Morrison v Autumnal Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TAURANGA MOANA ROHE

CIV-2017-470-000196

[2020] NZHC 3189

BETWEEN

S A MORRISON and THE AUDAINE TRUST TRUSTEES LIMITED

Plaintiffs

AND

AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED

First Defendant

M W and A T O’REILLY

Second Defendants

CIV-2017-470-000190

BETWEEN

AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

S A MORRISON

Defendant

Hearing: 12 – 16 and 19-20 October 2020

Appearances:

G C Jenkin for Plaintiffs in CIV-2017-470-000196 and for Defendant in CIV-2017-470-000190

G Brittain QC and J Delaney for Defendants in CIV-2017-470- 196 and for Plaintiff in CIV-2017-470-000190

Judgment:

3 December 2020


JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J


This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie

On 3 December 2020 at 4.00pm Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:…………………………

S A MORRISON and THE AUDAINE TRUST TRUSTEES LTD v AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LTD [2020]
NZHC 3189 [3 December 2020]

Contents

Introduction  [1]

The evidence  [5]

The Trust and the purchase of the properties  [5]

The Trust’s and Mr Morrison’s financial difficulties  [8]
The “no cost trustee” proposal  [17]
Mr Love/Landing Road Trustee No 1 Ltd  [19]
Further valuations obtained/Mr Morrison seeks to refinance  [27]
Mr Morrison/Mr O’Reilly – a meeting in early April 2013?  [31]
Mr and Mrs O’Reilly decide to purchase the properties  [37]
Meeting of 12 April 2013  [50]

Further meeting on 15 April 2013  [62]

A trust document?/the lease  [71]

Settlements  [76]
Discussion – Neil Morrison and the O’Reillys  [81]

Mr Morrison’s bankruptcy – the SAMZ companies  [82]
Post-settlement arrangements  [89]

The subdivision  [97]
Attempts by Mr Morrison to buy back properties from Autumnal  [100]
Update on the properties  [116]

Assessment of the evidence  [117]

Mr Morrison and Mr O’Reilly – general comments  [117]

Mr Rendle’s evidence  [122]

Was there a meeting between Mr Morrison and Mr O’Reilly in early April 2013?

[123]

Meeting of 12 April 2013  [128]
Matters post 12 April 2013  [134]
Findings on the balance of probabilities  [136]

Pleadings – relevant law  [137]

Express trust  [138]
Institutional constructive trust  [139]

Promissory estoppel  [149]
Breach of fiduciary duty/buy back agreement  [152]

Result  [153]
Declaration/Transfer of properties  [153]
Subdivision/Sale of section  [155]

Accounting for profits  [158]

Costs  [165]

Introduction

[1]    The plaintiffs, Stuart Morrison and The Audaine Trust Trustees Limited, are the current trustees of the Audaine Trust (“the Trust”). They have brought proceedings against the first defendant, Autumnal Investments Limited (“Autumnal”), and its directors and shareholders, Maurice and Anne O’Reilly. They seek a declaration that Autumnal holds two properties in Tauriko, west of Tauranga, both now contained in one title as trustee of an institutional constructive trust in favour of them as trustees of the Trust.1 They say that, as trustees of the Trust, they are the beneficial owners of the properties. They also seek an order that the properties vest in them on such terms and conditions as to the payment of money as the Court thinks just. In addition, they seek an order that Autumnal accounts to them for the proceeds of sale of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morrison v Autumnal Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 3189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stuart Morrison and The Audaine Trust Trustees Limited, as trustees of the Audaine Trust, brought proceedings against Autumnal Investments Limited and its directors and shareholders, Maurice and Anne O’Reilly, seeking a declaration that Autumnal holds two properties in Tauriko, west of Tauranga, both now contained in one title as trustee of an institutional constructive trust in favour of them as trustees of the Trust. They sought an order that the properties vest in them on such terms and conditions as to the payment of money as the Court thought just. They also sought an order that Autumnal account to them for the proceeds of sale of a section subdivided off one of the properties and an account of the profits Autumnal had derived from its use of the properties. Autumnal denied that it holds the properties as a constructive trustee. It said that it is the registered proprietor and that it owns them in its own right. It had brought a counterclaim. Mr Morrison lives in a house on one of the properties and Autumnal seeks an order for possession. The Court found that there was an oral undertaking or promise made by Mr O’Reilly in early April 2013, and repeated at the meeting on 12 April 2013. The Court found that Mr Morrison, as trustee of the Trust, was induced by the oral undertaking or promise given by Mr O’Reilly to part with the properties to Autumnal. It found that Mr Morrison, as trustee of the Trust, would not have parted with the properties to Autumnal but for the oral undertaking or promise made by Mr O’Reilly. The Court found that there was an institutional constructive trust over the properties, in favour of the Trust as the beneficial owner of the properties. The Court made a declaration that Autumnal holds the properties as trustee of an institutional constructive trust in favour of the trustees of the Trust. The Court ordered that Autumnal is to transfer the property back to the trustees of the Trust so that it vests in the trustees, subject to certain conditions. The Court ordered that Autumnal account to the trustees of the Trust for all net income received from the properties over the period of its trusteeship. The plaintiffs were the successful parties in this proceeding and they were entitled to their reasonable costs and disbursements.