Hai v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2014-404-000128 [2014] NZHC 2043

BETWEEN

MOHAMMED HAI

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing: 25 August 2014

Appearances:

J H A Wiles for Appellant
J D Cairney for Respondent

Judgment:

27 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 27 August 2014 at 3.00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date……………………….

HAI v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2014] NZHC 2043 [27 August 2014]

Introduction

[1]      Mohammed Hai, pleaded guilty in the Manukau District Court to 19 charges of dishonestly obtaining Work and Income benefits totalling $115,470.50 over a ten- year period.1   Judge Winter sentenced him to 20 months’ imprisonment and ordered him to pay the full sum in reparation.2   Mr Hai appeals that sentence on the ground that it is manifestly excessive.

[2]     Mr Wiles, for Mr Hai, acknowledged that the sentence of 20 months’ imprisonment was within the range available for the offending.   The appeal is advanced on the basis that home detention was the appropriate sentence and the Judge was wrong to reject that in favour of imprisonment.  In particular, it is asserted that the Judge:

(a)       Wrongly assessed Mr Hai’s circumstances and the degree of planning and premeditation;

(b)      Wrongly distinguished the case from Ransom v R;3 (c)           Failed to refer to s 16(2) of the Sentencing Act 2002; (d)          Failed to take account of the time spent in custody.

(e)       Failed to take account of the size of the reparation order;

The offending

[3]      Mr Hai obtained a domestic purposes benefit on the basis of applications dated 17 November 1998 and 18 February 2009 and an unemployment benefit on the basis of applications dated 3 March 2011 and 22 November 2012.  When he signed the applications he agreed to advise the Ministry of any changes to his circumstances

that might affect his benefit entitlement.

1      Seven counts of obtaining by deception under s 240 Crimes Act 1961, three of using a document under s 229A and nine of dishonestly using a document under s 228.

2      Police v Hai Manukau DC CRI-2014-092-002228, 15 May 2014.

3      Ransom v R [2010] NZCA 390; (2010) 25 CRNZ 163.

[4]      Throughout the relevant period Mr Hai told the Ministry that he was either single or not living in a relationship in the nature of marriage.   In fact, he was married and had reconciled with his wife in September 1994.  In addition, Mr Hai and his wife jointly owned a property in Rawene between July 2008 and December

2009.  That asset would have precluded entitlement to supplementary assistance.  In December 2009 they sold the property to their family trust and did not declare the proceeds of sale as an asset.

[5]      Thirdly,  between  April  2003  and  August  2005  and  February  2009  and September 2009 Mr Hai was running a business and receiving income from it which he failed to disclose to the Ministry.   Instead,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hai v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2043
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hai v Ministry of Social Development, the appellant, Mohammed Hai, appealed against his sentence imposed by the Manukau District Court for dishonestly obtaining Work and Income benefits amounting to $115,470.50 over a ten-year period. The High Court of New Zealand reviewed the appeal, focusing on whether the sentence of 20 months’ imprisonment was manifestly excessive. The appellant argued that home detention was the appropriate sentence, and the Judge had erred in rejecting it in favour of imprisonment.

The legal issues in this case included whether the Judge made unjustified assumptions about the appellant's circumstances, whether the Judge erred in distinguishing the case from Ransom v R, whether the Judge failed to refer to and take into account section 16(2) of the Sentencing Act 2002, whether the Judge failed to take account of the time spent in custody, and whether the reparation order placed an unfair burden on the appellant.

The Court found that the Judge had properly considered the relevant factors in sentencing and was alive to the requirements of section 16(2) of the Sentencing Act 2002. The Court noted that the appellant's offending involved a high degree of planning and premeditation, and that home detention would not have met the purposes and principles of the Sentencing Act 2002. The Court also found that the reparation order, while significant, was not excessive when taking into account the appellant's ability to pay.

The appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence of 20 months’ imprisonment and the reparation order were upheld.

Final orders:

1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The original sentence of 20 months’ imprisonment is upheld.
3. The reparation order in the full sum of $115,470.50 is upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established