IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2015-404-000099
[2017] NZHC 3274
BETWEEN JNJ HOLDINGS LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND KENT SING TRADING COMPANY
LIMITED
First Defendant
QUOC THAI
Second Defendant
LE QUAN WU
Third Defendant
Hearing: 13 to 17 February 2017
10 April 2017
3 to 7 July 2017
Appearances: Paul Dalkie for the Plaintiff
Michael Black for the Defendants
Judgment: 21 December 2017
JUDGMENT OF MOORE J
This judgment was delivered by me on 21 December 2017 at 12:00 pm
pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/ Deputy Registrar
Date:
JNJ HOLDINGS LIMITED v KENT SING TRADING COMPANY LIMITED & ORS [2017] NZHC 3274 [21 December 2017]
Contents
Paragraph
Number
Introduction............................................................................................................ [1]
Factual background............................................................................................... [5]
The pleadings........................................................................................................ [26]
Burden of proof..................................................................................................... [42]
The parties to the contract – a privity issue....................................................... [44]
Did JNJ validly cancel the contract?.................................................................. [53]
Was Kent Sing in breach of the lease at the time JNJ issued its notice? ...................................................................................................
(a) Rent..................................................................................................... [57]
(b) Operating expenses ........................................................................... [61]
(c) Consumables...................................................................................... [69]
(d) Marketing and promotion fund...................................................................................... [71]
Did the notice dated 10 June 2014 comply with the relevant provisions of the
PLA? ...................................................................................................
(a) Inconsistency with invoices .............................................................. [73]
(b) “With” versus “within”....................................................................... [74]
(c) Other expenses not due and payable................................................... [78]
Did JNJ re-enter the premises prematurely?... ................................................................................................... [85]
Matters raised in defence – my approach to the factual analysis.................... [92]
Alleged breaches
Water leaks...... ................................................................................................... [95]
Noxioussmells ................................................................................................... [156]
Signage ............................................................................................................ [184]
Automatic doors ............................................................................................. [238]
Lessor’s works ................................................................................................... [252]
(a) Clause 5............................................................................................. [253]
(b) Clause 6............................................................................................. [264]
Roof and exterior. ................................................................................................... [268]
Commonareas ................................................................................................ [272]
Utilities ................................................................................................... [280]
Failure to deliver-up; “the white sheet”... ................................................................................................... [285]
(a) Did the white sheet screen off the lower basement?......................... [291]
(b) Did the white sheet amount to a landlord acquiescence?.................. [300]
Alleged breaches of terms.................................................................................. [305]
Quiet enjoyment
Pleadings..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... [306]
Legal principles ........................................................................................................... [312] Analysis ...........................................................................................................
(a) Whether the water leaks and the smells, individually or collectively
breach the landlord’s covenant of quiet enjoyment?......................... [318]
Business efficacy
Pleadings [325]
Legal principles... ........................................................................................................... [329]
Analysis. ........................................................................................................... [336]
(a) Was fitness for purpose an implied term?.......................................... [337]
(b) Does the “as is” term deny relief?..................................................... [340]
Derogation from grantPleadings [344]
Legal principles... ........................................................................................................... [345]
Analysis. ........................................................................................................... [350]
Penalty interest..................................................................................................... [355]
The submissions for Kent Sing. ........................................................................................................... [357]
Were the payments for rent and other expenses due and payable?. ........................................................................................................... [358]
Is JNJ required to prove loss?.. ........................................................................................................... [359]
Is cl 3.10 an unenforceable penalty?.. ........................................................................................................... [365]
What can the plaintiff claim for?
Unpaid rent..... ........................................................................................................... [376]
Unpaid operating expenses, unpaid rates and wash-up of operating
expenses for the year ending 31 March 2014.... ........................................................................................................... [377]
Unpaid utility charges. ........................................................................................................... [378]
Agency fees ........................................................................................................... [379]
Fit-out costs.. ........................................................................................................... [380]
Loss of future rent. ........................................................................................................... [381]
Legal costs associated with enforcement of rates under lease.... ........................................................................................................... [384]
Conclusion on plaintiff’s claim........................................................................... [385]
The counterclaim – did the defendants validly cancel the contract?.............. [389]
In any event, are the defendants entitled to any damages?
Pleadings
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JNJ Holdings Ltd v Kent Sing Trading Co Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 3274
- Decision Date