O'Loughlin v Tower Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-002385 [2013] NZHC 438

BETWEEN  MATTHEW JOHN O'LOUGHLIN AND VALERIE JEAN O'LOUGHLIN Plaintiffs

ANDTOWER INSURANCE LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         7 March 2013

Counsel:         G Shand and KP Sullivan for Plaintiffs

AR Galbraith QC and MC Harris for Defendant

Judgment:      7 March 2013

RULING OF ASHER J

Solicitors/Counsel:

G Shand, PO Box 13090, Armagh, Christchurch 8141. Email:  grant@grantshand.co.nz

KP Sullivan, PO Box 5817, Lambton Quay, Wellington 6145. Email:  Kevin@portnic.co.nz

Gilbert Walker, PO Box 1595, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. Email:  matthew.harris@gilbertwalker.com

AR Galbraith QC, PO Box 4338, Shortland Street, Auckland 1140. Email: argalbraith@shortlandchambers.co.nz

O'LOUGHLIN V TOWER INSURANCE LTD HC CHCH CIV-2012-409-002385 [7 March 2013]

Introduction

[1]      A ruling is required on the admissibility of the evidence of Dallas Leicester McDonald.   Mr McDonald, a deponent  for the  plaintiff,  describes himself as  a project manager for a number of building entities who has had 10 years experience in the building industry.

[2]      It  is  now  the  fourth  day  of  hearing.    On  the  second  day  of  hearing, Mr Galbraith QC for the defendant raised in advance his objection to the admission of this evidence.

[3]      Mr McDonald’s brief runs to four paragraphs.  The first two paragraphs are

by way of background. The substantive two paragraphs read:

The property is severely damaged.   To remedy the house requires reconstruction, rather than repair.

In my view any repair is impracticable.   I would not be involved in any attempt to repair the house. As well as being impracticable any repair would not return the house to “as new” condition.

[4]      I indicated in my Minute (No.3) of 5 March 2013, dictated after Mr Galbraith had raised the objection, that I was minded to uphold it.  I recorded:

[6]     Thus, I am minded to uphold Mr Galbraith’s objection.  However, it may be that an amended brief could be filed on short notice which does at least briefly set out a reasoning process.   Such an affidavit may be of assistance.  The risk is, of course, that any such new brief filed at such a late time may prejudice the defendant who will not have an opportunity to respond.

[7]      I have  decided that the  most  fair  way forward  is  to  adjourn  this application for 24 hours to be determined tomorrow morning.   I have indicated the order I will make should the brief not be amended.  If the brief is amended, it will then be open to Mr Galbraith to persist with his objection and raise any new issue or prejudice that may arise and I will deal with the application then.

[5]      Two days have passed.   Mr Shand advises that no amended brief will be offered.  Mr Galbraith seeks a ruling.

[6]      I have decided that this brief should not be admitted for reasons that I now set out, including those that are already in my earlier minute.

Decision

[7]      While Mr Galbraith does not contest that Mr McDonald has provided some evidence of expertise, he objects to this evidence being admitted on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Loughlin v Tower Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard the case of O'Loughlin v Tower Insurance Limited. The plaintiffs, Matthew John O'Loughlin and Valerie Jean O'Loughlin, sought to introduce the evidence of Dallas Leicester McDonald, a deponent and project manager with experience in the building industry. The defendant, Tower Insurance Limited, objected to the admission of Mr McDonald's evidence, arguing that it was conclusory and too brief to provide substantial assistance to the court in understanding other evidence or ascertaining facts relevant to the case. The plaintiffs contended that Mr McDonald's evidence would assist the court and directly address points in contention.

The court was required to decide whether Mr McDonald's evidence should be admitted. The court considered whether the evidence met the criteria under section 25 of the Evidence Act 2006, which permits the admission of expert opinion if the fact finder is likely to obtain substantial help from that opinion in understanding other evidence or ascertaining facts of consequence to the determination of the proceeding. The court also considered the probative value of the evidence in relation to its unfairly prejudicial effect under section 8 of the Evidence Act 2006.

The court concluded that Mr McDonald's evidence should not be admitted. The court found that the evidence was conclusory and too brief to be weighed or evaluated by a fact finder. The court noted that without an attempt to present facts relied on by the expert and their reasoning, the evidence was of little or no probative value. The court also found that the evidence could be seen as having an unfairly prejudicial effect in that it was conclusory and adverse to the defendant's position. The court indicated that if a fuller and more helpful brief was provided, it would be considered on its merits. However, the court emphasised that any such new brief filed at such a late time may prejudice the defendant.

The court ruled that Mr McDonald's evidence should not be admitted. The court found that the evidence was conclusory and too brief to be weighed or evaluated by a fact finder. The court also found that the evidence could be seen as having an unfairly prejudicial effect in that it was conclusory and adverse to the defendant's position. The court indicated that if a fuller and more helpful brief was provided, it would be considered on its merits. The court also noted that any such new brief filed at such a late time may prejudice the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.