Marteley v Legal Services Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 61/2014
[2015] NZSC 127
BETWEEN

TODD AARON MARTELEY
Appellant

AND

THE LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER
Respondent

Hearing:

5 May 2015

Court:

Elias CJ, William Young, Glazebrook, Arnold and O’Regan JJ

Counsel:

A J Ellis and A Shaw for Appellant
F M R Cooke QC and B D Huntley for Respondent

Judgment:

21 August 2015

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed, the Court of Appeal judgment is set-aside and the order that the appellant receive legal aid for his conviction appeal is restored.

BIn this Court the appellant is awarded costs of $25,000 together with reasonable disbursements.

CThe appellant is also entitled to costs and disbursements in the High Court and Court of Appeal to be fixed by those Courts.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

William Young, Glazebrook, Arnold and O’Regan JJ [1]
Elias CJ [83]

WILLIAM YOUNG, GLAZEBROOK, ARNOLD AND O’REGAN JJ

(Given by William Young J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction [1]
The merits issue:  to what extent is a consideration of the
merits of a criminal appeal material to the decision to grant
legal aid?
[6]
Overview [6]
Pre-Nicholls evolution of the statutory scheme [10]
The human rights context [19]
Nicholls v Registrar of the Court of Appeal [26]
The Legal Services Act 2000 [33]
Subsequent criticism of Nicholls [37]
The 2006 amendments [39]
The 2011 Act [40]
The approach of Collins J [43]
The Court of Appeal judgment [45]
Three different approaches [48]
Our approach [50]
Should legal aid have been granted for the conviction appeal? [56]
The background to the conviction for murder [56]
An overview of the proposed conviction appeal [64]
The dealings between the appellant and the Agency and
Commissioner
[70]
The Legal Aid Tribunal [71]
The appeal to the High Court [74]
The appeal of the Court of Appeal [76]
Our approach [77]
Costs [81]
Disposition [82]

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Todd Aaron Marteley, pleaded guilty to a charge of murder and was later sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of imprisonment of 14 years.[1]  He wished to appeal against his conviction and sentence.  There followed a dispute with the Legal Services Agency (under the Legal Services Act 2000) and later the Legal Services Commissioner (under the Legal Services Act 2011) over legal aid for the purposes of his appeal.  The Commissioner was prepared to fund an appeal against sentence but not conviction; this for perceived lack of merit. 

    [1]R v Marteley HC Hamilton CRI-2009-19-9786, 5 November 2010. 

  2. The Commissioner’s decision was upheld on review by the Legal Aid Tribunal.  The Tribunal’s decision, however, was successfully challenged in the High Court on appeal.  In allowing the appeal, Collins J saw the merits or otherwise of the proposed appeal as of no moment where, as here, the grounds of appeal, if made out, would be capable of resulting in the appeal being allowed.[2]  He also concluded that the Commissioner ought to have addressed the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marteley v Legal Services Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZSC 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision of the Legal Aid Tribunal, issued on 1 November 2012, upheld the Commissioner's decision to deny legal aid to the appellant, Marteley, in relation to his application for an appeal against his conviction for murder. Marteley sought legal aid to challenge his conviction, alleging prosecutorial misconduct and impugning the voluntariness of his guilty plea. The Tribunal dismissed the application, finding that Marteley's allegations were unsubstantiated and that his plea was informed and voluntary.

The primary legal issues the Tribunal had to decide were whether Marteley's allegations of prosecutorial misconduct were substantiated and whether his guilty plea was voluntary. The Tribunal found that Marteley's claims of prosecutorial misconduct, including the concealment of evidence and undue influence, lacked supporting evidence and were therefore unarguable. The Tribunal also accepted that Marteley was properly advised of his legal position and made an informed decision to plead guilty, despite having a possible defence. Consequently, the Tribunal held that Marteley's appeal grounds were unarguable, and his conviction could not be impugned.

The Tribunal concluded that providing legal aid for an appeal against conviction would not be in the interests of justice, given the unarguable nature of Marteley's grounds for appeal. The Tribunal found that the Commissioner's decision to deny legal aid was neither manifestly unreasonable nor wrong in law. Accordingly, the Tribunal upheld the Commissioner's decision, denying Marteley's application for legal aid to pursue his appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In a decision issued on 1 November 2012[73] the Legal Aid Tribunal confirmed the Commissioner’s decision of 16 April 2012.[74] The relevant passages from the decision are as follows:[75][73]There was an earlier decision of 7 June 2012 in which the Tribunal refused to grant the appellant an extension of time with respect to an application to review an earlier decision of the Commissioner which had been superseded by the Commissioner’s decision of 16 April 2012.[74]Re Marteley [2012] NZLAT 41 & 111, 1 November 2012. [75]References omitted.Prosecutorial misconduct…[17] The Applicant’s allegations of prosecutorial misconduct include the Police concealing evidence; Police exceeding their statutory authority during its investigation and prosecution of the Applicant; that there has been misconduct by officials involved with the prosecution of his case; that a witness was paid to provide a false statement adverse to the Applicant; that there has been subterfuge between animal control officers and the Police to re-home and re-name the Applicant’s two dogs despite the Applicant being told that both dogs had been destroyed.[18] The Applicant has made these sweeping allegations but without any documentary records, independent accounts or other corroboration. The allegations are without support and therefore unarguable.[19] The Applicant also says he was induced to enter a guilty plea so that his partner who was also accused of the same murder could have her charge reduced from murder to manslaughter. This actually occurred. Understandably, this could have been a powerful inducement. The reduction of charge to his partner if the Applicant pleaded guilty to murder was suggested by Counsel for the Applicant’s partner. Counsel for the Applicant’s partner was not an official involved in the prosecution of the Applicant. The inducement cannot be said to have been made by the prosecution and therefore cannot be prosecutorial misconduct. This ground is equally unarguable.Impugning the Applicant’s own Guilty Plea[20] A successful appeal against conviction following a guilty plea is possible but if an accused fully appreciated the merits of his or her position and made an informed choice to plead guilty, the conviction cannot be impugned. …[22] It is accepted that the Applicant’s lawyer when the guilty plea was entered advised the Applicant he had a possible defence based on his instructions but in light of the prosecution evidence, including previous inconsistent accounts from the Applicant, that there was a significant risk that the Applicant would be disbelieved by a jury and consequently convicted. The Applicant has not disputed the correctness of this advice. The Applicant there accepts both that he was properly apprised of the merits of his position before he entered his guilty plea and that he made an informed choice to plead guilty. His concessions make this ground of appeal unarguable.…CONCLUSION[24] Even though the conviction is very serious and the Applicant would have difficulty arguing his own case, it cannot be in the interests of justice for the Applicant to be provided with publicly funded legal services to argue grounds of appeal that are unarguable.[25] Accordingly, the Tribunal concludes that the Commissioner was not manifestly unreasonable or wrong in law to determine the interests of justice do not require a grant of legal aid for an appeal against conviction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.