IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY
CIV-2011-442-000119
BETWEEN DB BREWERIES LIMITED Plaintiff
ANDBARRY JOHN MCCANN Defendant
Hearing: 24 August 2011
Counsel: A Shakespeare for Plaintiff
Defendant appears In Person
Judgment: 20 September 2011
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS
[1] The plaintiff (DB) has applied for summary judgment against the defendant (Mr McCann) in the sum of $63,576.57. The claim comprises a sum owing to DB by Irish Hospitality Limited, now in liquidation, on current account for liquor supplied to the company’s bar and restaurant “House of Ales”, together with interest, costs on a solicitor client basis, and disbursements. Mr McCann is the guarantor of the indebtedness of Irish Hospitality Limited to DB. Under the terms of the guarantee he also agreed to pay interest at the base commercial lending rate charged by DB’s primary banker, plus 5 percent – in this case 15.8 percent. He also agreed to pay costs incurred in recovery of sums owing, on the above basis.
[2] The defendant does not deny the existence or validity of the guarantee, nor the quantum of the claim. He maintains, however, that he has three defences to the claim:
(a) Estoppel, based on an alleged promise by the plaintiff that it would not pursue him for the shortfall, a promise on which he relied to his
detriment.
DB BREWERIES LIMITED V BARRY JOHN MCCANN HC NEL CIV-2011-442-000119 20 September 2011
(b)A contract with DB based on the same promise, in respect of which Mr McCann says he provided consideration including assistance to achieve an optimum sale price for the business.
(c) Conduct by the plaintiff preventing it enforcing the guarantee, that conduct resulting in a reduction of $15,000 in a sale price which could otherwise have been achieved, and the incurring of an additional
$38,000 in liquidator’s fees, thereby leaving a shortfall of $53,000 which is a sum exceeding the entire debt of Irish Hospitality Limited at the time of sale. Although well short of the sum now claimed, interest would not have been incurred, nor costs, so Mr McCann’s liability would have been extinguished.
Principles of summary judgment
[3] Before the Court can enter summary judgment for a plaintiff against a defendant, the plaintiff must satisfy the Court that the defendant does not have a defence to the claim (r.12.2 of the High Court Rules). The onus is on the plaintiff to satisfy the Court. However, although the evidentiary burden remains throughout with the plaintiff, it is for a defendant to introduce sufficient evidence to demonstrate
the existence of a tenable defence (Pemberton v Chappell;[1] Auckett v Falvey[2]).
[1] [1987] 1 NZLR 1
[2] HC Wellington CP296/86, 20 August 1986, Eichelbaum J
[4] The Court will generally refrain from attempting to resolve genuine conflicts of evidence or to assess the credibility of the statements made by deponents in affidavits. As noted by Greig J in A-G v Rakiura Holdings Ltd:[3]
[3] (1986) 1 PRNZ 12 at p 14
In a matter…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read DB Breweries Limited v McCann HC Nelson CIV-2011-442-000119 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NZHC 1678
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court noted that for summary judgment to be granted, DB must demonstrate that McCann has no defence. The court would not resolve genuine conflicts of evidence or assess the credibility of affidavits. DB argued that the liquidator, Rhys Cain, had authority to communicate DB's position, but there was conflicting evidence on whether a $5,000 shortfall was mentioned. This conflict could not be resolved based on the affidavits alone.
Regarding the estoppel defence, the court found it arguable that McCann relied on DB's promise not to pursue him for the shortfall if he cooperated with the liquidation. Although DB argued that McCann's detriment was limited to lost time, the court found that the detriment might be more substantial if the promise was established. The court could not eliminate the possibility that equity would prevent DB from resiling from its promise.
As the court found an arguable defence of estoppel, it declined DB's application for summary judgment. The court also declined to address the other defences. McCann was awarded costs on a 2B basis with disbursements fixed by the Registrar.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi