| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA424/2012 [2014] NZCA 512 |
| BETWEEN | NEW ZEALAND CARDS LIMITED |
| AND | COLIN RAMSAY |
| Hearing: | 22 October 2014 |
Court: | Miller, Heath and Dobson JJ |
Counsel: | No appearance for Appellant |
Judgment: | 23 October 2014 at 4.00 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal was dismissed at the hearing.
BCosts are reserved. The respondent is to file a memorandum in support of an application for costs by 29 October 2014. The appellant must file submissions by 12 November 2014. Costs will be determined on the papers.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Miller J)
This judgment addresses an appeal from the Employment Court[1] in respect of which leave has previously been given. The question is whether the facts as found by the Employment Court Judge could amount to a constructive dismissal on the basis of the duty and good faith under s 4(1)(A) of the Employment Relations Act 2000. Leave to appeal was granted in a judgment delivered on 28 June 2012.[2]
[1]New Zealand Cards Ltd v Ramsay [2012] NZEmpC 51.
Mr Beresford was permitted to represent New Zealand Cards Ltd on the leave application, but it was made clear to him that no fixture would be granted unless the Registrar was satisfied that the company was legally represented. That was reinforced in a minute of 8 August 2013, in which Wild J also directed that future communications with the Court had to come from a lawyer instructed by the company.
We observe that the company has pleaded impecuniosity in support of its attempts to appear by Mr Beresford rather than by counsel. So it is of moment to record that Stevens J dismissed applications to review the Registrar’s decisions declining to dispense with security and waive the setting down fee, finding in two judgments that financial hardship had not been established.[3]
[3]New Zealand Cards Ltd v Ramsay [2012] NZCA 456 (relating to security for costs) and New Zealand Cards Ltd v Ramsay [2013] NZCA 72 (relating to the setting down fee).
At various times the company has engaged counsel. We note that the case was filed by Lane Neave, and Mr Beck was subsequently briefed. He appeared on an unsuccessful stay application[4] and was briefed for the appeal.
The appeal was set down, initially for 20 February 2014, a fixture which had to be adjourned because the company proposed at a late juncture to change counsel, and then for 31 July 2014. On 23 June 2014 Mr Beck sought leave to withdraw. O’Regan P granted leave in a minute of 3 July. He indicated that having regard to the proximity of the fixture Mr Beresford could seek dispensation allowing him to represent the company at the fixture. Contrary to Mr Beresford’s recent claims, O’Regan P did not grant dispensation.
Mr Beresford then…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Cards Limited v Ramsay and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZCA 512
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the facts found by the Employment Court Judge could amount to a constructive dismissal under the Employment Relations Act 2000. The Court of Appeal examined the evidence and submissions to determine whether the Employment Court's findings were consistent with the statutory requirements for constructive dismissal. The Court was also required to consider whether the appellant's conduct in attempting to represent itself through a layperson, despite explicit instructions to the contrary, warranted any additional costs being awarded to the respondent. The Court found that the appellant's conduct did not justify an award of additional costs, as the dismissal of the appeal was a result of the appellant's failure to comply with the Court's orders, rather than any action by the respondent.
The Court of Appeal held that the Employment Court's findings were consistent with the statutory requirements for constructive dismissal and, as such, the appeal was dismissed. The Court emphasised the importance of following the Court's orders and the need for legal representation in proceedings before the Court of Appeal. The Court also noted that the appellant had been granted leave to appeal and had engaged counsel at various stages, but ultimately failed to file submissions and did not appear at the hearing. The Court found that the appellant's conduct did not warrant an award of additional costs to the respondent, as the dismissal of the appeal was a result of the appellant's failure to comply with the Court's orders, rather than any action by the respondent. The Court reserved costs pending an application by the respondent and submissions by the appellant, to be filed by specified dates.
In summary, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal brought by New Zealand Cards Limited against a decision of the Employment Court regarding a claim of constructive dismissal by Colin Ramsay. The Court found that the Employment Court's findings were consistent with the statutory requirements for constructive dismissal and dismissed the appeal due to the appellant's failure to comply with the Court's orders. The Court reserved costs pending an application by the respondent and submissions by the appellant, to be filed by specified dates.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Employment Court, where Colin Ramsay successfully claimed that he was constructively dismissed by New Zealand Cards Limited (NZCL). NZCL filed an appeal against the Employment Court's decision, and leave to appeal was granted. The appeal was initially set down for 20 February 2014 but was later adjourned to 31 July 2014. Mr Beck sought leave to withdraw from representing NZCL, which was granted on 3 July 2014. Mr Beresford then sought an adjournment, which was granted, and a fixture was set for October or November 2014. NZCL subsequently failed to file submissions, and the respondent was excused from filing submissions. On 1 October 2014, the registry notified NZCL that the matter would be called on 22 October 2014 and no adjournments would be granted. Mr Beresford responded by faxes and email, initially indicating that the appeal would be abandoned and then that he anticipated the appeal would be dismissed. The appeal was called on 22 October 2014, and Mr Wilson appeared by AVL from Christchurch, while there was no appearance for the appellant. The appeal was dismissed accordingly.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the facts as found by the Employment Court Judge could amount to a constructive dismissal on the basis of the duty and good faith under s 4(1)(A) of the Employment Relations Act 2000.
2. Whether the Court of Appeal should grant costs to the respondent due to the appellant's conduct during the appeal process.
Held
1. The appeal was dismissed. The Court of Appeal concluded that the facts as found by the Employment Court Judge did not amount to a constructive dismissal under s 4(1)(A) of the Employment Relations Act 2000.
2. The Court of Appeal reserved the question of costs and required the respondent to file a memorandum in support of an application for costs by 29 October 2014, with submissions from the appellant due by 12 November 2014.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal addressed the appeal from the Employment Court, focusing on whether the findings of the Employment Court Judge could constitute a constructive dismissal. The appeal was dismissed due to the appellant's failure to appear at the hearing, despite multiple opportunities and reminders to be legally represented. The Court of Appeal emphasized the necessity for the appellant to be represented by counsel, a requirement that was repeatedly ignored. The Court highlighted the procedural history where the appellant's attempts to represent itself or have the appeal adjourned were consistently denied. The appellant's conduct, including suggesting that the appeal might proceed in the Supreme Court after abandonment, did not satisfy the Court that the appeal should be entertained. The dismissal of the appeal was a direct consequence of the appellant's non-compliance with the Court's directions regarding legal representation. In terms of costs, the Court of Appeal reserved the decision, instructing the respondent to file a memorandum for costs, with the appellant having the opportunity to respond. The Court noted the respondent's counsel's assertion that the appellant had not genuinely attempted to attend the hearing, despite being available at the courthouse.