Jojaro Investments Ltd v ASB Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV 2011-441-398 [2012] NZHC 980

BETWEEN  JOJARO INVESTMENTS LIMITED First Plaintiff

ANDJOHN RICHARD TOWNSEND GIFFORD AND SUELLEN GIFFORD Second & Third Plaintiffs

ANDROBERT ELVIDGE AND ELIZABETH ANN ELVIDGE

Fourth & Fifth Plaintiffs

ANDASB BANK LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         8-9 December 2011

Counsel:         M T Scholtens QC with J L W Wass for Plaintiffs

M J Tingey with N F D Moffatt for Defendant

Judgment:      10 May 2012

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS

Introduction

[1]      A senior insurance company employee steals capital the company has set aside to maintain its credit rating.  He does this by transferring the capital into the principal trading account maintained by the company at the ASB Bank in Napier. Then he draws cheques on that account.  Over a period of 20 months, he embezzles nearly $4 million.  No one notices.  Not the directors, not the auditors, and not the bank.

[2]      The fraud ruins the shareholders of the insurance company.   They cannot afford to replenish the stolen capital.  So they sell their shares to a third party for a

JOJARO INVESTMENTS LIMITED v ASB BANK LIMITED HC NAP CIV 2011-441-398 [10 May 2012]

nominal consideration.   The new owner will recapitalise the business.   Most importantly, it will keep the employees in work.  In due course the company, newly owned, sues the auditors and former directors.1   That case is settled.  The company does not sue the bank.  There is an issue over whether the fraudster was entitled to operate the trading account.  But the new owners are not interested in pursuing that claim.

[3]      Now  the  former  shareholders  say  the  bank  is  liable  to  them,  as  the shareholders, funders and indirect guarantors of the company.  They say there is an implied term in the agreements they have with the bank (contracts of loan and guarantee) and a duty of care (the content of which is substantially the same) that the bank not permit the fraudster to operate the trading account in breach of the mandate given by the company.

[4]      The bank applies to strike out those claims against it.  Alternatively it seeks summary judgment at this early stage of the case.  Failing all that it seeks security for its costs.  That is because, as a result of the fraud, the plaintiffs now have very little money.

Background

[5]      The Gifford and  Elvidge families  had  been  banking with  the ASB bank (bank) since the early 1990s.   Messrs Elvidge and Gifford had legal backgrounds. They branched out into commerce.  Together they owned and directed a company called CRN Group.  It administered claims and repairs for self-insuring vehicle fleet owners.   That experience led Messrs Gifford and Elvidge to conceive and start a specialist vehicle insurance company – Pioneer Insurance Company Limited (Pioneer).   In 2002 they incorporated Pioneer.   Jojaro, a company owned and controlled by the Gifford and Elvidge families, had been incorporated in 2000.

[6]      Pioneer needed a substantial capital injection.  Much of its capital had to be maintained in a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jojaro Investments Ltd v ASB Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 980
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a claim by the former shareholders of Pioneer Insurance Company Limited against ASB Bank Limited. The shareholders alleged that the bank was liable to them for the fraudulent actions of Blair Fitzsimons, who embezzled nearly $4 million from Pioneer’s accounts over a period of 20 months. The shareholders brought claims in both contract and tort, alleging that the bank had breached an implied term of the loan agreements and guarantees, and that it had failed to exercise reasonable care in operating Pioneer’s accounts. The bank sought to have the claims struck out or alternatively, for summary judgment to be granted in its favour. The court found that the proposed implied term in the loan agreements and guarantees was not reasonably arguable. The court also found that the duty of care contended for by the plaintiffs was unsustainable as a matter of law, and that the plaintiffs’ claims were not reasonably arguable. Accordingly, the plaintiffs’ claims were struck out, and the bank was awarded costs on a category 2 band B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established