JNJ Holdings Ltd v Kent Sing Trading Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-000099

[2017] NZHC 3274

BETWEEN  JNJ HOLDINGS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND  KENT SING TRADING COMPANY

LIMITED

First Defendant

QUOC THAI

Second Defendant

LE QUAN WU
Third Defendant

Hearing:                   13 to 17 February 2017

10 April 2017

3 to 7 July 2017

Appearances:           Paul Dalkie for the Plaintiff

Michael Black for the Defendants

Judgment:                21 December 2017

JUDGMENT OF MOORE J

This judgment was delivered by me on 21 December 2017 at 12:00 pm
pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

JNJ HOLDINGS LIMITED v KENT SING TRADING COMPANY LIMITED & ORS [2017] NZHC 3274 [21 December 2017]

Contents

Paragraph

Number

Introduction............................................................................................................ [1]

Factual background............................................................................................... [5]

The pleadings........................................................................................................ [26]

Burden of proof..................................................................................................... [42]

The parties to the contract – a privity issue....................................................... [44]

Did JNJ validly cancel the contract?.................................................................. [53]

Was Kent Sing in breach of the lease at the time JNJ issued its notice? ...................................................................................................

(a)      Rent..................................................................................................... [57]

(b)     Operating expenses ...........................................................................  [61]

(c)      Consumables...................................................................................... [69]

(d)            Marketing and promotion fund...................................................................................... [71]
Did the notice dated 10 June 2014 comply with the relevant provisions of the

PLA? ...................................................................................................

(a)      Inconsistency with invoices ..............................................................  [73]

(b)     “With” versus “within”....................................................................... [74]

(c)      Other expenses not due and payable................................................... [78]

Did JNJ re-enter the premises prematurely?... ................................................................................................... [85]

Matters raised in defence – my approach to the factual analysis.................... [92]

Alleged breaches

Water leaks...... ................................................................................................... [95]
Noxioussmells ................................................................................................... [156]

Signage ............................................................................................................ [184]

Automatic doors ............................................................................................. [238]

Lessor’s works ................................................................................................... [252]

(a)      Clause 5............................................................................................. [253]

(b)     Clause 6............................................................................................. [264]

Roof and exterior. ................................................................................................... [268]

Commonareas  ................................................................................................ [272]

Utilities ................................................................................................... [280]

Failure to deliver-up; “the white sheet”... ................................................................................................... [285]

(a)      Did the white sheet screen off the lower basement?......................... [291]

(b)     Did the white sheet amount to a landlord acquiescence?.................. [300]

Alleged breaches of terms.................................................................................. [305]

Quiet enjoyment

Pleadings..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... [306]
Legal principles ........................................................................................................... [312] Analysis ...........................................................................................................

(a)    Whether the water leaks and the smells, individually or collectively

breach the landlord’s covenant of quiet enjoyment?......................... [318]

Business efficacy

Pleadings   [325]

Legal principles... ........................................................................................................... [329]

Analysis. ........................................................................................................... [336]

(a)      Was fitness for purpose an implied term?.......................................... [337]

(b)     Does the “as is” term deny relief?..................................................... [340]
Derogation from grant

Pleadings   [344]

Legal principles... ........................................................................................................... [345]

Analysis. ........................................................................................................... [350]

Penalty interest..................................................................................................... [355]

The submissions for Kent Sing. ........................................................................................................... [357]

Were the payments for rent and other expenses due and payable?. ........................................................................................................... [358]

Is JNJ required to prove loss?.. ........................................................................................................... [359]

Is cl 3.10 an unenforceable penalty?.. ........................................................................................................... [365]

What can the plaintiff claim for?

Unpaid rent..... ........................................................................................................... [376]
Unpaid operating expenses, unpaid rates and wash-up of operating

expenses for the year ending 31 March 2014.... ........................................................................................................... [377]

Unpaid utility charges. ........................................................................................................... [378]

Agency fees ........................................................................................................... [379]

Fit-out costs.. ........................................................................................................... [380]

Loss of future rent. ........................................................................................................... [381]

Legal costs associated with enforcement of rates under lease.... ........................................................................................................... [384]

Conclusion on plaintiff’s claim........................................................................... [385]

The counterclaim – did the defendants validly cancel the contract?.............. [389]

In any event, are the defendants entitled to any damages?

Pleadings  

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JNJ Holdings Ltd v Kent Sing Trading Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 3274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JNJ Holdings Limited (JNJ) is the registered proprietor of a commercial building in Auckland, known as The Metro Centre. Kent Sing Trading Company Limited (Kent Sing) is a wholesale company, which imports a wide variety of goods from Asia and sells them to local retailers. Kent Sing established General Goods Limited to operate a new retail venture out of leased premises in the Centre. The dispute arose from the operation of the lease for the retail premises. The lease was terminated by JNJ on the basis that Kent Sing had failed to pay outstanding rent and operating expenses. Kent Sing claims the lease was terminated because of various breaches of the lease by JNJ. Kent Sing sought damages and other relief for loss of business and stock damage. The Court found that JNJ had validly cancelled the lease for non-payment of rent. The Court found that Kent Sing was not justified in vacating the premises because of breaches of the lease by JNJ. The Court found that Kent Sing was not entitled to damages because the business model it had established was flawed and not viable. The Court found for JNJ and awarded damages in the amount of $215,048.42 plus interest.