Morrison v Autumnal Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TAURANGA MOANA ROHE

CIV-2017-470-000196

[2021] NZHC 117

BETWEEN

S A MORRISON and THE AUDAINE TRUST TRUSTEES LIMITED

Plaintiffs

AND

AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED

First Defendant

M W and A T O’REILLY

Second Defendants

CIV-2017-470-000190

BETWEEN

AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

S A MORRISON

Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Judgment:

10 February 2021


JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

[Costs]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie On 10 February 2021 at 11.00 am

Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:…………………………

Solicitors/counsel:

Bruce Dell Law/G C Jenkin, Auckland

Jackson Reeves Lawyers/G Brittain QC, Tauranga

S A MORRISON and THE AUDAINE TRUST TRUSTEES LTD v AUTUMNAL INVESTMENTS LTD [2021]

NZHC 117 [10 February 2021]

Introduction

[1]    I refer to my judgment in this matter issued on 3 December 2020.1 I declared that the first defendant in proceedings CIV-2017-470-196 – Autumnal Investments Limited – holds a property as trustee of an institutional constructive trust in favour of the trustees of The Audaine Trust. I ordered that Autumnal was to transfer the property back to the trustees, subject to various conditions, and that Autumnal must account to the trustees for the net sum received from the sale of a section subdivided off the property and the net income received by it over the period of the trusteeship.

[2]    The plaintiffs in proceedings CIV-2017-470-196 were the successful parties. I held that they were entitled to their reasonable costs and disbursements and directed the filing of memoranda.

[3]I have now received those memoranda:

(a)Except in two respects, the plaintiffs accept that category 2 is the appropriate categorisation for costs purposes. They also accept that band B is the appropriate band for most steps taken in the proceedings. They say however that significant time was spent preparing their briefs of evidence and in preparing for trial and they seek that costs should be assessed on a category 3 band B basis for these steps. They also assert that considerable time was required to complete discovery and inspection. They seek costs on a category 2 band C basis for these steps. They seek costs of $132,647, disbursements of $6,971 and the reimbursement of their fees payable to an expert for the preparation of a brief of evidence in the sum of $17,868.13 – in total: $157,486.13.

(b)The defendants, Autumnal, and its principals, Mr and Mrs O’Reilly, accept that costs must follow the event. They assert that the proceeding was of average complexity and that no individual step warrants an increased time allocation. They argue that costs should be assessed on a 2B basis for all steps taken. They dispute some of the steps claimed


1      Morrison v Autumnal Investments Ltd [2020] NZHC 3189.

for by the plaintiffs and calculate costs, on a 2B basis, in the sum of

$82,933. They dispute one disbursement claimed and argue that disbursements properly incurred amount to $5,573.95. They accept the expert witness fees claimed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morrison v Autumnal Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Justice Wylie presided over a case between S. A. Morrison and The Audaine Trust Trustees Limited against Autumnal Investments Limited. The primary dispute centred on the ownership of a property held by Autumnal Investments, with the plaintiffs asserting that it was held as trustee of an institutional constructive trust in their favour. The defendants contested this claim. The court was tasked with deciding the appropriate categorisation and banding of the proceedings for cost purposes, as well as determining the specific costs incurred by the plaintiffs.

Justice Wylie meticulously assessed the claims made by both parties. The plaintiffs argued for a higher categorisation of their costs and a greater time allocation for certain steps, such as preparing briefs of evidence and undergoing discovery. The defendants contested these claims, asserting that the proceedings were of average complexity and that the plaintiffs' claims for costs were excessive. They also argued for a reduction in costs due to the plaintiffs' unsuccessful pursuit of an express written trust claim. After careful consideration, Justice Wylie found that while some of the plaintiffs' claims for increased time allocation were justified, others were not. The court concluded that the proceedings should be categorised as category 2 and mostly band B for complexity, with some steps warranting a band C classification due to the necessity of obtaining documents from various non-parties. The court also determined that a 10% reduction in costs was appropriate due to the plaintiffs' unsuccessful pursuit of the express written trust claim.

Justice Wylie awarded the plaintiffs costs on a 2B basis, reduced by 10%, amounting to $90,987.30, along with the claimed disbursements of $6,971 and expert witness fees of $17,868.13, for a total of $115,826.43. This sum was to be paid by the defendants, Autumnal Investments Limited.