Legal Services Commissioner v Marteley

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA735/2013
[2014] NZCA 185

BETWEEN

THE LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER
Appellant

AND

TODD AARON MARTELEY
Respondent

Hearing:

27 February 2014

Court:

Ellen France, Randerson and Miller JJ

Counsel:

F M R Cooke QC for Appellant
A J Ellis and G K Edgeler for Respondent

Judgment:

19 May 2014 at 2:15 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe two questions of law identified at [8] of this judgment upon which leave to appeal was granted are each answered in the affirmative.

CLeave is reserved to apply if there is any further issue about relief.

DThere is no order for costs.   

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Ellen France and Randerson JJ
Miller J

[1]
[100]

ELLEN FRANCE AND RANDERSON JJ

(Given by Randerson J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
Background facts
The Tribunal’s decision
The High Court judgment
The position of the parties on appeal
First issue – grounds of appeal

The terms of the legislation
The decision in Nicholls
The Privy Council’s decision in Taito
The legislation after Taito
The relevant provisions of NZBORA, the international conventions and the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights

Our conclusions on the first issue
This case
Second issue – fiscal consequences
Result

[1]
[10]

[17]

[25]

[33]
[36]
[37]
[43]
[55]
[59]

[65]

[77]
[86]
[93]
[96]

Introduction

  1. This appeal raises an important question about the criteria for the grant of legal aid for appeals to this Court in criminal cases. 

  2. The respondent Mr Marteley pleaded guilty on 3 September 2010 to the murder of a Mr Kingi on 10 June 2009.  He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of imprisonment of 14 years.[1]  Mr Marteley then appealed to this Court against his conviction and sentence on 23 August 2011.  Over a lengthy period, Mr Marteley has been in dispute with the Legal Services Commissioner over his entitlement to legal aid for the purposes of his appeal.  We will refer later to the history in more detail.  For the present it is sufficient to record that interim grants of legal aid were made on a limited basis but, on 16 April 2012, the Commissioner determined under the Legal Services Act 2011 (the 2011 Act) there were no realistic grounds for an appeal against conviction.  A limited grant of aid was made for the purpose of providing the Commissioner with an analysis of grounds for a sentence appeal on the basis of disparity with the sentences imposed on Mr Marteley’s co‑offenders.

    [1]R v Marteley HC Hamilton CRI-2009-019-9786, 5 November 2010. 

  3. Mr Marteley sought a review of the Commissioner’s decision under s 52(1) of the 2011 Act on the grounds that the decision was manifestly unreasonable or wrong in law.  In a decision issued on 1 November 2012 the Legal Aid Tribunal confirmed the Commissioner’s decision of 16 April 2012.[2]  The Tribunal found that, although the conviction…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v Marteley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the criteria for the grant of legal aid for appeals to this Court in criminal cases. The respondent, Mr Marteley, pleaded guilty to the murder of Mr Kingi on 10 June 2009. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum period of imprisonment of 14 years. Mr Marteley then appealed to this Court against his conviction and sentence on 23 August 2011. The Commissioner determined that there were no realistic grounds for an appeal against conviction. Mr Marteley sought a review of the Commissioner’s decision under s 52(1) of the Legal Services Act 2011 on the grounds that the decision was manifestly unreasonable or wrong in law. The Legal Aid Tribunal confirmed the Commissioner’s decision of 16 April 2012. The Tribunal found that, although the conviction was very serious and Mr Marteley would have difficulty arguing his own case, it could not be in the interests of justice in terms of s 8 of the 2011 Act for Mr Marteley to be provided with publicly funded legal services to argue grounds of appeal that the Tribunal considered were “unarguable”. Mr Marteley then appealed to the High Court under s 59 of the 2011 Act on the grounds that the Tribunal’s decision was wrong in law. The focus of the argument in the High Court was the extent to which the Commissioner is entitled to consider the grounds of an appeal against a criminal conviction in terms of s 8(2)(a)(viii) of the 2011 Act. Collins J delivered a reserved judgment in which he allowed the appeal on the ground that the Tribunal had erred in law in deciding that it was not in the interests of justice for Mr Marteley to be granted legal aid to pursue his appeal against his conviction for murder. The central finding made by Collins J was that the Commissioner would be satisfied of the requirements under s 8(2)(a)(viii) of the 2011 Act if he considered that the grounds of appeal disclosed matters which, if established, would be capable of leading to the appeal being allowed. Effectively, except in “truly hopeless” cases, the Commissioner was not entitled to embark on an examination of the merits of the appeal which, the Judge found, was properly the function of this Court on appeal. As a secondary point, Collins J also held that the Tribunal had erred in failing to take into account the overall fiscal implications of denying Mr Marteley’s application for legal aid. In particular, the Judge took into account the likelihood that an amicus would be appointed by this Court if legal aid were declined. This, the Judge considered, would result in a higher cost to the public purse than granting legal aid. The Tribunal should have taken this factor into account. Both aspects of the High Court judgment are challenged by the Commissioner on this appeal. Collins J granted leave to appeal on 21 October 2013 under s 60 of the 2011 Act on two questions of law: (1) Did I err when I decided that when considering the interests of justice under s 8(1)(c)(ii) of the Legal Services Act 2011, the requirements of s 8(2)(a)(viii) of the Act are satisfied if the grounds of appeal set out by an applicant for criminal legal aid disclose matters which, if established, would be capable of leading to the appeal being allowed? (2) Did I err when I decided that the Commissioner erred when failing to take into account factors set out in paragraphs [55]–[57] of my judgment? The appeal is allowed. The two questions of law identified at [8] of this judgment upon which leave to appeal was granted are each answered in the affirmative. Leave is reserved to apply if there is any further issue about relief. There is no order for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.