Manchester Industrial Holdings Limited v Hazelton

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-457 [2016] NZHC 211

UNDER

the Judicature Amendment Act 1972 and

the Construction Contracts Act 2002

IN THE MATTER OF

an adjudication held pursuant to Part 3
Construction Contracts Act 2002

BETWEEN

MANCHESTER INDUSTRIAL HOLDINGS LIMITED Applicant

AND

ANDREW G HAZELTON First Respondent

BUSSELL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED Second Respondent

Hearing: 26 January 2016

Counsel:

J R Grace for applicant

No appearance for first respondent (abiding the decision) F B Collins for second respondent

Judgment:

18 February 2016

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      This proceeding comprises an application for judicial review alleging errors of law by an adjudicator in a determination under the Construction Contracts Act

2002 (CCA).  The applicant (MIH) owns a block of residential flats in Eva Street, central Wellington, including a penthouse on the top floor of the building.   MIH concluded an oral contract with the respondent (Bussell) to do building work on the property.  The work could be characterised as either part of earthquake strengthening work being undertaken by engineers at the property, or otherwise renovations being

undertaken contemporaneously with earthquake strengthening work.

MANCHESTER INDUSTRIAL HOLDINGS LTD v ANDREW G HAZELTON [2016] NZHC 211 [18 February

2016]

[2]      The contract was not for a fixed price, but rather Bussell was to charge for the time its workers spent working at the premises, plus charges for the materials used. Invoices were to be presented on a monthly basis.

[3]      Bussell undertook physical works between late 2012 and early 2013 and MIH paid  the  first  five  claims  up  to  February  2013  for  a  total  of  some  $103,000. Questions were raised on behalf of MIH and by its architect about the content of Bussell’s invoices after the first five payments.  Those questions were not resolved and on 1 April 2013 Bussell issued a further payment claim for $27,499.05.  MIH questioned the payment claim and its concerns remained unresolved.

[4]      On 6 April 2013, MIH terminated its contract with Bussell and engaged an alternative builder to complete the works contemplated by the original contract with Bussell.

[5]      On  13 April  2013,  Bussell  issued  another  payment  claim  for  a  further

$16,942.64.  The following day, 14 April 2013, MIH emailed Bussell, disputing both of  the April  payment  claims.    That  email  stated  that  Bussell’s  work  had  been defective and asked for particulars of the charges.  Further information was sought including details  of the  areas  of work  to  which  the various  components  of the charges related.  There was no timely response.  However, some 15 months later on

31 July 2014, Bussell issued a payment claim for $40,648.15 plus GST.  It described the  claim  as  relating  to  work  on  the  Eva  Street  project  for  the  period  from

26 November 2012 to 5 April 2013.

[6]      The following day, MIH emailed back to Bussell in the following terms:

Dear Geoff

Your claim for payment is not accepted

As previously discussed this account is disputed

The matters raised in our correspondence to you last year have not been addressed

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Manchester Industrial Holdings Limited v Hazelton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 211
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Manchester Industrial Holdings Limited (MIH) brought an application for judicial review of an adjudicator's decision under the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA) in relation to a payment claim made by Bussell Construction Limited. The dispute concerned an oral contract for building work on a property owned by MIH. The central issue was whether the adjudicator had correctly determined that MIH had failed to submit a valid payment schedule in response to Bussell's payment claim, thus leaving MIH obligated to pay the full amount claimed. MIH argued that the adjudicator had erred in finding that Bussell's payment claim was valid and in concluding that MIH's response did not constitute a payment schedule as required by the CCA.

The High Court examined whether Bussell's payment claim satisfied the statutory requirements under section 20 of the CCA. The Court found that the payment claim met the necessary criteria, despite MIH's contentions that it was insufficiently detailed. The Court also scrutinized MIH's response, specifically an email dated 1 August 2014, to determine if it qualified as a payment schedule under section 21 of the CCA. The adjudicator had ruled that MIH's email did not constitute a valid payment schedule because it failed to indicate the manner in which MIH had calculated the scheduled amount and the reasons for the difference between the scheduled amount and the claimed amount.

The Court agreed with the adjudicator's assessment that MIH's email did not sufficiently detail the required information to qualify as a payment schedule. While the Court acknowledged that the adjudicator's requirement for a payment schedule to be in a single document was an error of law, it concluded that MIH's communications were inadequate regardless. Therefore, the application for judicial review was dismissed, and Bussell was awarded costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established