Ministry of Social Development v Albert

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2014-404-000435 [2015] NZHC 1288

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

v

AARON CHARLES ALBERT

Hearing: 2 June 2015

Appearances:

Rina See for the Appellant
Rachael Reed for the Respondent

Judgment:

9 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF MOORE J [Appeal against sentence]

This judgment was delivered by me on 9 June 2015 at 4:00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT v ALBERT [2015] NZHC 1288 [9 June 2015]

Introduction

[1]      Over a period of 16 months between 2012 and 2013 Mr Albert received sickness benefits using three different stolen identities in addition to his own.  As a result  the  Ministry  of  Social  Development  (“MSD”)  overpaid  him  more  than

$72,000.

[2]      After pleading guilty he was convicted and sentenced to community-based sentences and ordered to make reparation.

[3]      MSD appeals that sentence because, it says, the end sentence was manifestly inadequate.

Factual background

[4]      Mr Albert was a sickness beneficiary and later received a domestic purposes benefit for caring for his sick and infirm mother.

[5]      It  was  discovered  he  was  also  receiving  sickness  benefits  under  three different identities in addition to his own.  These identities were stolen from friends and family living in Australia.  The overpayment in relation to the stolen identities totalled more than $72,000.

[6]      Then, it was discovered that Mr Albert had stopped caring for his mother in late 2012 but had not declared this change of circumstance to MSD as he was required to.  As a result, MSD had overpaid his domestic purposes benefit by more than $7,000.

[7]      Thus the total amount overpaid by MSD to Mr Albert was $80,094.50.  As a result, he was charged with five charges of dishonestly using a document1  and four charges of obtaining by deception.2   Both crimes carry a maximum penalty of seven

years’ imprisonment.

1      Crimes Act 1961, s 228(b).

2      Crimes Act 1961, s 240.

District Court decision

[8]      Mr Albert pleaded guilty to all charges.   He was convicted by the District Court Judge who sentenced him to six months’ community detention, 12 months’ intensive  supervision,  250  hours  of  community  work  and  ordered  reparation  of

$75,000 payable at $200 per week (which Mr Albert had been making for four months by the time he was sentenced).

[9]      In sentencing Mr Albert, the Judge described the offending as premeditated, calculated and a breach of trust.   He adopted a starting point of 28 months’ imprisonment with an uplift of four months for Mr Albert’s previous convictions. From that starting point of 32 months’ imprisonment, his Honour gave a discount in recognition that some reparation had been paid and gave credit for a guilty plea. This  reduced  the  starting  point  to  22  months’ imprisonment  thus  leaving  home detention as an available sentencing option.

[10]     His  Honour  noted  that  he  had  intended  to  impose  home  detention  but Ms Reed, for Mr Albert, had persuaded him to impose a sentence of community detention which his Honour…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ministry of Social Development v Albert and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Ministry of Social Development appealed against the sentence imposed on Aaron Charles Albert who was found to have committed benefit fraud amounting to over $80,000. Albert had been sentenced to six months' community detention, 12 months' intensive supervision, 250 hours of community work and ordered to make reparation of $75,000. The Ministry submitted the sentence was manifestly inadequate. The court found the sentence was manifestly inadequate and substituted it with a sentence of seven months' home detention.

The court considered the hierarchy of sentences as set out in s 10A of the Sentencing Act 2002. The most restrictive sentence is imprisonment, followed by home detention, followed by community-based sentences of intensive supervision and community detention and thereafter sentences of community work and supervision. The court noted a drop of two levels in the sentencing hierarchy is unusual and would require compelling reasons to justify it. The court found there was nothing in Albert's case which justified a less restrictive sentence than that of home detention.

The court noted that a sentence of 22 months' imprisonment placed this case close to the statutory limit for a sentence of home detention. Applying the common rule of thumb that a sentence of home detention is half of the equivalent sentence of imprisonment, a sentence of eleven months would have been imposed. This is just one month short of the statutory maximum. Reducing this to a lesser sentence, and imposing that sentence for only six months, represented a significant indulgence to the defendant.

The court noted that in benefit fraud cases there is no recognised tariff case. It is necessary for sentencing Judges to determine, on a case-by-case basis, whether a sentence of home detention is an appropriate response to the particular offending or whether a sentence of imprisonment is required. The court found that Albert's offending, viewed against a backdrop of comparable cases, left it in no doubt that the provisional sentence reached by the Judge of 22 months' imprisonment was appropriate. The court found that a community-based sentence should not have been imposed and that the sentence should have been one of imprisonment. The reduction from 22 months' imprisonment to six months' community detention represented such a significant reduction in sentence that it could not be justified on orthodox sentencing principles.

The court found that, despite the merits and pragmatism of the Judge's decision to give priority to Albert's ability to make reparation, a sentence of imprisonment should have been imposed. However, the court found that to impose that sentence at this time would be a severe injustice to Albert. In all the circumstances the court found a sentence of home detention would now meet the requirements of justice in this case. The court substituted a sentence of seven months' home detention with special conditions.