Maa v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI-2013-485-000039 [2013] NZHC 1846

BETWEEN  JENNIFER NELSON MAA Appellant

ANDMINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing:                   23 July 2013

Counsel:                  M G Kilbride for Appellant

D D Watterson for Respondent

Judgment:                24 July 2013

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      The question raised by this appeal is whether a sentence of seven months’ home detention and 100 hours’ community work imposed on Ms Maa should be overturned.

Context

[2]      This question arises in the context of an appeal against a sentence imposed by Judge Butler in the Lower Hutt District Court on 17 May 2013 after Ms Maa pleaded guilty to:

(1)       two charges of deception;1   and

(2)       seven charges of dishonestly using a document.2

1      Crimes Act 1961, s 240.

2      Section 228(b).

MAA v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2013] NZHC 1846 [24 July 2013]

[3]      Ms Maa received a domestic purposes benefit (DPB) from 21 February 2000 to 23 January 2011.  It was a condition of her receiving the DPB that she notify the Ministry of Social Development (the Ministry) of any changes in her circumstances that might affect her entitlement to the DPB, including changes to her employment status.

[4]      The two deception charges arose from Ms Maa’s failure to tell the Ministry

about her income from work for two significant periods:

(1)       24 April 2006 to 28 June 2008 when she was employed by Global

Interactive Ltd;  and

(2)       3 August 2009 to 3 May 2010 when she was employed by Phones

Unlimited Ltd.

[5]      The  seven  charges  of  dishonestly  using  documents  arose  when  Ms Maa dishonestly completed Ministry forms in which she stated she was not working or receiving any other income, other than the DPB.

[6]      As a consequence of her offending Ms Maa received $34,946.23 in DPB

payments that she was not entitled to receive.

Judge Butler’s decision

[7]      Judge Butler explained that he was endeavouring to impose a sentence that was consistent with others he had imposed for this type of offending.  He adopted a starting point of 24 months’ imprisonment which he reduced to 18 months to take account of mitigating factors.  That provisional sentence was reduced by a further four months to reflect Ms Maa’s guilty plea.   Judge Butler then “converted” the sentence of 14 months’ imprisonment to one of seven months’ home detention and

100 hours’ community work.

Appeal jurisdiction

[8]      I can only allow Ms Maa’s appeal if I am satisfied that the end sentence was clearly excessive or if I am satisfied facts relating to the offence or  Ms Maa’s character or personal history were not before the Court which imposed sentence.3

Grounds of appeal

[9]      Ms  Maa  appeals  on  the  grounds  that  Judge  Butler  failed  to  sufficiently consider her personal circumstances, and in particular the impact of home detention on her ability to work and care for her children.

[10]     Ms Maa is currently in full-time employment.  She submits that a sentence of home detention will mean she…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maa v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1846
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Jennifer Nelson Maa appealed against the sentence imposed by the Lower Hutt District Court, challenging the appropriateness of the sentence of seven months’ home detention and 100 hours of community work. The appeal was brought against the Ministry of Social Development, the body responsible for administering domestic purposes benefits. The appeal arose from Ms Maa's failure to report changes in her employment status, leading to charges of deception and dishonestly using a document, resulting in her receiving $34,946.23 in domestic purposes benefits to which she was not entitled. The legal issues in the case revolved around whether the sentence imposed was excessive and whether the sentencing court had taken into account relevant personal circumstances, including Ms Maa's employment and responsibility for her children. The court found that the starting point for sentencing was higher than comparable cases and that the sentencing judge did not have the benefit of evidence regarding the impact of home detention on Ms Maa's employment and her children. The court substituted the sentence with six months’ community detention, 400 hours of community work, and an order for reparation at the rate of $100 per month. The court concluded that the amended sentences would adequately fulfil the objectives of the Sentencing Act 2002. The appeal was allowed, and the sentences imposed by the sentencing judge were replaced with the sentences set out in the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established