order for discovery.

Lastly, the Court of Appeal found that the Malkhasians are entitled to their costs in the High Court on a 2B basis, as set out in their submissions. The Court held that any disagreement as to the amount may be determined by the High Court.