New Zealand Cards Limited v Ramsay

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA247/2012
[2013] NZCA 582

BETWEEN

NEW ZEALAND CARDS LIMITED
Applicant

AND

COLIN RAMSAY
Respondent

Court:

Randerson, Wild and White JJ

Counsel:

D G Beck for Applicant
S G Wilson for Respondent

Judgment

(On the papers):

25 November 2013 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for a stay of execution is dismissed.

BThe Employment Court is to pay out to the respondent the $14,500 it holds plus any interest accrued on that sum.  That payment will be in satisfaction of the $13,880 judgment and on account of the costs of the Employment Court hearing, which that Court should now fix as promptly as it can.

CThe applicant must pay the respondent’s costs of the stay application on a Band A basis.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Randerson J)

Introduction

  1. The applicant (NZ Cards) seeks a stay of execution of an Employment Court decision issued against it on 27 March 2012.[1]  In that decision Judge Couch upheld the Employment Relations Authority finding that the respondent had been unjustifiably dismissed[2] and ordered NZ Cards to pay the respondent Mr Ramsay $13,880 in remedies plus costs.[3]  Both parties were content for the application to be dealt with on the papers. 

Procedural history of the case

[1]New Zealand Cards Ltd v Ramsay [2012] NZEmpC 51.

[2]Ramsay v New Zealand Cards Ltd ERA Christchurch CA4/10, 15 January 2010.

[3]The issue of the monetary amount of costs in the Employment Court remains outstanding.

  1. NZ Cards has already applied to this Court for an extension of time to seek leave to appeal against the Employment Court decision and has filed an application for leave to appeal.  This Court granted the extension of time subject to certain conditions and allowed the application for leave to appeal on a question of law.[4]  An earlier application for a stay of execution was adjourned to allow both parties the opportunity to file further submissions.

    [4]New Zealand Cards Ltd v Ramsay [2012] NZCA 285. The substantive appeal has been set down to be heard by the Court of Appeal on 20 February 2014.

  2. NZ Cards filed submissions in support of the application for a stay of execution on 12 July 2012.  The director of NZ Cards, Mr Beresford, also provided a sworn affidavit in support of the application.  Mr Ramsay filed a memorandum in opposition to the application for a stay of execution on 26 July 2012.  That same day, Mr Ramsay also filed his written submissions and an affidavit in opposition to the application.

  3. Unfortunately the application did not progress in any material way until May 2013.  That delay is not attributable to either party.  Given the passage of time since the earlier submissions and affidavits were filed, on 1 May 2013, Randerson J issued a Minute allowing both parties the opportunity to file updating affidavits.[5]  These were to be received by the Court by 15 May and 29 May respectively. 

    [5]New Zealand Cards…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Cards Limited v Ramsay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 582
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, New Zealand Cards Limited applied for a stay of execution of a decision from the Employment Court, which had found that Colin Ramsay was unjustifiably dismissed and ordered New Zealand Cards to pay him $13,880 plus costs. The Court of Appeal, consisting of Randerson, Wild, and White JJ, dismissed the application. The substantive appeal against the Employment Court decision had already been allowed on a question of law, and the Court of Appeal found that the interests of justice lay with the respondent, Colin Ramsay, who had not received the judgment debt for nearly two years.

The key legal issue was whether the Court should grant a stay of execution of the Employment Court decision pending the outcome of the substantive appeal. The Court of Appeal considered various factors, including whether the appeal would be rendered nugatory without a stay, the bona fides of the applicant, the effect on third parties, the novelty and importance of the question involved, and the overall balance of convenience. The Court found that the appeal would not be rendered nugatory, that Ramsay had ample funds to repay any amount paid to him, and that the overall balance of convenience favoured not granting a stay. The Court also noted that Ramsay's elderly mother would be affected by a stay of execution, as Ramsay intended to use the judgment money for maintenance work on her house.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the interests of justice lay with the respondent, given the prolonged delay in paying the judgment debt. The Court also noted significant delays in the application for a stay and the substantive appeal, many of which were attributable to New Zealand Cards. The Court ordered that the Employment Court pay Ramsay the $14,500 it held plus any interest accrued on that sum. New Zealand Cards was also ordered to pay Ramsay's costs of the stay application on a Band A basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 2010, the Employment Relations Authority found that Colin Ramsay had been unjustifiably dismissed by New Zealand Cards Limited. The Employment Court upheld this finding on 27 March 2012 and ordered New Zealand Cards to pay Ramsay $13,880 in remedies plus costs. New Zealand Cards had already paid $14,500 to the Employment Court as security for costs. The issue of the precise amount of costs in the Employment Court remained outstanding. New Zealand Cards had applied for an extension of time to appeal and leave to appeal, both of which were granted by the Court of Appeal. The substantive appeal was set down to be heard on 20 February 2014.

The matter before the Court of Appeal is an application by New Zealand Cards for a stay of execution of the Employment Court decision. This Court had previously granted an extension of time and leave to appeal on a question of law. An earlier application for a stay of execution was adjourned to allow further submissions. The Court issued a Minute on 1 May 2013 allowing both parties to file updating affidavits. Submissions were filed in response to the respondent's updating affidavit, and the Court determined the appeal on the papers based on the material already before it.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the Court grant a stay of execution of the Employment Court decision?
2. If a stay is granted, what should be the conditions, if any, of such a stay?
3. Who should bear the costs of the stay application?

Held
1. The Court dismissed the application for a stay of execution of the Employment Court decision.
2. The Employment Court was ordered to pay out to the respondent the $14,500 it holds plus any interest accrued on that sum. This payment was in satisfaction of the $13,880 judgment and on account of the costs of the Employment Court hearing.
3. The applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the stay application on a Band A basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the application for a stay of execution on the papers, taking into account the well-known criteria for granting a stay, which required weighing the factors between the successful litigant's rights to the fruits of a judgment and the need to preserve the position in case the appeal is successful. The Court examined the submissions of both parties and the relevant factors, including the risk of prejudice to either party if the stay were granted or not granted, the effect on any third parties, the novelty and importance of the question involved, the public interest in the proceedings, the strength of the case on appeal, and the overall balance of convenience. The Court found that the interests of justice lay with the respondent, Mr Ramsay, who had been awarded remedies and costs in the Employment Court nearly two years ago but had not received any payment. The Court also considered the effect on a third party, Mr Ramsay's elderly mother, from the granting of a stay of execution. The Court concluded that the overall justice of the case and balance of convenience favoured not granting a stay of execution. This decision was based on the fact that Mr Ramsay had ample funds available to repay any amount paid to him, and the delays in the application for a stay and the substantive appeal were largely attributable to the conduct of the applicant, NZ Cards. The Court did not assess the merits of the appeal at this juncture but treated it as a neutral factor.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court of Appeal will not grant a stay of execution if the interests of justice lie with the respondent, particularly when the respondent has been denied the fruits of the judgment for a sustained period of time and has ample funds available to repay any amount paid, and the applicant has caused significant delays in the proceedings.