Mike Pero Mortgages Limited v Pero

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-2193 [2016] NZHC 651

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER

of MPRE Limited

BETWEEN

MIKE PERO MORTGAGES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MIKE PERO First Defendant

MIKE PERO MARKETING LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing: 11 April 2016

Counsel:

G P Blanchard and J P Nolen for plaintiff
D Bigio and A Malone for defendants

Judgment:

11 April 2016

ORAL JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

Solicitors:      Lowndes, Auckland

Duncan Cotterill

Counsel:       G Blanchard, Barrister, Auckland

D Bigio, Shortland Chambers, Auckland

MIKE PERO MORTAGES LIMITED v PERO & MIKE PERO MARKETING LIMITED [2016] NZHC 651 [11 April 2016]

Introduction

[1]      Mike  Pero  Mortgages  Limited  (“MP  Mortgages”)  sues  Mike  Pero  and Mike Pero Marketing  Limited (“MP Marketing”), of which Mr Pero is  the sole director,1 alleging breach of a shareholders’ agreement and the company constitution, shareholder oppression, and breaches of certain provisions of the Companies Act

1993  (“Act”).     Mr  Pero  and  MP  Marketing  have  counterclaimed,  alleging

shareholder oppression by MP Mortgages.

[2]      The substantive trial commenced before me this morning, with an estimated hearing time of two weeks.   Last Thursday, however, MP Mortgages filed an application for leave to file a second amended statement of claim.  That application is  opposed.     In  addition,  the  defendants  challenge  a  number  of  aspects  of MP Mortgages reply evidence, on the basis that it is not strictly in reply.

[3]      I will deal first with the application for leave to amend the pleadings, before turning to consider the various evidence issues.

Should leave be granted to MP Mortgages to amend the current pleading?

[4]      MP Mortgages have provided a draft second amended statement of claim with the proposed changes marked up.

[5]      A number  of  the  proposed  amendments  are  uncontroversial  and  are  not objected to. The defendants, however, object to three particular proposed amendments.   They are set out at [23](h), [23](j) and [27.2] of the draft second amended statement of claim.   Those amendments relate to an allegation that the defendants have failed to provide full details of payments they have received from MPRE Ltd2 and/or MP Real Estate Limited,3 despite requests to provide such information.  MP Mortgages alleges that the defendants have deliberately concealed

the exact amount that they and/or their related parties have received in excess of a

1      The shares in MP Marketing are owned as to half by Mr Pero and as to half by a trust of which he is one trustee.

2      A joint venture between MP Mortgages and MP Marketing.

3      A wholly owned subsidiary of MPRE Limited.

sum of $200,000 per annum remuneration for Mr Pero that has been agreed in a

shareholders’ agreement between the parties.

[6]      The genesis of this particular allegation appears to lie in a misunderstanding between the parties.  The relief sought in relation to the first cause of action in the original statement of claim (breaches of shareholders’ agreement/constitution) included:

(a)       a declaration that all purported resolutions of MPRE signed only by

Mr Pero are void and of no…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mike Pero Mortgages Limited v Pero and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 651
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mike Pero Mortgages Limited sued Mike Pero and Mike Pero Marketing Limited, alleging breach of a shareholders’ agreement and company constitution, shareholder oppression, and breaches of certain provisions of the Companies Act 1993. The defendants counterclaimed for shareholder oppression by Mike Pero Mortgages. The court first had to decide whether leave should be granted to Mike Pero Mortgages to amend its pleadings. The defendants objected to certain proposed amendments relating to an allegation that the defendants failed to provide full details of payments received from MPRE Ltd and/or MP Real Estate Limited. The court found that the amendments were not necessary to ensure that the real controversy went to trial and that their relevance appeared to be somewhat peripheral. The court also found that allowing the proposed amendments would be prejudicial to the defendants at this very late stage. The court then had to consider the defendants’ challenges to Mike Pero Mortgages’ reply evidence. The court found that the challenged portions of Mr Goodall’s reply brief should be provisionally admitted. The decision as to the relevance and admissibility of that evidence is reserved for determination post trial. The court also found that paragraphs [36] to [38] of Mr Collins’ reply brief of evidence should be excluded. Finally, the court found that paragraphs [69] to [78] of Mr Ma’s reply brief of evidence would be admitted, provided that they are redrafted in more neutral terms. The final orders of the court were that leave was granted to make the proposed amendments marked up in the draft second amended statement of claim, save for the amendments set out at [23](h), [23](j), and [27.2] of that document. The defendants were to file a defence to the second amended statement of claim by Friday, 15 April 2016. MP Mortgages’ reply (if any) was to be filed by Monday, 18 April 2016. Paragraphs [11] to [21] of Mr Goodall’s reply brief of evidence were provisionally admitted. The decision as to the final admissibility of that evidence was reserved. Leave was granted to the defendants to reply to paragraphs [11] to [21] of Mr Goodall’s brief, either by way of supplementary brief of evidence or through evidence produced or orally by Mr Hagen (or any other relevant witness) at trial. Paragraphs [36] to [38] of Mr Collins’ reply brief of evidence were excluded. Paragraphs [69] to [78] of Mr Ma’s reply brief of evidence would be admitted, provided that they are redrafted in more neutral terms. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.