IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA166/07
[2008] NZCA 18THE QUEEN
v
GLENDA MARY TOPLISS
Hearing:12 February 2008
Court:Glazebrook, John Hansen and Wild JJ
Counsel:D J Taffs for Appellant
S B Edwards for Respondent
Judgment:22 February 2008 at 3pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
The appeal is dismissed.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Wild J)
[1] Of the four grounds initially advanced in the notice, this appeal against conviction reduced to two:
(a)Incompetence on the part of trial counsel.
(b)The prolixity of counts and the trial Judge’s directions about them.
[2] The appellant was convicted following trial before Judge Saunders and a jury in the District Court at Greymouth over 10 days in February 2007. She had faced 107 counts of fraud.
[3] The charges arose out of the appellant’s employment as accounts manager for a Greymouth engineering company. The Crown case was that the appellant had fraudulently overpaid herself and her husband.
[4] Affidavits in support of the appeal were filed by the appellant and by Mr Topliss. The Crown filed an affidavit by trial counsel, Mr Green. Messrs Topliss and Green were cross-examined on their affidavits. The appellant did not file an affidavit in reply to that of Mr Green. She was not required for cross-examination on the one affidavit she did file (sworn on 22 July 2007), and chose not to avail herself of the opportunity to give evidence by video, an arrangement offered as she was unable for medical reasons to travel to Wellington.
[5] At the start of his submissions, Mr Taffs conceded that he could not pursue the first ground of appeal, insofar as it alleged that Mr Green had not followed the appellant’s instructions. There was uncontested evidence from Mr Green that he had followed the appellant’s instructions, in particular as to the disclosure which should be requested before the trial. Mr Topliss, in turn, accepted he was not present when some of those instructions were given.
[6] Mr Taffs did pursue, albeit faintly, a submission that Mr Green had been incompetent in not pursuing disclosure of the records of the appellant’s use of her computer at the company, in particular the log-on and log-off dates and times. He contended that this may have enabled Mr Green to challenge the evidence given by the company’s two directors that they had authorised the fraudulent payments made by the appellant.
[7] It seemed to us that this line of questioning would have involved a real risk of demonstrating to the jury that the appellant had made the fraudulent payments without the directors’ authority. That was because she had in fact paid the company’s wages each Tuesday night using, without authority, one of the director’s computer access codes. Both directors were under the mistaken belief that the wages had only been paid following their authorisation each Wednesday morning. Mr Green’s appreciation of that risk was the very reason he counselled the appellant against pursuing the computer evidence, advice he said the appellant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NZCA 18
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the first ground of appeal, which alleged incompetence on the part of the trial counsel, Mr Green. The appellant argued that Mr Green had failed to follow her instructions and did not pursue certain disclosure requests, which could have challenged the evidence of the company’s two directors that they had authorised the fraudulent payments made by the appellant. However, the court found that there was uncontested evidence from Mr Green that he had followed the appellant’s instructions. Furthermore, the court concluded that the line of questioning suggested by the appellant would have involved a real risk of demonstrating to the jury that she had made the fraudulent payments without the directors’ authority. The court was satisfied that the other disclosure sought was irrelevant, as the Crown did not allege fraud on the appellant’s part in paying Mr Topliss wages for days which he had not in fact worked after 16 March 2003. The court found that there was nothing in the trial counsel competence point.
The court then turned to the second ground of appeal, which was the prolixity of the counts and the trial Judge’s directions about them. The appellant argued that the Judge had directed the jury based on the “groupings” of counts, which invited the jury to take a “job lot” approach. However, the court rejected this submission and found that the Judge’s directions were clear, helpful, and did not detract from his direction to the jury that they needed to consider the evidence individually for each count, in arriving at their verdicts. The court also found that the Judge’s requirement for pagination was no more than the Judge insisting that the documentary evidence provided to the jury was properly managed.
As neither of the points pursued on appeal succeeded, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant, who was granted bail pending the outcome of this appeal, is to resume the sentence of imprisonment imposed on her, in respect of which she has been granted home detention. The Crown undertook to ensure that the appropriate authorities would advise the appellant of the arrangements for the resumption of home detention.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.