| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA424/2012 [2014] NZCA 580 |
| BETWEEN | NEW ZEALAND CARDS LIMITED |
| AND | COLIN RAMSAY |
| Court: | Miller, Heath and Dobson JJ |
Counsel: | No appearance for Appellant |
Judgment: (On the papers) | 1 December 2014 at 11.30 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe respondent’s application for increased costs is declined.
BThe appellant must pay the respondent’s costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis.
CThe quantum of the costs is $7,612.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Dobson J)
This appeal had a somewhat protracted history before it was dismissed in the absence of submissions in support of the appeal. The circumstances in which that occurred are explained in our judgment dismissing the appeal, delivered on 23 October 2014.[1] Costs were reserved pending memoranda.
We have subsequently received memoranda, first on behalf of the respondent dated 29 October 2014 seeking increased costs, and a reply on behalf of the appellant from Mr Beresford dated 12 November 2014.
For the respondent, Mr Wilson sought increased costs for pre-hearing steps in responding to the appeal on the basis that the appellant’s conduct, and in particular Mr Beresford’s conduct in failing to comply with directions from the Court, unnecessarily contributed to additional costs incurred on behalf of the respondent. Although the respondent was excused from the formal requirement to file submissions given the non-filing of submissions for the appellant, Mr Wilson has submitted that additional costs were incurred in monitoring Mr Beresford’s numerous contacts with the Registry, undertaking a measure of preparation for hearings that did not proceed in February and July 2014, and in considering earlier unsuccessful interlocutory applications by the appellant in July and August 2012 and January 2013.
Mr Wilson sought an uplift of 75 per cent on costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis for pre-hearing attendances, the effect of which would be to add $447.75 to the costs entitlement.[2]
[2]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, ss 53B and 53C.
Mr Beresford opposed the costs sought on the basis that the claims are excessive, often factually wrong and often spurious. Mr Beresford urged the Court to undertake a further inquiry as to the work actually done on behalf of the respondent by Mr Wilson, and also an inquiry into the failings of counsel and solicitors previously instructed by the appellant. If we were minded to accept Mr Beresford’s criticisms of those acting for him, they would not be relevant to quantification of the successful respondent’s costs entitlement. In any event, we are not inclined to accept that the criticisms Mr Beresford makes of counsels’ conduct had a material bearing on the pre-hearing steps where Mr Wilson claims that additional or unnecessary work was required on behalf of the respondent.
The largest component of the scale costs relates to preparation for hearing of the appeal, where band A for a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Cards Limited v Ramsay and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZCA 580
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal considered the respondent's argument that additional costs were incurred due to the appellant's conduct, specifically the failure to comply with directions from the Court. The respondent argued that additional costs were incurred in monitoring the appellant's contacts with the Registry, preparing for hearings that did not proceed, and considering unsuccessful interlocutory applications by the appellant. However, the Court of Appeal found that the additional work required on behalf of the respondent was balanced out by the lesser extent of work ordinarily reflected in the scale costs for preparation for hearing of the appeal. The Court of Appeal also rejected the appellant's criticisms of counsels' conduct, finding that they did not have a material bearing on the pre-hearing steps where additional work was required on behalf of the respondent.
The Court of Appeal's reasoning was based on the fact that the respondent did not have to file submissions, and therefore the level of work ordinarily reflected in the scale costs for preparation for hearing of the appeal was not required. The Court of Appeal also found that the claims for increased costs were excessive, often factually wrong, and often spurious. The Court of Appeal ordered costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis, but reduced the amount claimed for the preparation of the costs memorandum. The Court of Appeal rejected any further unsolicited submissions made by the appellant, finding that they did not justify departure from scale or warrant a departure from the Court's previous judgment.
The final orders of the Court of Appeal were that the respondent's application for increased costs was declined, and the appellant must pay the respondent's costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis. The quantum of the costs was set at $7,612, which was a reduction of $497.50 from the amount specified in the respondent's memorandum. The Court of Appeal also rejected any further unsolicited submissions made by the appellant. The costs were to be paid by the appellant to the respondent within 14 days of the date of the judgment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case had a protracted history and was dismissed in the absence of submissions in support of the appeal, as explained in the judgment dated 23 October 2014. The appeal was dismissed on the papers. Costs were initially reserved pending memoranda. The respondent's counsel, Mr Wilson, submitted on 29 October 2014 that increased costs should be awarded due to the appellant's conduct, particularly Mr Beresford's failure to comply with court directions. The appellant, Mr Beresford, responded on 12 November 2014, opposing the costs sought by the respondent. The Court of Appeal heard the arguments and subsequently decided on the costs to be awarded.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to increased costs for pre-hearing steps due to the appellant's conduct.
2. If so, what should be the quantum of the increased costs.
3. Whether the appellant's criticisms of the conduct of his previous counsel and solicitors are relevant to the quantification of the respondent's costs entitlement.
Held
1. The respondent is not entitled to increased costs for pre-hearing steps due to the appellant's conduct.
2. The quantum of the increased costs is determined to be $7,612, reflecting a reduction in the costs claimed for the preparation of the costs memorandum.
3. The appellant's criticisms of the conduct of his previous counsel and solicitors are not relevant to the quantification of the respondent's costs entitlement.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the respondent's application for increased costs, which was based on the appellant's conduct, particularly the appellant's failure to comply with directions from the Court. The respondent argued that additional costs were incurred due to the appellant's conduct, including monitoring his numerous contacts with the Registry, preparing for hearings that did not proceed, and considering interlocutory applications by the appellant. The respondent sought a 75% uplift on the costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis. The appellant opposed the claim for increased costs, arguing that the costs were excessive, factually incorrect, and spurious, and suggested that an inquiry into the failings of the appellant's previous counsel and solicitors was warranted.
The Court found that the respondent was excused from filing formal submissions due to the appellant's failure to file submissions in support of the appeal. The Court also noted that the respondent did not need to prepare a draft of submissions in response to the appeal, as formal submissions were not required. However, the Court concluded that the additional work required in other pre-hearing aspects balanced out the reduced work needed for preparing submissions. Consequently, the Court declined the application for increased costs.
Regarding the quantum of costs, the Court ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs as for a standard appeal on a band A basis, amounting to $7,612. This amount was determined by reducing the costs claimed for the preparation of the costs memorandum by half. The Court rejected the appellant's further unsolicited submissions, finding that the complaints about costs and not being heard did not justify any departure from the scale of costs.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a party's conduct contributes to additional costs for the opposing party in pre-hearing steps, the court will consider whether those additional costs are justified and whether they result in a net increase in costs. The court will also consider the relevance of criticisms of the conduct of previous counsel and solicitors to the quantification of costs. In this case, the Court found that the appellant's conduct did not result in a net increase in costs and that the criticisms of previous counsel and solicitors were not relevant to the quantification of the respondent's costs entitlement.